The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Sports: sitter sclaffed

Posted on January 14, 2013 by

In the news business, there are some advantages to being second to a story. So when Scotsman journalists were digesting the contents of an exclusive splash in their rival at the opposite end of the M8 this morning, they at least had the opportunity to learn from its mistakes with the benefit of a little distance and time.

By simply avoiding the amateurish, widely-mocked spin of the Herald’s reporting of its own poll, the ailing Johnston Press paper could have scored itself an easy open goal by presenting the facts more truthfully and even-handedly, enabling it to at a stroke look like the more fair and balanced voice in the Scottish “quality” media.

Or, of course, it could shank the golden opportunity hideously and embarrassingly wide. Do we even need to finish this article, or can we go and have a sandwich?

.

15 to “Sports: sitter sclaffed”

  1. Luigi says:

    The Herald and the Scotsman: two once great Scottish newspapers, now reduced, sadly, to an independence stalling role as BritNat propaganda comics. I look forward to their final extinction.
     

    Reply
  2. scottish_skier says:

    According to the vast majority of recent polls, less than half of Scots are prepared to vote for the union tomorrow (yes, tomorrow morning, you need to decide right now). That’s all you need to know at the moment.

    Enjoy your sandwich. 

    Reply
  3. Luigi says:

    It is going to be interesting this year, watching increasingly desperate attempts by the MSM to spin away the inevitable, upward trend towards a yes vote in 2014. It will probably take the form of: SWING TO INDEPENDENCE WEAKER THAN EXPECTED, or: SALMOND FAILS TO GAIN ENOUGH GROUND BEFORE THE REFERENDUM, or UNDECIDEDS LIKELY TO VOTE NO. Meanwhile, in the real world, the no vote continues to plummet.

    Reply
  4. martyn says:

    did you expect anything less from them (cringe even thinking about their name and how it completely misrepresents itself.)

    Reply
  5. Macart says:

    What are you having on your sandwich? Like a nice BLT masel’.

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      “What are you having on your sandwich? Like a nice BLT masel’.”

      Warburtons Sandwich Thin with mature cheddar, no spread. Lovely. Have been known to add a wee daud of sweet chilli sauce, though.

      Reply
  6. Rabb says:

    I had some tattie and leek soup. It was lovely with a wee bit of bread 🙂

    Sorry Rev, what were you saying about polls?

    Reply
  7. Macart says:

    @Rev

    Mmmmmm, nice. 🙂

    Lost the will to check out the Scotsman page. However, the canteen beckons. 

    Reply
  8. Dcanmore says:

    Things are not working out at Johnston Press. After a two-phased project of (1) restructuring and refinancing the company, and (2) refurbishing and relaunching titles in print and more specifically online over the past 12 months, the company’s shares are trading at only 12p as of now. The share price remained stagnant at 14p over December 2012, having started that year at 15p per share, but have fallen backwards to their current level.

    I’ll give JP/Scotsman 6 months then toast. 

    Reply
  9. Doug Daniel says:

    What I’d like to know is, how low does the “no” vote have to drop in the polls before the media stop telling us “two thirds” of the population support the union?

    Reply
  10. Oldnat says:

    Rev

    Unless things have changed recently, TNS-BMRB political polls aren’t commissioned by the Herald. TNS continued the System Three practice of giving them free to the Herald, to publicise their firm. 

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      “Unless things have changed recently, TNS-BMRB political polls aren’t commissioned by the Herald. TNS continued the System Three practice of giving them free to the Herald, to publicise their firm.”

      Fair enough. Not sure it materially changes anything, but will phrase more carefully in future.

      Reply
  11. Cruachan says:

    Not sure what the listening figures are for Good Morning Scotland, but they gleefully reported the “Yes vote poll shocker” story at least four times before I left for work this morning.  Depsite continuing falls in circulation, the pro-Union press can always rely on their friends at Pacific Quay to repeat the Newspaper headlines to their listeners.

    Reply
  12. Dave Smith says:

    That place needs razed. Pacific Quay, I mean.

    Reply
  13. Oldnat says:

    Rev

    Agreed – no significant change – but pedants rule! 

