The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Maths on acid

Posted on April 08, 2013 by

As we browsed the print edition of the Daily Record today to compare its coverage of the latest independence referendum donations news with the online version (with particular regard to Kevin McKidd), we spotted something else curious.

recordmckidd2

We’ve already noted a curious hypocrisy in the Scotsman’s reporting of the same issue this morning, where it pointedly questioned whether the SNP had handed over some sizeable donations to the party to the Yes campaign, while allowing Blair McDougall to make a virtue out of the fact that Labour and the Conservatives hadn’t transferred party funds to the No campaign. But the Record’s arithmetic is even more confused than the Scotsman’s logic.

The Record suggests that “Better Together” has a warchest twice the size of Yes Scotland. But we know from the original Herald article that the No camp has only actually received around half of that figure, with the rest of it in as-yet-undelivered promises. So that’s one rather dodgy stat right away.

Then the text notes that “Better Together’s top donator is oil trader Ian Taylor, who handed over £500,000… 100 times that donated by Labour-supporting Man Utd boss Alex Ferguson”, who the graphic lists as donating £501 (said at the time to be a defiant gesture at Yes Scotland’s suggestion that no donations over £500 should be accepted from people living outside Scotland). Except that £501 times 100 is £50,100 rather than £500,000.

(The online version – which now has a picture of Sir Alex in place of Kevin McKidd – is even worse, saying that £500,000 is “ten times” £501.)

But it’s not just on the No side that the Record’s all over the shop. The image only actually lists one supposed donation to the independence side – that of Colin and Chris Weir, which the Scotsman has told us in fact hasn’t been given to Yes Scotland by the SNP. But if we’re including contributions to the SNP rather than the Yes campaign, presumably we’d also have to include the near-£1m bequeathed to the Nats by the former Makar, Edwin Morgan. There’s a case for including both or neither, but not just one of them.

So while the Record presents the “score” as £2m No to £1m Yes, the reality is either £1.1m No to £0 Yes, or £1.1m No to £2m Yes. The only thing we can say with any sort of certainty is that it isn’t what the Record says it is.

Uncharitable readers might suggest that was a good maxim for the paper’s coverage of Scottish politics in general, but we couldn’t possibly comment.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

30 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
annie

O.T.  Just came accross a tweet from Tom Harris ” anyone spotted on a bus and over the age of 30 is a failure in life” the sheer arrogance of this man leaves me speechless.  I wonder how many of his constituents fall into this category.

Marcia

The article could backfire on them as some readers might send in donations to the Yes Campaign.

Martyn

Can you link to the Tom Harris comment? That is outrageous, has he just ridiculed the whole park and ride policy, does this mean we should ignore the upcoming trams in favour of driving around Edinburgh instead. 
 
What a twat

themadmurph

Rev, 2nd last sentence has an extra ‘is’ in it.  Should it read -: …certainty is that it isn’t what the Record says it is.

Robert Louis

Sorry to be O/T, but some such as scottish skier may be interested in the latest release from wikileaks, the Kissinger cables.  This is documents from the early 70’s and includes many items related to oil and devolution and independence.
 
Oh, and there is also this wee gem, regarding the BBC.  Some things, it would seem, never change.
 
link to wikileaks.org

Tattie-boggle

meanwhile in Glasgow
link to glasgow.gov.uk
?

Robert Louis

Anybody else finding the wings site is loading very slowly, or not completely??  My browser has not changed.

drygrangebull

i know this is nothing to do with the article, but for the few that watched the man down south refusing to pay his license fee because of the coverage of 9/11 and particular the building called 7
link to beforeitsnews.com
says it all

Bugger (the Panda)

RL
 
Yes me too

ronald alexander mcdonald

Promises to NO campaign. We’ll give you x if you exempt us from criminal prosections/paying tax. Give us a knighthood/seat in The House of Lords.
  

Dcanmore

@Rob Louis …
 
What I find is at my home computer using Safari Wings is fine; but a work using Firefox Wings is very slow.
 
