The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Quoted for truth #42

Posted on January 13, 2014 by

“Herald View”, the Sunday Herald, 12 Jan 2014:

“The Deputy First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon, is to be commended for refusing to participate in the victimisation of the ‘undeserving poor’. She promises to scrap the bedroom tax, keep housing benefits and reject the forthcoming Universal Credit, which amalgamates a whole range of benefits into one payment. The Nationalists say they will increase social security benefits and the minimum wage annually by the rate of inflation.

However, they cannot secure these protections under the current constitutional arrangements.”

“We share the Deputy First Minister’s belief that Scottish voters want no part of this war on benefits.

Welfare is likely to become a central issue in the referendum campaign, if only because it highlights the difference in political culture between Scotland and the south-east of England. The SNP say that only with independence can Scotland be protected from Tory policies.

Can Better Together persuade Scots that if we stick with the UK we will not be subject to the benefit reforms that are being driven through Westminster, and that there can still be what the former Labour Prime Minister, Gordon Brown, yesterday called ‘a union for social justice’ in Britain?

Of course, Gordon Brown has no power to deliver the new powers he believes Scotland should have.

Nor are his proposals sufficient to ensure social justice in Scotland. The Unionists must come up with something more substantial if they want to prevent many Scots who aren’t nationalists voting yes to independence to ensure that Tory policies stop at the Border.”

Does Labour being even tougher on welfare than the Tories count, we wonder?

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

49 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Alex Grant

All we need now is an editorial on the economics situation incl today’s announcement re debt and a serious view on market reaction if WM dared to reject Scotland’s CONTINUED participation in a currency Union

Brian Powell

“The Unionists mus come up with something more substantial”, but they can’t.
 
Whatever they come up with it would need to survive the Two Party system in Westminster, and the House of Lords, and future Westminster Governments.
 
No matter how ‘enshrined’ the existence fo Holyrood becomes, without full control of resources it will be forever at the mercy of Westminster policies, and the need to pay for them, no matter if the requirement for the policies does not originate in Scotland.
 
I hope this eventually penetrates and voters really, really begin to understand this.

gordoz

Well if thats the Sunday Herald view they are to be commended.

Gray

Interesting to note that the article is by an un-named journo .. is this the view of Ian Stewart, the editor?

dinnatouch

That should be the final nail in Better Together’s coffin if the rest of the Scottish press didn’t act as the propaganda division of UK PLC.

Taranaich

Of course, Gordon Brown has no power to deliver the new powers he believes Scotland should have.
 
I know, right? If only we could’ve seen him as Prime Minister, even for only three years or so, then we could’ve seen what he would’ve done in power to grant Scotland the powers he says they should have.
 
*Paddington stare*

heraldnomore

Ian Stewart’s at The Hootsmon, and these are not words I’d expect him tto allow into print.

Bugger (the Panda)

O/T
 
If it is not Duck Houses and flat screen TVs, it is portaits of one and other.
The Court of Louis XIV had nothing on this lot.
link to telegraph.co.uk
 
 

PRJ

The term “unionist” is usually linked to the Tory party. Should we not be replacing this term with “Labour party and partners.”
The continuing use of “unionist” disconnects the voter from the labour party.  

Tony Little

@gordoz
 
There are only two comments on the article.  Usually hundreds from anti-independence supports on other article which are less fact-based.  It really says something about the position of many Herald readers.  
 
I am still of the belief that nearer the time the Herald will come out as YES.  (However, I am not prepared to bet my house on it!)

SquareHaggis

@BtP
 
Oh my Gawd, what an obscene waste of taxpayers hard earned cash.
 
Can’t understand what Blair is doing among that lot, he’s not even an MP!

Bugger (the Panda)

Tony Little
As i viewed it, there are no comments on the article, although two on the casptured version.

SquareHaggis

Oh, wait a minute though, he’s a “Peace Envoy” to the Middle East – hahaha, so funny it’s sad 🙁

Smith

Congratulations … I see you’ve now popped up on Newsnow.
 
link to newsnow.co.uk

Ian Brotherhood

Here’s a portrait of Alistair Carmichael, painted just ten minutes after Nicola had finished with him:
 
link to galeri3.uludagsozluk.com

gordoz

@Taranaich
Dont take offence but that was as sarcastic and cutting as a ‘Noel Gallagher’ retort. Clinical man – seriously made me laugh
 
@Tony Little
‘Who are you going to believe me or your own eyes ?’ (Boom, Boom)
We live in hope –

ronnie anderson

SquuareHaggis, Tony Blair is the EU peace Embassidor to the Middle east, if you had notice on that TV piece his left lapel , torn garment pinned , you,s are no tearing ma Armanni suit  fur nae cunt, its a Jewish custom to tear clothing at a death.

alexicon

Today while visiting my local, I had someone say to me that he is voting YES because of the Tories attack on welfare.
Before he was a fifty/fifty yes or no, but I assume that he’s had a shock in the post regarding his benefits.
Another YES in the bag.

