The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Scotsman deploys threat multiplier

Posted on November 21, 2011 by

As a newspaper, The Scotsman is under absolutely no obligation to report the news impartially (a fact frequently misunderstood by a great many people). But it's becoming less and less subtle in its distortions of the truth the further we get into the SNP majority administration. One of its big politics stories today is a case in point. As a reader of Wings over Scotland you are by definition a normal, well-adjusted person, so how would you interpret the following headline?

"Swinney demands £20bn to secure the economy"

Since John Swinney is an MSP with a remit which covers only the devolved Scottish Government, naturally you'd assume he was demanding this £20bn for Scotland, right? Particularly as the story opens with this sentence:

"Finance secretary John Swinney has demanded billions of pounds from the UK government for major building projects in Scotland"

Even for the most ardent nationalist it sounds an outrageous demand, even in less austere times than these. £20bn is around two-thirds of the Scottish Government's entire annual block grant, and would pay for every conceivable major infrastructure project in Scotland – finishing the Edinburgh trams and the Edinburgh and Glasgow airport rail links, dualling the entire A9, building the new Forth road crossing, completing the Borders railway, implementing the Beauly-Denny power line and opening the carbon-capture plant at Longannet – with a good £10bn still left over.

But with readers duly inflamed, the next paragraph quietly reveals the truth. Swinney wants the Chancellor to spend £20bn on capital investment projects in the whole of the UK, with just a tenth of that money coming to Scotland. He's asking for £2bn, not £20bn, and – we find out another nine paragraphs later – that £2bn would be spread over three years, amounting to a somewhat more modest £0.67bn a year for Scotland, set against the UK government's total annual Scottish spending of £53bn.

The arguments for extra capital investment to drive growth, create employment in the construction sector and avoid a double-dip recession are economically sound, but that's another debate entirely. The Finance Secretary has in fact asked for approximately one-thirtieth of what the Scotsman's highly-misleading headline implies. It's hard to see that misrepresentation as an accidental one.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

2 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
JRTomlin

You aren't quite right or only partially right about The Scotsman's responsibilities. They do have a responsibility to report the news truthfully and not to misrepresent it. They regularly break this remit.
That does not mean that they have to be unbiased as an organisation and all newspapers have an admitted and advertised bias. They support a certain political opinion and are expected to do so editorially.
That does not make it acceptable to mis-report and distort news stories in an attempt to support that bias.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,670 Posts, 1,202,848 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Mia on The Long Unravelling: “An much more distressing thought for me is that, if those disgusting individuals with absolute no principles, no morals, no…Nov 22, 10:39
    • Hatey McHateface on The Long Unravelling: ““as long as those parasites who claim to represent us can keep their salaries, pensions and access to subsidised bars,…Nov 22, 10:38
    • Republicofscotland on The Long Unravelling: ““Glasgow is an Indy stronghold.” Of course it is – why do you think that there are more security cameras…Nov 22, 10:28
    • Mac on The Long Unravelling: “You are on here, every day, all day, posting the same black lies that have been debunked a long time…Nov 22, 10:27
    • Hatey McHateface on The Long Unravelling: “It’s not an “anglo-american” war though is it. Currently 41 countries are providing active support to U. All of this…Nov 22, 10:22
    • Mia on The Long Unravelling: “And paying for one shit parliament is far, far cheaper than having to pay for three: Keep Holyrood and ditch…Nov 22, 10:22
    • Andrew F on The Long Unravelling: “Devoid of facts and overflowing with bigoted bile – let alone juvenile playground insults. If anyone has a right to…Nov 22, 10:21
    • Mia on The Long Unravelling: ““It is staffed by incompetent people with no real.skills outside of being in politics” The exact same applies to Westminster…Nov 22, 10:13
    • Hatey McHateface on The Long Unravelling: “There’s a number of facts in my post, “Mac”. You should take them on board. I’m finding that by sticking…Nov 22, 10:04
    • Gordon on The Long Unravelling: “Give up on that pish, who ever capitalised a letter in the middle of a name?Nov 22, 10:04
    • Sven on The Long Unravelling: ““These plunderers of the world” ; their appetite and greed recognise no borders.Nov 22, 09:52
    • Shug on The Long Unravelling: “I read that the SNP just lost another 3 council seats. That makes 15 now i think. Has Swinney realised…Nov 22, 09:50
    • Mia on The Long Unravelling: ““if Wingers truly believe that any enemy of ours must be given carte blanche to do as they want” A…Nov 22, 09:44
    • Zander Tait on The Long Unravelling: “It is a distressing thought that if Nikita Stalin, Evans, Wark, Garavelli, Swinney, Ruddock, Lloyd and all the others had…Nov 22, 09:37
    • Mac on The Long Unravelling: “Having a government that is consumed with an unexplained hatred for the source of cheap and plentiful energy on Europe’s…Nov 22, 09:22
    • Mia on The Long Unravelling: ““the sabotage and destruction that’s been ongoing since 2014” I like to call it British and USA’s deep states’ sponsored…Nov 22, 09:21
    • TURABDIN on The Long Unravelling: “The anglo-american Nato war by proxy in central Europe ought to be a game-changer for the bright , if there…Nov 22, 09:18
    • Mia on The Long Unravelling: “Actually, twathater, he might have been democratically elected to the post of MSP, but he was “coronated” as leader of…Nov 22, 09:03
    • Zander Tait on The Long Unravelling: “Thanks RM, So another poll showing 52% to 48% in favour of Yes. Humpster will be down in the Dumpster.Nov 22, 08:42
    • Dan on The Long Unravelling: “If energy is too expensive to buy to keep you, your family home, or business premises warm, you can at…Nov 22, 08:41
    • Mac on The Long Unravelling: “Now into telling blatant lies to justify gen0ocide and ethnic cleansing. What a repulsive individual. The world can see who…Nov 22, 08:09
    • Hatey McHateface on The Long Unravelling: “Winter Covid’s making a resurgence, Gregor. Many don’t know when they have it. First thing to go is the sense…Nov 22, 07:52
    • Hatey McHateface on The Long Unravelling: “Stupidity, surely. He’s standing with the burners of babies, the rapist mutilators of teenage lassies, the hostage takers, the indiscriminate…Nov 22, 07:27
    • Hatey McHateface on The Long Unravelling: “Well, well. So you do have an ‘S’ on your keyboard. It’s just “scotland” that has to go without. Who’d…Nov 22, 07:16
    • Hatey McHateface on The Long Unravelling: “‘This is not a case of me , you , or anyway else thinking our opinions are ” superior ”’…Nov 22, 07:07
    • Hatey McHateface on The Long Unravelling: “Sure, Breeks. The soil of Holy Mother R is, of course, sacred. The soil of everywhere else, like U for…Nov 22, 07:00
    • Hatey McHateface on The Long Unravelling: “Falling out of windows is certainly endemic in R and its satellites. But targets and innocent bystanders can also get…Nov 22, 06:53
    • Robert Hughes on The Long Unravelling: “Yes , indeed , B . I’ve never known such levels of mendacious propaganda being spewed 24/7 by MSM &…Nov 22, 06:03
    • Oneliner on The Long Unravelling: “Yep – better to stick to an ad hominem like ‘microbe’ Do you have any mirrors in your butt an’…Nov 22, 05:21
    • Mark Beggan on The Long Unravelling: “He should have grown a moustache like Neil Gray.Nov 22, 04:59
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
114
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x