This Wikileaks stuff is superb, just pick a year and put Scotland in the search and tons of stuff comes up, especially about devolution circa 1970s.
link to wikileaks.org

benarmine

pity, I like Baxters soup but that’s off the menu for a while now

MJB

This chap just upped the Yes pot thanks to Sir AF,good on you Mr Black.   https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=539828649401871&set=a.441088302609240.117414.440378819346855&type=1

Dcanmore

O/T sorry Rev
Re: Wikileaks … this 1976 excerpt could have been written recently!
 
ACCORDINGLY, IT MAY BE ASSUMED THAT THE SNP’S BEDROCK SUPPORT DOES NOT EXCEED 20 PERCENT OF THE ELECTORATE, WITH THE BALANCE BEING UP FOR GRABS. WHETHER THE LABOR PARTY — TORN BY INTERNAL STRIFE, QUESTIONABLE SCOTTISH LEADERSHIP AND A CREDIBILITY PROBLEM — THE CONSERVATIVE PARTY — DIVIDED AND BANKRUPT ON DEVOLUTION — OR THE LIBERAL PARTY — VIRTUALLY IRRELEVENT AT THE MOMENT — WILL BE ABLE TO EXPLOIT THE SNP’S APPARENT WEAKNESSES IS ANOTHER QUESTION. AT THE MOMENT THERE ARE FEW GROUNDS FOR OPTIMISM.

pmcrek

Interesting that Tom Harris considers actively ruining the environment a measure of success, no doubt he sees his car as compensation for his cock size as well.
 
 

Morag

i know this is nothing to do with the article, but for the few that watched the man down south refusing to pay his license fee because of the coverage of 9/11 and particular the building called 7
 
Bwahahahaha!  That’s spin beyond even the BBC.  The judge said, in effect, go away you silly little man, and these fruitloops claim a huge victory.  You couldn’t make it up – except they did.

Morag

Pmcreck said:
Interesting that Tom Harris considers actively ruining the environment a measure of success, no doubt he sees his car as compensation for his cock size as well.
 
He was tweeting something Thatcher was alleged to have said.  Maybe we need to know the point he was trying to make before we launch into an insulting attack.

Marcia

MJB
 
I was right in my comment above. People power rather than millionaires. The chap is always writing in the local papers blasting all parties if he disagrees with any issue or plan not to his liking.

pmcrek

Apologies Morag you are correct, I simply expect the worst of him (and avoid twitter)

Morag

Still, once we find out the point he was trying to make, it may still be appropriate to have a go.  Live in hope!

Boorach

Norrie over at Lethal Yak has the naysayers funding perfectly….. a picture IS worth a thousand words!
 
 

Boorach

Apologies it’s the ipad won’t let me post links in first post of day, here it is
 
link to norrie.wordpress.com

TYRAN

@MJB – Well done Mr Black

alexicon

Looks like the Biased BBC just can’t help itself.
 
link to newsnetscotland.com

annie

Well done Joan McAlpine – above and beyond the call of duty sharing a couch with George Foulkes.

alexicon

alexicon says:
8 April, 2013 at 10:23 pm

Looks like the Biased BBC just can’t help itself.
 
link to newsnetscotland.com
 
I thought I had deleted this comment.
I deleted the post while it was under pre mod, but it hasn’t cleared. Anyone know how you do this?