SquareHaggis

Uk debt and the Scottish Independence referendum – from the Uk Treasury
 
link to gov.uk

ronnie anderson

ah forgot on my last post re T Blair he negotiated away £350mil to the EU , UK taxpayer,s money to help Spain, they built road,s with the money, ambassidor,s job secured.

Horacesaysyes

Now what we need are similar sentiments to be expressed in a paper with a slightly higher circulation, but it’s a start.

Macart

Here we go.
 
link to theguardian.com
 
That’ll leave a mark. 🙂

SquareHaggis

Alex Salmond on Good Morning Scotland 02:37
 
link to bbc.co.uk

Gin

For the fist time in many years I bought a sunday paper YESterday –  the sundayherald .  Happy to give business and support to the one Scottish paper that seems to making an effort at balance.
 
Also hoping that the Putin #indyrefski Front Cover will be a great historical artefact and rise in value from £1.30 in years to come 🙂

FraserP

Exactly, Horace. The circulation of the Scottish Daily Mail is more than twice the Herald’s. The Record and Scottish Sun have more than ten times as many readers. More people read the Dundee Courier than read the Herald. Quality is all very well, but when it comes to voting only quantity counts.

Macart

O/T
 
For sheer short sighted idiocy this one by Chris Deerin takes the biscuit.
 
link to theguardian.com
 
Two tablets and a lie down in the darkened room required.

Alex Grant

Deerin’s article is amazing. More amazing that the Guardian reprints shite originally published in the Daily Mail! Shows you how much they ‘get it’!

Kalmar

“Flat screen TV” klaxon, Bugger the panda 🙂

Macart

@Alex Grant
 
BTL is entertaining. Even some of the unionist support are somewhat agog.
 
No bloody wonder. The Grauniad and a blatantly right wing article?

Jingly Jangly

RE Icm poll Gruard, SNP at 4% as we only have 8.3% of UK Population does that mean that the SNP have nearly 50% in Scotland?

setondene

The Herald hasn’t ceased being a unionist paper.  This is part of a managed retreat.  Sort of – ‘OK then, we might concede you some powers on welfare but we know you’re not really interested in defence or oil revenues’.

MochaChoca

OT – Gordon McIntyre-Kemp on STV Scotland Tonight this evening in response to the latest developments…. Should be good! 

ronnie anderson

Macart, ma heart,s bledin on the piece , the world,s fawin apart,FFs a load of valium, fur that pish lol.

Tamson

@Macart:
 
that’s not the only very interesting piece in the Guardian just now. How’s about this CiF piece?
 
link to theguardian.com

ronald alexander mcdonald

Brown came up with next to bugger all when he was Prime Minister never mind now.

HandandShrimp

The Chris Deerin piece in the Guardian is a shocker. It is a lift from a Daily Hell piece. I feel dirty having just read it. I may have been slightly intemperate.

Macart

@ronnie
 
Know whit ye mean fella. Know whit ye mean.

Macart

@Tamson
 
Oh jeez after the weekend the opposition have just had, that’s the capper. 😀

Macart

@HandandShrimp
 
I thought you were perfectly well behaved. 🙂

HandandShrimp

Macart
 
I confess to be mildly shocked at being told in the Groaniard that staying British is a “moral” imperative. I’m not entirely pleased if truth be told.

Horacesaysyes

o/t – My wife is currently filling in a YouGov survey which is asking about the referendum and in particular media outlets and how much you trust them to cover Scottish issues including the referendum. It’ll be interesting to watch out for the results.

Macart

@HandandShrimp
 
Definitely a click baiting exercise, but I never thought to see a beaut like that in the Groan. Darling was right y’know. it did get worse. 😉

HandandShrimp

Macart
 
True but I didn’t think he meant the next day. The gloves are off.

joe kane

Robin McAlpine explains how the Labour method of attacking and destroying the welfare state differs from their Better Together Tory mates’ preferred method –

The campaign against the welfare state is now in full-flow in Scotland: Your guide to unmasking and destroying it ~ Jimmy Reid Foundation 
link to blacktrianglecampaign.org

Morag

I am still of the belief that nearer the time the Herald will come out as YES.  (However, I am not prepared to bet my house on it!)
 
If they do, I will joyfully renew my regular order.  As well as paying Stu.

Patrician

Rachel Reeves, the true face of the Labour party.  When anyone tells you that labour are the party of the working class, the downtrodden, the poor, just point them at Ms Reeves and what she says out loud.  I hadn’t realised until I read the attached article she is marked as future leadership material, and that is so scary.  She appears to be to the right of Tony Blair and she doesn’t even feel the need to hide it.

Morag

More people read the Dundee Courier than read the Herald. Quality is all very well, but when it comes to voting only quantity counts.
 
I don’t care.  It will bring joy to me personally to have my Herald back, and that ain’t gonna happen without a big, brash, indy-colours-to-the-mast coming-out.

Beastie

Ah, that’s a refreshing piece of writing to find in a newspaper. But it’s the Sunday Herald, so it’s not a total surprise.

You can argue that the Sunday Herald doesn’t have a big readership, but when was the last time a Dundee Courier front page got shared thousands of times on Facebook and Twitter? How many times has a previous day’s release of an image boosted their hardcopy sales?

