The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



They come bearing half-truths 22

Posted on September 09, 2012 by

The CBI Director-General, John Cridland, came north this week to tell Scotland we shouldn’t be independent. He has every right to do so. But what he has no right to do is use half-truths as the basis for his scaremongering.

I hear that Mr Cridland told the CBI Annual Dinner in Glasgow on Thursday night that the “immediate effects [of independence] would be profound, and in the short term costly. When Slovakia separated from the Czech Republic, it cost the country four per cent of its GDP in the following year.” But what Mr Cridland won’t tell us is what happened next.

Read the rest of this entry →

The arc of recovery 101

Posted on September 08, 2012 by

We’re thrilled to welcome to the blog the YesScotland campaign’s estimable post-graduate European law expert Stephen Noon, with some intriguing stats.

The International Monetary Fund has just published its latest statistics for the relative wealth per head of different countries. And, for Iceland, Ireland, Norway and the UK, they paint a fascinating picture.

The figures are based on “purchasing power parity”, which allows us to make a fair comparison between the different countries, and they show that Norway, Ireland and Iceland are all wealthier per head than the UK. Indeed, at no point in the financial crisis did any of the countries dip below the UK in this IMF wealth league table.

If we take a look at 2010, when the full impact of the crisis was being felt, the wealth per head for each country, in current international dollars, was:

Norway     $52,165
Ireland      $39,492
Iceland     $36,535
UK           $35,344

The UK was $1,192 behind the ‘poorest’ of the three, Iceland, at this point. If we fast-forward to the current year, 2012, the IMF estimates are:

Norway     $54,479
Ireland      $40,443
Iceland     $39,083
UK           $36,605

This year, the average UK citizen is now forecast by the IMF to be $2,478 poorer than his equivalent in ‘insolvent’ Iceland. And putting the IMF’s crystal ball to full use, let’s take a look at referendum year, 2014. What will be the relative strengths of the four nations by then? Won’t being a powerhouse big country have propelled the United Kingdom above lowly Iceland at least?

Norway    $57,217
Ireland     $44,283
Iceland    $41,647
UK          $38,935

It seems not. In 2014, the UK won’t even reach the level of GDP per capita that Iceland enjoyed in 2012. The wealth gap between the two countries will have increased, once again, to $2,712 per person.

Similarly, for Ireland, 2010 saw the Irish $4,148 ahead of the UK in wealth per head, and according to the IMF that Irish advantage will increase to $5,348 in 2014.

And finally, Norway’s $16,821 advantage per person in 2010 is forecast to become $18,727 by 2012 – in other words, just short of 50% wealthier than the UK.

It’s not quite what you’d expect from listening to the rhetoric of the anti-independence parties. Perhaps they should actually go to Iceland, or Ireland or Norway – small, independent nations which, it seems, now form an arc of faster recovery.

.

A version of this post appeared previously on SNmr.

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,671 Posts, 1,202,922 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James on The Long Unravelling: “Nothing false about it. Read it again.Nov 22, 17:40
    • Mark Beggan on Telling the truth by mistake: “Are you sure about the GRC’s? Nothings new!Nov 22, 17:38
    • Nae Need! on Telling the truth by mistake: “I’m so glad I grew up/was schooled in the 70s/80s. Just imagine being a wean the now . . .…Nov 22, 17:27
    • Nae Need! on Telling the truth by mistake: “I picked up on that too. Fucking lunatics the lot of them.Nov 22, 16:53
    • Cynicus on Telling the truth by mistake: “Fearghas « Reflecting on why Children in Need only suspended donations to LGBT Youth Scotland in May, the newspaper said: “It…Nov 22, 16:22
    • Cynicus on Telling the truth by mistake: “Do you mean the third Synod of Macon when the learned divines denied women had souls? Mind you, they had…Nov 22, 16:09
    • Republicofscotland on Telling the truth by mistake: “This is exactly why we need to vote these b*stards out of office – they’ve f*cked-up the country up big-time,…Nov 22, 16:05
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Telling the truth by mistake: “MSP slams pro-trans group’s primary school scheme « LGBT Youth Scotland should not be allowed to push its trans agenda in…Nov 22, 15:52
    • James on The Long Unravelling: “McTernan lol wasn’t he the one who welched on the Rev’s bet? And gets *everything* wrong? Lower than a snake’s…Nov 22, 15:35
    • Zander Tait on The Long Unravelling: “We’re both wrong Humpster. It’s Free Thinkers 48 (not 42) and Dependence Monkeys 52 (not 58) You’re numbers in brackets.…Nov 22, 15:28
    • James on The Long Unravelling: “Clown looking for a circus.Nov 22, 15:21
    • Campbell Clansman on The Long Unravelling: “The latest poll is Nov. 20th, Survation. And the results are 42% Indy, 58% not. You might be surprised to…Nov 22, 15:07
    • Frank Gillougley on Telling the truth by mistake: “With apologies to Tom Leonard (for borrowing his spelling) and to Keats. The point I’d like to make is that…Nov 22, 15:06
    • Mark Beggan on Telling the truth by mistake: “Is this a translation from the council of Macon.Nov 22, 14:55
    • Zander Tait on The Long Unravelling: “I did read it Camster. It states in answer to the question, “should Scotland be an Independent country?” The answer…Nov 22, 14:48
    • Campbell Clansman on The Long Unravelling: “The actual latest poll (Survation) showed: 34% for Indy in the EU 8% for Indy outside the EU Total: 42%…Nov 22, 14:26
    • moixx on Telling the truth by mistake: “Email from For Women Scotland: “We still have a way to go to meet our fundraising target to cover the…Nov 22, 14:22
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Long Unravelling: ““Getting back to the article ‘The Long Unravelling’ the question is where are the ‘SNP Whistleblowers’.” Where do you think…Nov 22, 14:21
    • rogueslr on Telling the truth by mistake: “So an adult human female is really just a woman without a GRC? Well that makes life simple!Nov 22, 14:20
    • Campbell Clansman on Telling the truth by mistake: “The SNP’s “submission” is 40 pages long. In what alternate reality does it take 40 pages to “define” what a…Nov 22, 14:16
    • Confused on The Long Unravelling: “our enemies, the people who run this shithole, are fucking rats, all of them, since forever; never forget it  https://archive.ph/8SUqn…Nov 22, 14:12
    • Shug on The Long Unravelling: “They need to be winning. If they cant win when labor has withdrawn the heating allowance and the middle east…Nov 22, 14:01
    • Zander Tait on The Long Unravelling: “And the last 3 polls on Scottish Independence show wins for YES. Nae luck Dumpster.Nov 22, 14:00
    • Sven on Telling the truth by mistake: “Well, I’m really glad they cleared that up for us.Nov 22, 13:37
    • Karen on Telling the truth by mistake: “So a man with a self id’d £5 bit of paper is a “woman”, according to them. And a woman…Nov 22, 13:30
    • sarah on Telling the truth by mistake: “I didn’t get it until your response! 🙂Nov 22, 13:30
    • Alison on Telling the truth by mistake: “For just a wee ‘bit of admin’ this sure has created an awful lot of words. And whilst some of…Nov 22, 13:21
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on Telling the truth by mistake: “(You’re fired – Ed)Nov 22, 13:15
    • Graham on Telling the truth by mistake: “Nah that’s just what they call a mobile phone these days.Nov 22, 13:07
    • Muscleguy on Telling the truth by mistake: “Indeed the S35 order determined that such is not within ScotGov’s competence. It treads on Reserved matters as they well…Nov 22, 12:58
  • A tall tale



↑ Top