McFascist

I am a bit concerned that the Yes campaign might be away to reveal that its most significant donor is a political party. I hope that there is a rule against that.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,689 Posts, 1,208,418 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • panda paws on Safeguarding Is Not Right-Wing: “https://www.holyrood.com/editors-column/view,i-dont-need-to-be-told-by-elon-musk-that-the-uk-has-blood-on-its-hands-i-know-it Holyrood Mandy (Rhodes) knocking it out the park once again. IJan 12, 15:36
    • gregor on Inability To Learn: “Would you like to add anything else, Andy ? How fu**ing dare you slander and belittle those defenseless ones, whom…Jan 12, 15:31
    • Mia on In Ruins: “For second time on a row, please tone your ad hominem down. Besides being offensive and coming across as bullying,…Jan 12, 15:30
    • Dan on Inability To Learn: “https://x.com/fyrishsunset/status/1878445402216714291Jan 12, 15:26
    • Robert McAllan on In Ruins: “Spot on Dan! Forbes followed in Sturgeons wake with her eye on the big prize only to be compromised by…Jan 12, 15:21
    • Mark Beggan on Inability To Learn: “Just added a to do on my bucket list. Dance on Sturgeons grave. If and when possible.Jan 12, 15:20
    • gregor on Inability To Learn: “BBC (2025): I’ll use Trump’s Scottish links in tariff talks: “Swinney told BBC Scotland… Trump wanted the call to “express…Jan 12, 15:16
    • Andy Ellis on Inability To Learn: “Gregor is the Cameron Brodie “de nos jours”. From memory it took an inordinate amount of time for him to…Jan 12, 15:14
    • John.H on Inability To Learn: “Sorry if I messed up the link. It’s a long time since I did this.Jan 12, 15:09
    • John.H on Inability To Learn: “Moire Salmond has released a statement to the Press Association. I don’t know if this has been posted already x.com/fyrishsunset/status/1878445402216714291?s=48&t=2uGfpXYxglIPP9jMDbG3DwJan 12, 15:07
    • Michael Laing on Inability To Learn: “I wish the Rev Stu would have a word with you. I don’t care whose side you’re on, I’m sick…Jan 12, 14:48
    • diabloandco on Inability To Learn: “Oh God , please no! Someone has to explain to folk how the voting system with which we are foisted…Jan 12, 14:44
    • Michael Laing on Inability To Learn: “I couldn’t agree with you more strongly, Mia. I don’t think the SNP’s failure to pursue independence, and its disregard…Jan 12, 14:38
    • Ellie on Inability To Learn: “They enjoy kicking the can down the road. As soon as there’s an election looming, it’s easy for them to…Jan 12, 14:08
    • Dan on In Ruins: “Okay Liz, rather than point out flaws you perceive with an individual, why not come up with someone better suited…Jan 12, 13:48
    • robertkknight on Inability To Learn: “Odious wee nyaff. She’ll do the chat show circuits and the politico shows and the women’s and alphabet soup shows…Jan 12, 13:48
    • Jim Thomson on Inability To Learn: “The latest trope seems to be the “we want the same as Northern Ireland” line, because they know that the…Jan 12, 13:45
    • gregor on Eyes Full Of Beams: “The New York Times: The Day Jeffrey Epstein Told Me He Had Dirt on Powerful People: “The overriding impression I…Jan 12, 13:43
    • Mia on Inability To Learn: ““is there an alternative to a UK controlled referendum that the UK can’t block and which would be recognised internationally…Jan 12, 13:41
    • gregor on Eyes Full Of Beams: “The Electronic Intifada: New bombshell film exposes I***el lobby role in UK Labour Party: “A new cache of leaked Labour…Jan 12, 13:38
    • Mark Beggan on Inability To Learn: “Campaigning for Scottish Independence has been an experience on the Escher Stairs.Jan 12, 13:33
    • dearieme on Inability To Learn: “There is one obvious way to campaign for independence. You say that you are against Starmer’s sneaky attempt to chain…Jan 12, 13:22
    • Mia on In Ruins: ““Never attribute deliberate agency and/or malice when incompetence provides an equally plausible explanation” Incompetence as the reason for the current…Jan 12, 13:17
    • Liz on In Ruins: “I will never get this attraction for Eva Comrie She resigned from Alba when she realised she wasn’t the choice…Jan 12, 13:11
    • Mark Beggan on Inability To Learn: “I think the Counter Culture is just about to get Countersunk.Jan 12, 13:10
    • Liz on In Ruins: “Swinney saying he wants to be FM till 2031 sounds like a threat. All the main parties are useless but…Jan 12, 13:07
    • Robert McAllan on In Ruins: “Forbes ALWAYS was just that Martin and the constituents who put her there are all too aware of that fact.…Jan 12, 13:05
    • Mark Beggan on Inability To Learn: “The Learning disability is not solely a Scottish problem. The whole Western politik has some form of dysgraphia arrogantitis.Jan 12, 13:04
    • James Gardner on Inability To Learn: “It will be in the charity the week after………Jan 12, 12:58
    • Nae need! on In Ruins: “If you have ever been dennis’d you will know that neglect emotionally and inspire hope create a perpetual loop that…Jan 12, 12:56
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
399
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x