The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Four years on

Posted on April 19, 2011 by

Many, many caveats, of course. And a long spoon is clearly required.

But it's hard to class this as anything other than a significant victory. The Sun is the biggest-selling newspaper in Scotland, and while it's unlikely to have much direct influence on how people vote, it changes the atmosphere of the election considerably. Game on.

5 to “Four years on”

  1. Matty says:

    Wasn't there a period in the mid or late '90s when the Sun suddenly decided it was in favour of Scottish independence (but only the edition north of the border) and had "Fighting for Independence" on every front page before quietly dropping it? I've never quite understood what all that was about.

    Reply
  2. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    There was. It had a front page for (maybe) the 2003 Holyrood elections urging a vote for the SNP under the headline "Rise Now And Be A Nation Again" or something. So I'm taking their current conversion with a pinch of salt…

    Reply
  3. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    Wow. A quick bit of Googling reveals that it was actually 1992 (man, I'm getting SO OLD), and that the paper was actually backing independence, but explicitly NOT the actual SNP. Their position now, of course, is that they back the SNP but explicitly NOT independence.

    Reply
  4. Tom Camfield says:

    Hey Stu, can we have a "What I would happen after Independence" article? It's possible you've answered it elsewhere, but would you move back to Scotland, or would you stay in England with an even bluer nation around you? What would you gain from Scottish independence?
    Also, what would happen to Wales and N.Ireland?
    I'm from the South, so I grew up with the idea that we were subsidising these other regions (not Scotland, obv), do you think the union will fall apart? I'm not sure England needs Wales and N.Ireland, but they sure seem to care a lot about the Falklands and the oil fields nearby…
    Also, do you think Scotland would manage itself effectively? I don't mean this in a patronising way, since it can't be much worse than the UK, but the most powerful men up there would be Gordon Brown and Alistair Darling, or Charles Kennedy and Menzies Campbell; would they work together? What would stop them making the same mistakes they made south of the border? Would they be able to wrestle the oil fields from England? Would they set up a sovereign wealth fund, or spend the money on free prescriptions? High tax or low? Would there be a flight of business and businessmen to England, or from England?
    Just your opinion. Thanks!

    Reply
  5. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    I know you're not inviting me to do so, but I'm not going to get carried away with a chicken-counting exercise at this point. If and when the SNP win I'll definitely be writing something very substantial about it, but to answer a few direct questions for now:

    1. I don't accept that Brown, Darling, Kennedy and Campbell (etc) would be the most powerful men in an independent Scotland. For one thing, none of them are standing or likely to stand as an MSP any time soon, and independence would take a few years to happen even if there was a referendum and a Yes vote, by which time they'd all be pretty old or dead. Their parties would still want to siphon all their best talent to Westminster, and Brown also wants the IMF job.

    By far the strongest figure would be Salmond, because he already is the strongest figure in Scottish politics by a country mile and if he actually delivered independence he'd become something akin to a god. He'd be Nelson Mandela and Che Guevara rolled into one. (And he already looks like two people rolled into one, bless his fat-clogged Scottish arteries.)

    2. It would be almost impossible under international law for the remnant UK to hold onto anything but a tiny fraction of the oil fields. And the redrawing of the boundaries perpetrated by Blair in the late 90s would be very likely to be challenged to recoup the 6000 square miles of ocean he reassigned from Scotland to England.

    3. The SNP have already proved themselves canny and financially adept at managing the devolved Parliament's block grant. Their stated policy is to build up a Norway-style oil fund (the Norwegian one stands at somewhere around £350bn at the moment AFAIK, a vast reserve of money for a country of 5m people), and my view is that they'd likely focus much of their spending on infrastructure for renewable energy. (As well as a few crowd-pleasers.) Renewables potentially offer Scotland a bonanza of wealth greater even than that of oil, and by its nature an essentially infinite one. The country is at the epicentre of Europe's wind and wave power, and covered in enormous amounts of empty space in which to stick windfarms and hydro stations and the like without anyone getting too huffy about it.

    4. I think the rest of the UK would stay intact. The Welsh could barely be persuaded to come out and vote for more powers for their Assembly a few weeks ago, and I think they're happy with devolved status. They have none of Scotland's abundance of natural resources and would be in a much tougher position as an independent country, and I think they know it. They're indulged heavily with regard to the Welsh language too, which assuages a lot of nationalist sentiment.

    Norn Iron, meanwhile, would I think be extremely reluctant to separate from the UK for their own very particular reasons. I suspect the Loyalist community would consider such a move as rendering them much more vulnerable to being rejoined to the Republic sooner or later.