I’m betting never.

The days have long gone when the copy you get from the newsagent is the only way you’d see the paper. The Sunday Herald is doubtless well aware of this and the release of that particular front page was not just for breaking a big story that no other paper seemed to have decided to pay any attention to (because seriously, they couldn’t have missed it) it was also a very cheap, very effective advertising campaign. I wonder how many extra sales they got because of it?


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,666 Posts, 1,201,601 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Skip_NC on How it happened: “The 2017 GE in Scotland confirms the 2015 election was rigged, which confirms that the 2010 election was rigged. Obviously…Nov 8, 18:30
    • John Cleary on How it happened: “Sorry to go off topic, Rev, but the story today is that Liz Lloyd is going back to Number Ten…Nov 8, 18:29
    • Jay on How it happened: “Correction: Dunning Motion not ResolutionNov 8, 18:11
    • gregor on How it happened: “Elon Musk: “You are the media now”: https://archive.ph/vLbECNov 8, 18:09
    • Dan on How it happened: “C’mon Aidan, ffs it’s Friday evening, mix it up a little from all this dry legal shizzle. We’re currently in…Nov 8, 18:08
    • Aidan on How it happened: “Sure – happy to, I think I can say two things; Firstly, in law more recent legislation takes precedence over…Nov 8, 17:43
    • Dan on How it happened: “Holyroodstoun – Quality “Government” policy implementation. Turn the heating up to 11 0.11 The re-wilding of the taxpayer funded solar…Nov 8, 17:41
    • Jay on How it happened: “On my reading, Aidan referred to “misspelled English words” in the negative.Nov 8, 17:40
    • Jay on How it happened: “It would be helpful if Alf could find time and patience to deliver expositions in both Scots and English language.…Nov 8, 17:37
    • Graeme on How it happened: “Well this gives me food for thought when it comes to voting to avoid a Lab/SNP coalition after the next…Nov 8, 17:28
    • robertkknight on How it happened: ““Nicola Sturgeon to headline comedy festival show” She’s already done that has she not? She was SNP Leader after all.…Nov 8, 17:21
    • Jay on How it happened: “If the Parliament in Westminster has unlimited power to legislate in Scotland then there could be little else as better…Nov 8, 17:20
    • robertkknight on How it happened: “To paraphrase George Foulkes… “Yes, but they’re doing it deliberately”.Nov 8, 17:14
    • gregor on How it happened: “Fakestream media doesn’t hold any true power – You/we do (yawn)… The Umpteenth Time: The New Kind Of People: Look…Nov 8, 17:14
    • Jay on How it happened: “Aidan maybe is a Unionist (at present, I have no idea)but to ignore him, and/or what he writes, could be…Nov 8, 17:08
    • Jay on How it happened: “Last night, using the Legislation website, I read the Claim of Right Act 1689. I lack legal education/training and its…Nov 8, 17:01
    • Jay on How it happened: “Who cares for theDemocrats? What about everyone and everything liable to suffer?Nov 8, 15:06
    • Alf Baird on How it happened: “That’s maybe why it is helpful to consider postcolonial theory, because it is based on ‘practice’ and hence actual evidence…Nov 8, 14:56
    • Jay on How it happened: “Genuinely fascinating. Thank you.Nov 8, 14:53
    • Chas on How it happened: “It is far simpler than what you suggest. The SNP are simply incompetent in everything they touch.Nov 8, 14:45
    • Jay on How it happened: “Yes, already found that, Acronyms are not my specialist subject. I do not know Polari, either.Nov 8, 14:42
    • Jay on How it happened: “The terms ‘left’ and ‘right’ have, largely, been a source of confusion for many decades. Using terminology from 18th century…Nov 8, 14:35
    • Aidan on How it happened: “Right, but we are communicating in English here, else a significant majority of people would not be able to understand…Nov 8, 14:12
    • Sven on How it happened: “Could maybe whistle a couple of bars of, “Here comes the Chief” ?Nov 8, 13:50
    • Jay on How it happened: “are you going to be on the panel with Jack Dee for ‘Sorry, I haven’t a clue’?Nov 8, 13:50
    • Vivian O’Blivion on How it happened: “Scot Gov ban on biomass heating in new property and conversions is as of today, officially scrapped. Oil fired burners…Nov 8, 13:46
    • Hatey McHateface on How it happened: ““In physics all is theory until proved factually through observation and rigorous experimentation in the laboratory” It’s a bit more…Nov 8, 13:42
    • Robert Hughes on How it happened: “yip , Peter , Dancing Fools n Cosmik Debris in abundance nae doot 🙂Nov 8, 13:41
    • gregor on How it happened: “re. “Hope there’s a Q&A opporchancity on the night.” Here’s the ultimate answer (regardless:) #NoSNPEscape #RealityWinsNov 8, 13:40
    • SteepBrae on How it happened: “That’s quite an optimistic prediction “that eventually people will cherish a new commodity: wisdom” given the evidence, ie the way…Nov 8, 13:31
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
52
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x