The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Author Archive


When winning is the only thing 185

Posted on March 05, 2021 by

What puzzles many about the Alex Salmond situation is motive. It’s incredibly difficult for some Yes supporters to imagine any motive that could justify the awfulness of what Alex Salmond has been put through by his successor, and so they reject the whole idea of any sinister goings-on out of hand.

However, it’s far easier to understand what went on when you look at the personality of Nicola Sturgeon and her historical pattern of behaviour.

Because the core fact is that Sturgeon simply cannot bear to lose. She’s very single-minded, and doesn’t really adapt or regroup in the face of adversity. When events and new information make problems for her ideas and plans, she just keeps going – often creating more problems as she tries to force the plan back on track.

Sturgeon’s main priority – in common with most politicians – is to stay in power and to boost her own image and profile. We can look at some hot topics and her behaviour around them, and gain clear insights into what happened to Alex Salmond and why.

Read the rest of this entry →

How to make a coup 132

Posted on February 02, 2021 by

Having never been part of a political party, an area where Wings lacks expertise is in understanding the nuts and bolts of their operation, and how a party’s rules can be used to usurp their members’ power. We’re delighted to have someone equipped to provide a valuable insight into how that’s happened to the SNP in the last two years.

The following line is still a definitive statement in the SNP constitution:

“National Conference is the supreme governing and policy-making body of the Party.”

But in practice it is no longer the case. The 2018 redraft of the constitution centralised power in the Leader and in the NEC. The party Leader has sole and total power over policy – both in the manifesto and in government – and the NEC has sole power over who represents the party and what they are allowed to say.

So in effect, since 2018 the party elite – not the membership – has ruled the SNP.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,862 Posts, 1,233,663 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Cynicus on List Voting For Cretins: “Colin Dawson says: 2 January, 2026 at 1:50 pm Playing Devil’s advocate, what happens if unionist voters decide to vote…Jan 3, 01:59
    • Young Lochinvar on The Gulf War: “AE and A: Righto chaps! Nothing new though I’m afraid to say in those 2 word salad “responses” though is…Jan 3, 01:09
    • Alf Baird on List Voting For Cretins: “Independence (i.e. decolonization) and ending ‘the scourge of colonialism’ is not merely about changing one government for another, it is…Jan 2, 23:44
    • Alf Baird on List Voting For Cretins: “We are talking of Northern Ireland, which is (still) a ‘devolved entity’. I assume you are you now going to…Jan 2, 23:24
    • Andy Ellis on List Voting For Cretins: “A future independent Scottish state would doubtless have much the same citizenship criteria as Ireland. Scotland as a devolved entity…Jan 2, 22:45
    • Andy Ellis on List Voting For Cretins: “Not the auld New Caledonia false equivalence again Alf. Dear oh dear. Scotland =/= New Caledonia. It’s not even like…Jan 2, 22:39
    • DaveL on List Voting For Cretins: “…are we there yet? Are we there yet? Drone drone drone. Call yourself factchecker? Change your name, ‘are we there…Jan 2, 22:30
    • DaveL on List Voting For Cretins: “Why have you called yourself factchecker? Surely with a name like that you’d be off quick sharp to find out…Jan 2, 22:25
    • Alf Baird on List Voting For Cretins: “This text is from Annex 2 of the 1998 Belfast Agreement, on the voter franchise agreed by UK and Irish…Jan 2, 22:19
    • David on List Voting For Cretins: “Needs a counter claim , continue with snp 1 and 2 . No voting Snp for number 1 abstain.Jan 2, 21:35
    • Northcode on List Voting For Cretins: “Excellent post, Alf…very interesting and informative.Jan 2, 21:09
    • BLMac on List Voting For Cretins: “I’ve finally cracked the conundrum! The SNP’s obsession with Gender Reform is the clue. They self-ID as an independence party…Jan 2, 20:37
    • Captain Caveman on List Voting For Cretins: “Your swearing black is white won’t save you or your ilk, Dave. Not interested in your ego-saving crass revisionism, projection…Jan 2, 20:34
    • Alf Baird on List Voting For Cretins: “Due to the usual tricks by the imperial power, France, New Caledonia applied the undernoted ‘secondary criteria’ in one of…Jan 2, 20:32
    • factchecker on List Voting For Cretins: “James said “Wanting other folk to do your research again, Yoon? How about….umm…”France”. Heard of it? You Inglis don’t like…Jan 2, 19:56
    • Dave Hansell on List Voting For Cretins: “Yeah, right. A media outlet which has pushed Establishment narratives since its first edition is ‘left-wing’. One notes that, woke…Jan 2, 19:16
    • Bob on List Voting For Cretins: “I’ve offered wondered: what’s the difference between the shadowy billionaires who fund Reform (Boo! Hiss!) and the shadowy billionaires who…Jan 2, 18:59
    • Northcode on List Voting For Cretins: ““…they will be disappointed because farage is part of the establishment and he thinks LEGAL immigration is acceptable…” Aye, TH.…Jan 2, 18:58
    • Northcode on The Gulf War: “I’ve just realised something germane to the ‘franchise’ argument RAGING (chortle) below the line here in this place. The Scots…Jan 2, 18:48
    • sarah on Off-topic: “You shouldn’t have mentioned the pastry, IB – it brought some sighs from my husband and recollections of his mother’s…Jan 2, 18:48
    • factchecker on List Voting For Cretins: “My dear twathater, it is the professor who is citing the Survey in support of his assertion. It is for…Jan 2, 18:40
    • Northcode on List Voting For Cretins: ““Please explain how the Survey defined a ‘Scot’, and how it sourced and assembled the data…” Folk are so lazy…Jan 2, 18:37
    • twathater on List Voting For Cretins: “Away and dae some research yirself ya lazy arse instead of asking others tae dae it , Alf isnae yir…Jan 2, 18:32
    • twathater on List Voting For Cretins: “Hear Hear Northy I too could be convinced by those criteria , but unfortunately the progressive , civic , DEI…Jan 2, 18:26
    • James on List Voting For Cretins: ““….give some examples of countries in the world where the franchise is based on something different that makes it “regular”….”…Jan 2, 18:25
    • Captain Caveman on List Voting For Cretins: “No Dave. You’re “living proof” of (yet another) Lefty attempting crass revisionism because facing up to reality has become too…Jan 2, 18:24
    • Northcode on List Voting For Cretins: ““… the tiny minority of ethno-nationalist bigots don’t get to decide…” I’ll have you know I’m over six feet in…Jan 2, 18:24
    • Northcode on The Gulf War: ““The right of peoples to self determination does not provide anyone with the right to… exclude minority ethnicities from participating…Jan 2, 18:15
    • Dave Hansell on List Voting For Cretins: “Only in your subjective opinion, Cave dweller. It says Daz on the side of buses, but they don’t sell soap…Jan 2, 18:14
    • factchecker on List Voting For Cretins: “Alf Baird says: 2 January, 2026 at 5:26 pm “if Scots can’t assemble a pro-independence majority from pro-independence native born…Jan 2, 18:08
  • A tall tale



↑ Top