    5. As for me, clearly I wouldn't benefit directly from Scottish independence. I do plan to move back home later in life, but right now I have too many personal ties where I am. It'd be a comforting thought to know I always had somewhere to retreat to if the Tory-dominated rump UK that would almost certainly result from Scottish independence became too intolerable, though.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,787 Posts, 1,222,007 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Alf Baird on According As We Need Them: “Thanks for the info, Confused. In particular, “Fanon’s theory of “disalienation” — the idea that for the colonized to escape…Jul 15, 12:53
    • Ben on According As We Need Them: “There was a young fella from gosham, who took out his b****cks tae washem. his wife said hey, put them…Jul 15, 12:43
    • sam on According As We Need Them: “The auld men o the sea Wi their daberlack hair Hae dackered the coasts O the country fell sair. They…Jul 15, 12:25
    • Mark Beggan on According As We Need Them: “Boo hoo. What a shame. Nevermind.Jul 15, 12:19
    • Stuart on According As We Need Them: “Mark Beggan says: I’m getting out of here. They’re all mad! You mean you have only just noticed-;)Jul 15, 11:45
    • James Cheyne on According As We Need Them: “The ideology of wrong thinking began long before 1984,Jul 15, 11:10
    • James Cheyne on According As We Need Them: “Once Scotland became a republic Country having voluntary giving their monarch to become the (new monarch of England) .leaving Scots…Jul 15, 11:08
    • James Cheyne on According As We Need Them: “As Scotland gave their personal bodily monarch and their following line of descent away to England to become the monarch…Jul 15, 10:31
    • Stuart on According As We Need Them: “Aye… Flat earthers believe the earth is flat. You keep believing son, the mother ship will be along any moment…Jul 15, 10:21
    • James Cheyne on According As We Need Them: “The monarch of England by descent and succession , and the Great Seal of England used the terminology the Great…Jul 15, 10:10
    • 100%Yes on According As We Need Them: “The message is getting out there, that’s good news.Jul 15, 10:02
    • sam on According As We Need Them: “The Bubblyjock by Hugh MacDiarmid It’s hauf like a bird and hauf like a bogle And juist stands in the…Jul 15, 09:37
    • James Cheyne on According As We Need Them: “100%Yes. Additional info to contribute to the illegal fiction of the union, which refers to the monarch of England and…Jul 15, 09:29
    • James Cheyne on According As We Need Them: “There was many a ballad ,poem or prose written in Scots language about the condition of Scots and Scotland in…Jul 15, 08:55
    • 100%Yes on According As We Need Them: “For those interested in Scotland, the message about the union is making its mark. https://menafn.com/1109571674/Scotlands-Constitutional-Status-Revealed-As-Legal-Fiction-Experts-Confirm-Basis-For-UN-DecolonisationJul 15, 08:06
    • DaveL on According As We Need Them: “‘…on the route to liberation, I reckon mime and interpretative dance are the only way to go.’ Can you explain…Jul 15, 02:20
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: “Poetry is all very well if you’re into that sort of thing. But when it comes to illustrating the oppressed…Jul 15, 00:17
    • Confused on According As We Need Them: “guy charged was an “aussie”, in a kilt; maybe done an ancestry.com and got told he was “connor macleod of…Jul 14, 23:32
    • Confused on According As We Need Them: “I was never an inmate unlike yourself. Did we meet? – if they had held onto the asylums we could…Jul 14, 23:20
    • Confused on According As We Need Them: “there was a young poster on wings cheap snarky disruption his thing agent x was his name the union his…Jul 14, 23:18
    • Alf Baird on According As We Need Them: “Development of poetry in the native tongue forms a key part of the liberation process and in understanding the colonial…Jul 14, 23:01
    • agent x on According As We Need Them: “@ James What in particular did you find Excellent?Jul 14, 22:00
    • James on According As We Need Them: “Excellent, Northcode. Keep ’em coming.Jul 14, 21:50
    • James on According As We Need Them: “Funny how the unionist rag describes the removal of the stone from a thief as ‘notorious’….Jul 14, 21:48
    • Gribble on According As We Need Them: “On the subject of intimidation on the stump, the impression as often given that this is a worsening problem. But…Jul 14, 21:39
    • Northcode on According As We Need Them: “Excellent article about a young Martinican psychiatrist’s time studying with the great Francesc Tosquelles at the Saint-Alban psychiatric asylum. Thanks…Jul 14, 21:30
    • Breastplate on According As We Need Them: “John Main, You Unionists seem to routinely register your disapproval on the reliance of 300 year old documentation, but accept…Jul 14, 20:43
    • agent x on According As We Need Them: “@ Northcode I notice there has been minimal, or maybe make that no support or encouragement for your poems on…Jul 14, 20:15
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Just Good Friends: “In case you are unaware (and for comparison): WAR O THE WARLDS By H. G. Wells – Owerset intae NOR-EAST…Jul 14, 20:11
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: “Enjoying your use of iambic quadrameter, NC. And your random departures from it too. If you’re taking requests, highlights from…Jul 14, 19:49
  • A tall tale



↑ Top