The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


What IS Labour’s policy on Trident?

Posted on August 30, 2012 by

Nationalists like to taunt Scottish Labour “leader” Johann Lamont for her reluctance to reveal her position on nuclear weapons. But in fairness to the little-seen notional chief, she’s hardly alone in her ambiguity. Despite the UK’s nuclear force being a huge issue, costing taxpayers tens of billions of pounds and being central to Britain’s permanent seat on the UN Security Council, one of the country’s two biggest political parties simply doesn’t seem to know – and hasn’t known for years, despite being in government on both sides of the border – whether it’s in favour of it or not.

As we noted earlier today, a Labour government resolved as recently as 2010 to replace the ageing weapon system with an upgraded version. But the overwhelming majority of over 230 with which that resolution passed was achieved thanks to the uniform support of Conservative MPs. Close to a third of Labour MPs – 94 out of a total of around 350 – opposed the motion along with all 55 Lib Dems and all six SNP members, and a narrow majority (31) of all Scottish MPs were against.

In the Scottish Parliament, meanwhile, renewal was overwhelmingly rejected despite (or perhaps because of) Labour refusing to take any position at all. A June 2007 vote conducted just after the SNP’s historic victory saw the Trident replacement scheme voted against by a comprehensive majority of 71-16, with all but four of Labour’s MSPs abstaining while the SNP, Lib Dems and Greens (along with the four Labour rebels) all voted No, and only the Tories backing the policy that the UK Labour government had chosen and voted to impose on Scotland.

It’s extraordinary that Labour has managed to maintain such a startlingly contradictory position for so long. Just two months ago the party’s shadow defence spokesman, Scottish MP Jim Murphy, blogged a statement from his fellow shadow defence minister Alison Seabeck reiterating that Labour’s official policy was to back Trident renewal. Yet in the country where the weapon system is sited, 37% of its Westminster MPs (15 from 41) voted against the proposal and not a single one of its Holyrood MSPs was prepared to vote in favour.

It’s difficult to overstate what a bizarre situation that is. That 37% is the very same percentage of Lib Dem MPs (21 from 56) who voted against the tuition-fees increase in England, having signed a conspicuous public pledge months earlier promising to do so. Yet the Scottish Labour MPs had made no such pledge.

An official Labour Party policy which chiefly affects Scotland, then, is backed by barely 60% of its Westminster Scottish MPs, and by 0% of its Holyrood MSPs. Of the six people who stood for the Scottish leadership in 2011 just 33% support renewal, while the successful candidate refuses to tell us what her oft-changed personal view is.

(Or indeed the Scottish party’s position, given its supposed policy independence from London. The 2011 Scottish Labour election manifesto makes no mention of Trident, or nuclear weapons in general, anywhere in its 98 pages.)

It’s incredible, in the literal sense of the word, that Labour feels able to make dramatic and strident pronouncements on the subject while cynically looking both ways at once. Poor old Ian Davidson is apparently so confused he rages against disarmament as a dire consequence of independence, despite not just opposing renewal but wanting the existing system scrapped.

Johann Lamont constantly angrily demands that the SNP detail every last possible consequence of a Yes vote in the referendum. Perhaps it’s time she set an example and started telling us what a No vote will mean. If, that is, she has any idea.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest


7 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Arbroath 1320

Aha the nuclear Trident question.
 
I have it on good authority 😆 that Scottish Labour policy is that if they, Labour, don’t mention Trident then it can’t possibly exist! 😆
 
The only things that exist in the alternate universe inhabited by Labour are things that Labour want to speak about. Nothing else exists! :LOL:

Cuphook

I thought a thought but the thought I thought wasn’t the thought I thought I thought.

Mind you – this could be applied to any of their policies.   

Arbroath 1320

WHIT?
 
Labour have POLICIES!
 
Will wonders NEVER cease?
 
Does the Lamentable one know that Labour have policies I wonder.
 
Naw, she disnae know about any Labour policy, if she did she’d be the first to be seen shouting from the roof tops. Wouldn’t she?

Doug Daniel

Perhaps someone in the mainstream media would like to take them to task about this, and find out their position once and for all? After all, if someone is trying to tell us that Scottish independence leading to nuclear disarmament for the UK is a bad thing, the very first question that would pop into my head would be “so you’re against nuclear disarmament, then?”

Meanwhile, the SNP tries to debate a nuanced change on their position on NATO, and it’s talked about as if they’re just blithely changing their anti-nuke stance. The level of hypocrisy is stunning, absolutely stunning.

James McLaren

Their policy is to have as many policies as is necessary by the circumstance and time of the need.
 
In Scotland, they have a compliant MSM who never ask questions of them and their cognitive dissonances.
 
The word, any word today, is the message, if it can been repeated authoritively ad nauseum.

