The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


2012: Will we die after independence?

Posted on December 28, 2012 by

One of our very favourite No-campaign scare stories of the year was the Huffington Post’s “Vote Yes And You’ll Die Of Cancer”. But if Scotland chooses independence in 2014, will it actually affect our healthcare? After all, we’ve already noted how NHS Scotland has been independent since inception (and why we need a Yes vote in order to provide it with a stable funding base that won’t be cut out from under it via the effect of Barnett consequentials under Westminster austerity).

But it’s also worth examining how it would work in practice. What about if we travel to the rUK or in Europe? What about the cross-border co-operation that currently characterises the relationship between the UK’s two health services? Would we still be able to be treated in an English hospital if we vote for independence? Let’s find out.

To answer the question we need to look at what happens now. It’s not only the citizens of the UK who can get free medical care on the NHS – anyone who falls ill here will be provided with emergency medical care. Citizens of European Economic Area (EEA) nations, however, also receive additional healthcare, as do those of other countries with which the UK has reciprocal arrangements. This arrangement is facilitated through the European Health Insurance Card (EHIC).

EHIC is issued free of charge and allows anyone who is insured by or covered by a statutory social-security scheme of the EEA countries (and Switzerland through a different agreement) to receive medical treatment in another member state for free or at a reduced cost, if that treatment becomes necessary during their visit (for example, due to illness or an accident), or if they have a chronic pre-existing condition which requires regular care, such as kidney dialysis.

The intention of the scheme is to allow people to continue their stay in a country without having to return home for medical care; as such, it doesn’t cover people who have visited a country for the specific purpose of obtaining medical care, nor does it cover care – such as many types of dental treatment – which can be delayed until the visitor returns home. It only covers healthcare which is normally covered by a statutory healthcare system in the visited country, or it would render travel insurance obsolete.

The net result is that if Scotland becomes independent there’ll very little effect on the provision of services as they are today. This only remains the case if the rUK is also within the EU, of course, though even if some sort of unholy Tory/UKIP alliance saw the rUK leave, it’s highly unlikely that it would give up access to the EEA – the world’s largest free-trade zone – and would endeavour to remain within the agreement through another means (possibly via membership of EFTA).

But not for the first time, the only real potential danger to the future of the Scottish people’s health lies in remaining within the United Kingdom, not in leaving it.

8 to “2012: Will we die after independence?”

  1. David Lee says:

    Nice analysis. As ever, once you dig a bit deeper, the scare stories evaporate. So many supposed benefits of the EU are, on closer inspection, external arrangements like the EHIC scheme and the Schengen free movement area, which are available to non-EU countries.

    Reply
  2. tammas says:

    A word on NHS reciprocal healthcare. I retired in September 2010 on an occupational pension. For 30 years in France I have worked on secondment from the UK for an intragovernmental organisation. During this time I paid UK taxes and national insurance on the UK element of my salary. Since I have made my life in France and my family live here I have remained, believing my healthcare would be taken care of through the reciprocal arrangement with the NHS. This held true for a period related to what I was due dating from my last payment into the National Insurance scheme.
    If I were living in the UK this limitation would not apply. In tying my healthcare provision to residency the UK are, I believe, in breach of Article 45 of the EU Treaty on the freedom of movement of workers: had I known my healthcare would be cut off I might well not have remained working in France and returned to UK.
    As I will not be 65 until November 2013 I have been obliged to make private arrangements for the intervening time.
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     

    Reply
  3. Doug says:

    Being a pedant, I would remind you of ‘memento mori’.

    However, as a GP up North (Moray) I can assure you the Scottish NHS is in far better shape than the English one and that the fact that the ‘Lansley’ reforms are not touching us a source of relief. 

    That public spending would be preserved in an independent Scotland would only be a good thing and help us to maintain the service to a high standard.

    Reply
  4. Cuphook says:

    There are already protocols in place regarding cross border patients within the UK and I see no reason for these to end upon independence. Largely, they’re just an effective way of making sure that the right authority pays for the patient’s healthcare.

    Health is one of those areas which the Neoliberals must attack in order to prove to England that there is no alternative. Ironically enough, even though most of the English population is nearer to mainland Europe you won’t find articles in the English press reflecting on service provision in France or Belgium etc. A special place is saved for Scotland and it’s wacky, unaffordable, subsidised, communistic, failing, unfair NHS.

    At a conference earlier this year NHS [England] Chief Executive Sir David Nicholson, in answer to the question, which country outwith England he would prefer to be treated in general practice, said: ‘Scotland. Because of the amount of money per head of population it gets.’ I’m not sure, though, if this was an acknowledgement of Scottish Government funding or a Daily Mail type rant regarding Barnett.

    Reply
  5. Morag says:

    As regards the title of the post, my immediate reaction was, “Jeez, I hope so!  I certainly don’t want to die before independence!”

    Reply
  6. Holebender says:

    Re the caption on your map, EFTA countries are also in the EEA.

    I’m with Morag; I definitely don’t want to die before independence!

    Reply
  7. Morag says:

    I was in Yugoslavia (before the schisms) with a choir tour.  One of the choir members had a fall and needed hospital treatment.  CT scan, everything, all on the house.  And very very fast so she didn’t miss her plane home.  As someone said, let’s hear it for communism.

