The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Author Archive


Fair’s Fair: the Brexit case for indyref 2 154

Posted on September 20, 2020 by

As a right-of-centre English conservative, there are Scottish National Party concepts I haven’t so far been able to comprehend. Perhaps it’s because I don’t follow Nicola Sturgeon and Ian Blackford. Should I keep an eye on what The Scotsman is saying?

SNP leaders talk in the same sentence of a “free” and “independent” Scotland having a future as a member of the EU. My grasp of those words is not theirs. Distinguished lawyers – be they Remainers, Leavers or Don’t-Care-Just-Pay-My-Billsers – all agree that a series of European Court of Justice decisions have established the unqualified supremacy of European Union laws – disguised as “Regulations and Directives” – over the national laws of EU states.

By 1970, the court ruled that Community law must take precedence even over the constitutional laws of member states — including basic laws guaranteeing fundamental rights, such as in Internationale Handelsgesellschaft mbH v Einfuhr- und Vorratsstelle für Getreide und Futtermittel.

I see this as vassalage, not independence.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,866 Posts, 1,234,359 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James Cheyne on Governing For Beginners: “It is time for four separate nations to regain their own border control, to regain their laws that keep them…Jan 14, 12:28
    • Alf Baird on Governing For Beginners: “Yes James, we are indeed products of our environment. As colonialism ‘is based on psychology’ (Cesaire) this means that in…Jan 14, 12:18
    • James Cheyne on Governing For Beginners: “One of the unforeseen damage control that all nations in Britain can play a part in is for the people…Jan 14, 12:14
    • James Cheyne on Governing For Beginners: “There is a need by people in general to regain there focus from events further afield to the circumstances of…Jan 14, 11:39
    • 100%Yes on Governing For Beginners: “The term “Claim of Right” refers to two significant historical documents in Scotland: the Claim of Right Act 1689 and…Jan 14, 11:14
    • Hatey McHateface on Governing For Beginners: “A great post, Lorna. There are some hopeful signs that people are starting to face reality once again. Wilful ignorance…Jan 14, 10:28
    • Aidan on Governing For Beginners: “James isn’t going to the UN Hatey, there is no chance they’ll give an ESTA or a visa to someone…Jan 14, 10:07
    • 100%Yes on Governing For Beginners: “Does any one listen to this guy “David McGuinness” he’s asking James Kelly ” James I want to interview so…Jan 14, 10:01
    • Hatey McHateface on Governing For Beginners: “You tell us, James. Surely the UN must be back at work by now? We’re half way through January, FFS!Jan 14, 09:10
    • Hatey McHateface on Governing For Beginners: “How fortunate then that we narrowly avoided a fourth in 1745/46. Although, technically, that would have disrupted the numbering somewhat.Jan 14, 09:08
    • Hatey McHateface on Governing For Beginners: “I am thinking about it, Dave, and I am smiling. It’s good news. You could play a part too. Even…Jan 14, 09:01
    • Cynicus on Governing For Beginners: ““A country that has had kings called David, Alexander, Constantine and James” ========= A formidable four names. It has also…Jan 14, 00:46
    • DaveL on Governing For Beginners: “Aww diddums, poor wee Hatey you’re upset. Just think of the long range missile the UK Government has decided to…Jan 14, 00:26
    • James on Governing For Beginners: ““Are we there yet?”Jan 14, 00:06
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Governing For Beginners: “The motto of Comhairle Nan Eilean Siar (Western Isles Council) is: “ÀRDAICHIDH FÌREANTACHD CINNEACH” That is the Gaelic version of…Jan 13, 23:38
    • Kate L on Governing For Beginners: “This is absolutely excellent. Enjoyed every word.Jan 13, 22:09
    • Dunx on Governing For Beginners: “It’s not right wing to expect citizens to contribute to the state. “From each according to their ability…” Karl Marx.Jan 13, 21:51
    • Hatey McHateface on Governing For Beginners: ““Truly America is chosen, though for what” Blethers, Alf. Just ask any of the tens of millions of illegals the…Jan 13, 21:30
    • Alf Baird on Governing For Beginners: ““Truly America is chosen, though for what is open to much rumination.” Being an artificial imperial construct that systematically obliterated…Jan 13, 21:11
    • Hatey McHateface on Governing For Beginners: “I am pleased, Dave, very pleased. My mates may or may not be winning, but so far, they’re not losing…Jan 13, 21:07
    • Hatey McHateface on Governing For Beginners: ““Religion in the western world has had it’s day” Oh dear, Chas. Oh deary deary me. We’re into the end…Jan 13, 20:37
    • Hatey McHateface on Governing For Beginners: ““I’m sure that’s how Stevenson saw it, too” Naw, you’re nae. You’ve found a good way to keep warm though,…Jan 13, 20:25
    • Hatey McHateface on Governing For Beginners: “1707 is around one hour before I usually start my denner. On a school day. Weekends are less predictable.Jan 13, 20:17
    • GM on Governing For Beginners: “Frightening.Jan 13, 20:12
    • Northcode on Governing For Beginners: ““Well, I did study history at a Scottish university. At the time Sarah is talking about, pre-1707…” Hard to believe,…Jan 13, 19:31
    • factchecker on Governing For Beginners: “Well, I did study history at a Scottish university. At the time Sarah is talking about, pre-1707, “direct democracy” as…Jan 13, 19:00
    • Aidan on Grandpa John’s Nightmare: “Breaking into a factory and attacking a policewomen with a hammer so severely that it broke her spine is an…Jan 13, 18:33
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on Grandpa John’s Nightmare: ““And who is reporting on the woman on hunger strike languishing in an English jail for peaceful legitimate protest. Now…Jan 13, 18:17
    • Stuart on Governing For Beginners: “Dictator! Not even close to being a patch on “Junta” by West End Games, the best evening of double crossing,…Jan 13, 18:15
    • Sargie on Governing For Beginners: “This is superb. Thank you!Jan 13, 16:37
  • A tall tale



↑ Top