Arbroath 1320

I know I’m O/T here, but I’ve just watched this video of Ryan, no NOT the guy with sausage rolls and wee dugs but the Republican V.P. candidate. Having listened to it I reached a point where I was uncertain about who he was ACTUALLY talking about. Was he REALLY talking about Obama and the Democrats? I felt for sure he was talking about the Tories, RED, BLUE and YELLOW, as well as the Bitter Together campaign. 😆
 
link to order-order.com

Arbroath 1320

Sorry folks, I’ve just read this over on NNS.
link to newsnetscotland.com
Are we worried folks?
Well I don’t think WE are worried but Westminster sure as hell are! 😆


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,693 Posts, 1,209,348 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • gregor on Poisoning The Unwell: “Yeah, MSM damage limitation.Jan 20, 09:07
    • gregor on Poisoning The Unwell: “Good Morning Britain: Brian Cox: Cox: “The thing that worries me the more than anything else is how women are…Jan 20, 08:58
    • James Gardner on Poisoning The Unwell: “Fits well with “Smoke and Mirrors”Jan 20, 08:43
    • yoon scum on Poisoning The Unwell: “There is three possibilities if AI takes over The first is it kills us all. An outcome that wouldn’t bother…Jan 20, 07:19
    • yoon scum on Poisoning The Unwell: “What team NAT needs to figure out is That the blatant incompetence of Westminster is no excuse or justification for…Jan 20, 07:11
    • Captain Caveman on The same old tricks: “Piss off you illiterate twat.Jan 20, 06:51
    • James on The same old tricks: “Mia, take heart; the majority here are with you. And the 59% (sorry, Yoons). BTL is under constant (suddenly increased)…Jan 20, 00:07
    • James on The same old tricks: “Facts, eh? They mean nothing to a Franchise Fanny. This subject MUST NOT be discussed. Roll up roll up, get…Jan 19, 23:58
    • James on The same old tricks: “The concern troll mask has slipped…..Jan 19, 23:55
    • James on The same old tricks: “LOL. Look in a mirror. Self awareness bypass.Jan 19, 23:54
    • James on The same old tricks: “You should try reading this site’s numerous blogs about the bollocks that is GERS. Oh, but of course, that’s not…Jan 19, 23:51
    • James on The same old tricks: “The concern trolling didnae work, fud. We see ye.Jan 19, 23:48
    • James on The same old tricks: “‘Aidan’ thinks it’s ‘British’ oil, Mia. Silly us!Jan 19, 23:47
    • James on The same old tricks: “Aye, Dan. 59% Yes. When’s the referendum, again?Jan 19, 23:45
    • Young Lochinvar on Poisoning The Unwell: “Indeed. Ruddicks one to watch once quality Polis Toshan eventually get round to it, leave the donut shop and investigate…Jan 19, 23:45
    • James on The same old tricks: “‘Aidan’ must have a lieu day. No doubt back soon to divert, distract, rinse, repeat. But hey, that’s the day…Jan 19, 23:42
    • James on The same old tricks: “But why would ‘Aidan’ believe the opposite of what he’s being paid to post (badly)?Jan 19, 23:36
    • James on The same old tricks: “ROTFLMFAO!!! You should be in the Sturgeon/McDairmid comedy gig. A proper threesome LOL.Jan 19, 23:26
    • James on Poisoning The Unwell: “They have no shame, Sarah. Craven wretches every one.Jan 19, 23:19
    • sarah on Poisoning The Unwell: “It is great that some of the MSM are beginning to report the defence evidence. I know they will not…Jan 19, 22:28
    • gregor on Poisoning The Unwell: “Scottish Daily Express (2025): SNP in ‘chaos’ as lawyer joins brutal clear-out of staff from Sturgeon-Murrell era: “The SNP’s long-serving…Jan 19, 21:39
    • Mia on The same old tricks: “Well, and that was me thinking that what looked truly ridiculous was someone demanding evidence about the formation of a…Jan 19, 21:11
    • sarah on Poisoning The Unwell: “Anent the strange house that the Murrells supposedly lived in, it does seem that perhaps it was all a set-up,…Jan 19, 20:22
    • Aidan on The same old tricks: “Mia – it’s no skin off my back if you don’t provide any evidence to support your claim. You just…Jan 19, 19:42
    • Dan on Poisoning The Unwell: “Comedy site this has become. Couple of rocket quick dislikes to my last posts. Do Angus and Jennifer really sit…Jan 19, 19:34
    • Dan on Poisoning The Unwell: “Indeed MaryB https://yoursforscotlandcom.wordpress.com/2023/04/14/how-can-we-trust-you/ https://wingsoverscotland.com/how-to-make-a-coup/Jan 19, 19:20
    • Dan on Poisoning The Unwell: “One can only ponder why Angus would be so compliant to ongoing UK requirements. Is he just a plain and…Jan 19, 19:17
    • MaryB on Poisoning The Unwell: “Remember that Angus Robertson was the initiator and enactor of all the SNP reforms which removed the internal democracy and…Jan 19, 19:16
    • gregor on Poisoning The Unwell: “Never:Jan 19, 19:14
    • gregor on Poisoning The Unwell: “Looks authentic to me:Jan 19, 19:12
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
468
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x