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,756 Posts, 1,217,813 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Peter Campbell on Some Attention For James: “To be fair, as far as the SNP goes, Gordon has definitely seen the light.May 15, 19:22
    • agent x on Some Attention For James: “Take it to a private room!May 15, 18:10
    • keaton on Some Attention For James: “I see he’s accepted. I’m looking forward to the debateMay 15, 18:01
    • Morgatron on Some Attention For James: “He’s not been the same since he lost the Stars in Your Eyes gig. Poor soul.May 15, 17:23
    • 100%Yes on Some Attention For James: “I said it yesterday and I’ll say it again today, Salmond said if Scotland wins Independence there wouldn’t be any…May 15, 16:51
    • Mark Beggan on Some Attention For James: “Yer teas oot Kelly!May 15, 16:22
    • Mr Boyce N Franks on The Undertaker: “I’m an indy supporter and tried to watch that on Sunday but I had to switch off. It took Swinney…May 15, 16:21
    • aLurker on Some Attention For James: “@Derek Spence Thanks for that reminder. I had almost forgotten, it is all slipping away in to the past now,…May 15, 16:03
    • Effijy on Some Attention For James: “Does Kelly have a family to look after him? This chap needs some form of psychiatric support and I think…May 15, 15:58
    • Jon Drummond on Some Attention For James: “Dan there, clearly still captivated by the NuSNP cult. What a nobskin.May 15, 15:34
    • Xaracen on The Blindness Of Hatred: “@Aidan; Firstly, Scotland’s sovereignty was owned by its people, and it still is. It was not owned by its monarch…May 15, 15:10
    • Gav on Some Attention For James: “I suggest Robin Mcalpine to refMay 15, 14:32
    • Skip_NC on Some Attention For James: “I believe Murdo Fraser was first on the Conservative list for Mid-Scotland and Fife, so he owes his position to…May 15, 14:12
    • factchecker on The Undertaker: “Respecting the wishes of the sovereign wishes of the people of Scotland would require a majority of votes, not a…May 15, 13:58
    • Graf Midgehunter on Some Attention For James: “James is a convert, or better reconverted ideologue to a dead and dying SNP, whose only reason to exist is…May 15, 13:52
    • Vestas on Some Attention For James: “He’s a sad narcissistic little man with an penchant for conspiracy theories – his own. First it was the SNP…May 15, 13:32
    • Casper1066 on Some Attention For James: “You having a quiet day………May 15, 13:29
    • Lorn on Some Attention For James: “He just doesn’t get it. We have tried this before and the Unionists won seats on the List. It really…May 15, 13:20
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on Some Attention For James: “I don’t see any chains holding you down, Dan. But by all means offer your constructive suggestions, because as I’ve…May 15, 13:16
    • Dan on Some Attention For James: “Sigh…The Epic Battle of the Dung Beetles continues… FFS, is hurling virtual internet shit at each other really the most…May 15, 13:07
    • Scott on Some Attention For James: “I just read James Kelly’s latest post and honestly, I’m starting to think the guy needs a carer. He’s quoting…May 15, 12:50
    • Derek Spence on Some Attention For James: “Good move. That’s sounds like a re run of the Lorraine Mann question that stumped George Robertson pre Devo Ref.May 15, 12:50
    • Craig on Some Attention For James: “I agree. The next independence voting question should read 1) Do you want Scotland to be an independent country? 2)…May 15, 12:41
    • Peter Campbell on Some Attention For James: “Oh, make it a podcast, please! You can get someone to referee, to ensure it is kept civil.May 15, 12:38
    • Craig on Some Attention For James: “Here is a question for you James. Who name is on the Constituency and who is on the List for…May 15, 12:34
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on Some Attention For James: “Scot Goes Plop.May 15, 12:17
    • Geoff Anderson on Some Attention For James: “Nobody reads James Kelley now. He has flipped. Indy is dead and the SNP and Greens are quite happy to…May 15, 12:12
    • stonefree on Some Attention For James: “Who is James Kelly ? Is he the one on Bella ?May 15, 12:05
    • Willie on The Undertaker: “That’s what ‘ political organisation professionals ‘ do. Like the self description. That’s absolutely genuine and gives an insight into…May 15, 11:40
    • ScottieDog on The Undertaker: “Robert Knight is spot on here. In the current political climate, England is more likely to end the union than…May 15, 11:30
  • A tall tale



↑ Top