    Reply
  8. Scott Minto (Aka Sneekyboy) says:

    Yeah thanks Holebender. The Rev meant to put Blue is EU members of EEA and Green is EFTA members of EEA.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,785 Posts, 1,221,311 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Northcode on The Con Merchant: ““As for the people banning it in Scottish schools being English – get a grip. They were as Scottish as…Jul 4, 15:18
    • Anthem on Too Tight To Mention: ““Ignited and united by the greed, deceit, and interference from Westminster”. There,fixed that for Mark. Do keep up.Jul 4, 15:13
    • James on Too Tight To Mention: ““Whitehall has created it’s very own Frankenstein government for Scotland…” There. Fixed that for you.Jul 4, 14:51
    • Southernbystander on The Con Merchant: “I read Alf’s last post and it was nearly all easily understandable to an English speaker who has lived in…Jul 4, 14:46
    • Hatey McHateface on The Con Merchant: ““The Scots language was at one time – not that long ago – banned by the English and the Scots…Jul 4, 14:30
    • Mark Beggan on Too Tight To Mention: “Scotland has created it’s very own Frankenstein. A Government created from all the dregs of it’s own community. All the…Jul 4, 13:50
    • Northcode on The Con Merchant: ““We Scots, whether or not we support Indy, are not going to be forced into speaking, reading and writing what…Jul 4, 13:24
    • Northcode on Too Tight To Mention: “Yer twistit weasel-worded anti-Scots bollocks wis spotted a long long time ago., Sveny. An noo awbody else sees it tae.Jul 4, 13:17
    • sarah on Too Tight To Mention: “O/T Just talking to people will do a lot to improve the prospects at the 2026 election. If they don’t…Jul 4, 12:57
    • Hatey McHateface on The Con Merchant: ““abuse directed at the Scots” Sorry to have to put you right, NC, but we Scots delight in puncturing pompous,…Jul 4, 12:55
    • Mark Beggan on Too Tight To Mention: “The Scottish independence movement is much like the Scottish football team. They can’t get by the first leg. They need…Jul 4, 12:55
    • Sven on Too Tight To Mention: “Northy @ 12.34. “Ever sparkling wit of Memmi”, oh Northy, you wee rascal you … I saw what you did…Jul 4, 12:52
    • Captain Caveman on The Con Merchant: “One of the many issues of you and your ilk, Northcode, is that you actively seek (nay, crave) grievance. Unsurprisingly,…Jul 4, 12:43
    • Northcode on Too Tight To Mention: “Aye, James. And this is what for many, if not most, colonised is the first and most difficult stage in…Jul 4, 12:34
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: “I reckon we should crowdfund NC to translate and publish Memmi’s (and maybe Fanon’s) seminal works into Scots. Are you…Jul 4, 12:32
    • Northcode on The Con Merchant: “There isn’t a single comment scribbled doun by anglo-quills and deposited here that is anything more than some form of…Jul 4, 12:25
    • Mark Beggan on Too Tight To Mention: “Have you been locked in a cupboard or something. Have you just realized. Even the mad flag wavers have called…Jul 4, 12:17
    • Northcode on The Con Merchant: “Fasci “groups of men organized for political purposes” has been a feature of Sicily since around 1895. The totalitarian sense…Jul 4, 12:10
    • Sven on Too Tight To Mention: “Northcode @ 11.29. How nice to have you back, Northy. Though I cannot help noticing in his later book, Decolonisation…Jul 4, 12:05
    • Mark Beggan on Too Tight To Mention: “Do you realise what you have said about yourself.Jul 4, 12:01
    • James Cheyne on Too Tight To Mention: “Northcode, To conquer any of the above mentioned in your post, As Alf Baird has pointed out, First ones mind…Jul 4, 12:00
    • Northcode on The Con Merchant: “It’s getting easier and easier for me to understand Scots without having to look up every word or mentally and…Jul 4, 11:57
    • Captain Caveman on The Con Merchant: ““2000 years of fascism” Quite apart from your trademark childish gibberish as a means of expression, this assertion (if we…Jul 4, 11:56
    • James Cheyne on Too Tight To Mention: “So everything that Stu posts on the antics of the devolved scottish parliament from Englands parliamentary Sovereignty claim concept is…Jul 4, 11:50
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: “Loving it, NC. But have you any advice for the lassies of Scotland as we loons reconquer our dimensions, decolonise…Jul 4, 11:44
    • Hatey McHateface on The Con Merchant: “Some good points there, Alf. It has to be pointed out though, that for the first 1900 years of the…Jul 4, 11:32
    • Northcode on Too Tight To Mention: “I’m reading more of Albert Memmi’s The Colonizer and the Colonized. It’s interesting stuff: We have seen that colonization materially…Jul 4, 11:29
    • George on Too Tight To Mention: “Actually I never thought like this but your right. The SNP are the biggest criminal syndicate in Scotland.Jul 4, 11:28
    • agent x on Too Tight To Mention: “Reason behind Peter Murrell’s legal aid success revealed – as bereaved family blast decision https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/reason-behind-peter-murrells-legal-35500054 one leading defence lawyer has…Jul 4, 11:04
    • Alf Baird on The Con Merchant: “Cultural Imperialism and its tools of ‘colonial procedures’ has aye been our bane for the last twa thoosan year, Hatey.…Jul 4, 10:55
  • A tall tale



↑ Top