The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Author Archive


Unionists are the real narrow nationalists 7

Posted on July 01, 2012 by

*Jonathan Edwards is the Plaid Cymru MP for Carmarthen East and Dinefwr. This piece first appeared on his own blog, but we asked if we could reprint it to bring some of its excellent insights to a wider audience. (And also to fix the original’s impressively esoteric rendering of “paraphernalia”. We’re real spelling Nazis.)

I’ve been meaning to write this blog ever since Ed Miliband’s car-crash speech on English identity. I have also taken part in a number of BBC interviews over recent months in which it is sometimes difficult to get your point across when you have an interviewer on the other end barking at you as you challenge unionist perceptions. It also supports why Leanne Woods’ intervention this week is an important one.

When the Miliband speech was being pre-briefed I had high hopes that we were about to hear something significant – that Labour were going to proclaim that their answer to the challenge posed by the SNP’s independence drive was a federal settlement for the British state. I expected Labour to position themselves as advocates of an English Parliament as the political expression of English identity. Instead what we got was hot air, followed by one of the most painful interviews I have seen by a Unionist leader on Channel 4 News.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,793 Posts, 1,223,097 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Young Lochinvar on From May To July: “I’m sure they’ll manage just fine next day when all of the previous days unsold copy is returned prior to…Jul 30, 00:48
    • Young Lochinvar on From May To July: “Reply to P3nisbreath McP3nisbreathface @ 11.03 Is that it P3nisbreath?! Really?! Laugh a minute you.. Away and have a gargle…Jul 29, 23:55
    • Hatey McHateface on From May To July: “YL Sah! has regained consciousness. And there’s 50p in the leccy meter too.Jul 29, 23:03
    • Young Lochinvar on From May To July: “With you P3nisbreath: Every accusation is a subliminal confession of a secret guilty pleasure. Away tae eff ya sad mong.Jul 29, 22:55
    • MrD on From May To July: “Clearly he’d just put the kettle on in the meantimeJul 29, 21:33
    • MrD on From May To July: “Clearly he’d just put the kettle on in the meantimeJul 29, 21:32
    • willie on From May To July: “Swinney is reported to be a deeply religious man piously attending mass as is the church’s calling. And that is…Jul 29, 21:08
    • Young Lochinvar on From May To July: “Secret service 🙂Jul 29, 21:07
    • Alf Baird on From May To July: ““As a matter of law, a referendum is not a required part of the process of becoming independent” (McCorkindale and…Jul 29, 21:05
    • willie on From May To July: “You’ve got the point exactly Agent X. Lower alcohol, no alcohol beer attracts lower to no excise duty and lower…Jul 29, 20:47
    • Young Lochinvar on From May To July: “Can we do a Spartacus thing? I’m John Swinney!!Jul 29, 20:33
    • Young Lochinvar on From May To July: “No, not fuckwits; pig fuckers.. If you are going to squeal on their behalf then at least get it right…Jul 29, 20:30
    • agent x on From May To July: “Willie says: “Yet UK excise duty imposes on beer under 3.5% proof a levy of £9.61 per litre of alcohol”…Jul 29, 20:24
    • Hatey McHateface on From May To July: “I’m confident Epstein was a terrific guy. I’m even more confident that back in the day, not one of the…Jul 29, 20:18
    • Hatey McHateface on From May To July: “They said DC was an Old Etonian toff. It’s malignant envy allied with juvenile so-called humour that likes to portray…Jul 29, 20:13
    • Hatey McHateface on From May To July: “Did he also clarify he was talking about whisky, not whiskey? Given that plenty of Indy-minded Scots (including some on…Jul 29, 20:07
    • Willie on From May To July: “Minimum unit prices. The SNP are having a laugh. Yes it is commendable that minimum unit prices might help assist…Jul 29, 19:52
    • agent x on From May To July: ““On whisky tariffs, Swinney said: “When the president came to Scotland at the end of last week, I think his…Jul 29, 19:10
    • Glenn Boyd on From May To July: “It has been reported that Trump has described John Swinney as ” A terrific guy!” A fine eulogy perhaps for…Jul 29, 18:47
    • Mark Beggan on From May To July: “Allowing Scotland to have it’s Independence referendum has successfully tied the Scots up in a pointless state for the last…Jul 29, 18:33
    • twathater on Scotland’s Saviour: “TBH Lorn I now view ALBA as another bunch of establishment gradualists with NO FIGHT in them, they don’t even…Jul 29, 18:31
    • Mark Beggan on From May To July: “NHS Fife accuse a woman of faking her period while defending a weirdo in a skirt. With the full backing…Jul 29, 18:23
    • agent x on From May To July: “The National: “OUR team has been totally overwhelmed by the volume of people seeking physical copies of Friday’s viral Trump…Jul 29, 18:08
    • Antoine Roquentin on From May To July: “Does he even realise that “the cause” exists? If he does, it’s highly unlikely that John Swinney would’ve tutored him…Jul 29, 18:07
    • twathater on From May To July: “Oh no bastard tax moan surely you wouldn’t want Donald to hand over Scotland to the P@lestinians especially when you…Jul 29, 18:06
    • agent x on From May To July: “Arise the Democratic Republic of Socialist Scotland – Trump flew the Saltire on his armoured tank.Jul 29, 18:02
    • agent x on From May To July: “Documented racism and generally bad comments from the cabal of bollocks allowed in the changing room doctors mates of the…Jul 29, 17:59
    • Stuart on From May To July: “Oh aye Professor? Riddle me this then… “Donald Trump has suggested there should be 50 or 75 years between referendums…Jul 29, 17:56
    • Hatey McHateface on Scotland’s Saviour: “It’s the first step to the establishment of the caliphate in the UK. If Indy suits that long-term aim (it’s…Jul 29, 17:50
    • Hatey McHateface on From May To July: ““Could be intirely wrong and could be jumping to conclusions” Then again, you could be onto something. My guess is…Jul 29, 17:43
  • A tall tale



↑ Top