The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Premature evaluation

Posted on February 01, 2012 by

There could have been nothing more predictable in the independence debate than that the Unionist parties, having furiously demanded a clear, simple, yes/no question for the last eight months, would be in a tumultuous rage when they finally got one. The First Minister had barely announced the Scottish Government’s chosen ten-word proposition to the Scottish people when a chorus of angry voices in the Unionist camp were on the airwaves denouncing it as “leading”, “unfair” and “rigged”.

Supposed experts were hastily summoned to explain to us how the phrasing of the question was designed to lead brainless voters down a “cognitive chute”, because the poor stupid Scottish electorate had no idea of what the SNP meant by “independent”. The Telegraph leapt into action, conducting its own polls with various possible versions of the question in an attempt to demonstrate how widely responses could be altered by simple changes in wording. It then swiftly wrote up the results in doom-laden terms, thundering in the article’s strapline that:

“The “loaded” question Alex Salmond wants to ask in the Scottish independence referendum leads to at least a 10-point increase in public support for ending the Union”

That analysis came a little TOO swiftly, as it turned out.

Because the Telegraph left the polls running after it published the story, and as the sample size grew, something very odd happened. The results for the different versions of the question all started to coalesce around almost identical numbers. Rather than the 10% variation described in the story, four out of the five options delivered outcomes that were only fractionally different. At the time of writing, the results (which you can see for yourself by going to the page linked in the second paragraph of this piece and clicking the “View Results” button for each poll) were as follows:

Do you agree that Scotland should be an independent country?
YES 52%
NO 48%

Do you want Scotland to remain part of the United Kingdom?
YES 51%
NO 49%

Do you want Scotland to leave the United Kingdom and become an independent country?
YES 51%
NO 49%

Do you want Scotland to leave the United Kingdom and become a separate nation?
YES 51%
NO 49%

Do you think the Scottish Parliament’s powers should be extended to enable independence to be achieved?
YES 44%
NO 56%

Even the outlier version at the end, asking an absurd question even we don’t understand (exactly which extended powers would “enable” independence to be achieved, rather than actually achieving it in themselves?), only managed to bring about a 7% swing. Of the three other versions, two resulted in independence winning by 51-49 and 52-48, including the one featuring the S-word on which the Unionist camp appears to be mainly pinning its hopes thus far.

Interestingly, the FUDs had more luck with a “positive” question (that is, one seeking a Yes answer for the Union rather than for independence) than with the scaremongering negative versions, scoring a narrow victory with the simple “Do you want Scotland to remain part of the UK?”, a formulation which has absolutely no chance of being adopted. But although it changed the result, even that question only actually altered the vote by 3% compared to the Scottish Government’s proposed version (the first one listed above), not the 10% claimed by the Telegraph.

We commend the Telegraph for leaving the piece on the site to be mocked, even though the entire text is now totally at odds with the reality. Perhaps in time the numbers will evolve further and we’ll be the ones looking stupid. But for now, amidst the fiery heat of debate, we can all enjoy a little light relief at their expense.

1 to “Premature evaluation”

  1. Shodan says:

    The SNP and others on the independance camp seem to be very pleased at this poll. A poll on the Torygraph (of all places) and it still shows either support or a very close run battle after several thousand votes. So much for their polls claiming no one wanted it to happen. Cheers Telegraph, the independance camp could do with more of this sort of help.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,794 Posts, 1,223,268 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Alf Baird on The Empty Hearse: ““We do actually need a government behind the movement.” The ‘nationalist’ Scottish Government should be fully supporting the movement’s Liberation…Aug 2, 09:23
    • Dan on The Empty Hearse: “@ George Hope you had a braw holiday break and your health is good. That Qualcast sounds like the original…Aug 2, 08:38
    • Iain More on The Empty Hearse: “With Laura Mitchell standing as the Woke SNP Candidate in Moray I wont be voting on the Constituency vote for…Aug 2, 03:05
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Empty Hearse: “Transition formatting garble: Title should be just TROD with no question marks.Aug 2, 01:41
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Empty Hearse: “TROD?? bhuail glainne fìona an sinc TIFF glass of wine hit the sinkAug 2, 01:37
    • Peter McAvoy on The Empty Hearse: “Earlier today I read that the one of Alexander Dennis sites in Scotland has been put up for sale. If…Aug 2, 01:14
    • Northcode on The Empty Hearse: ““An optimist will tell you the glass is half-full; the pessimist, half-empty; and the engineer will tell you the glass…Aug 2, 00:17
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Empty Hearse: “LOMAIRE-FEÒIR Chuala mi lomaire-feòir gu h-àrd anns an adhar a‘ gearradh tron ghuirme. Chunnaic mi air oidhche fhuair fras reòite…Aug 1, 23:19
    • sarah on The Empty Hearse: “@ Big Jock: the lack of a political force is why we need to spread the word about the political…Aug 1, 23:07
    • Big Jock on The Empty Hearse: “Dan ask yourself this. Are we closer to independence than September 2014? If you are honest the answer is an…Aug 1, 22:45
    • George Ferguson on The Empty Hearse: “I was gifted a 1950s Qualcast mower. No engine. Made the lawn look like Wembley. It was heavy roller at…Aug 1, 22:34
    • Dan on The Empty Hearse: “The Scottish Government Poundshop Administration of Devolved Powers wanting “a detailed seabird compensation plan”. FFS, I’m pretty sure most Scots…Aug 1, 22:10
    • Northcode on The Empty Hearse: ““I disagree with NOT voting at all in the Scottish elections” I appreciate that each of us must form our…Aug 1, 21:50
    • Dan on The Empty Hearse: “Sigh. “All it takes for evil to triumph is for good men (and women) to do nothing”… There’s plenty going…Aug 1, 21:18
    • Lorn on The Empty Hearse: “I agree, Hatey. However, the independence parties might be hard hit as many people will mistake Corbyn for a socialist…Aug 1, 21:13
    • Lorn on The Empty Hearse: “Yes, no votes SNP is the only possible answer. Angus Robertson’s book, ‘Vienna’ is quite brilliant, but, when it comes…Aug 1, 21:04
    • George Ferguson on The Empty Hearse: “@Agent X Simply because their higher echelons don’t care for their welfare. My brother is an ex Police Fed guy…Aug 1, 20:44
    • Willie on The Empty Hearse: “Just to move to the Sandie Peggie case reports are suggesting that NHS Fife’s legal bill is now nearing £700k…Aug 1, 20:36
    • Big Jock on The Empty Hearse: “Like many in the movement. I feel numb with the morass we find ourselves in. I used to post on…Aug 1, 20:36
    • agent x on The Empty Hearse: “A charity has been praised after serving more than 18,000 meals to police officers during US President Donald Trump’s visit…Aug 1, 20:07
    • agent x on The Empty Hearse: ““If the negotiations aren’t successful, then we’ll move to dissolve the union. It’s perfectly legal to do so.” No explanation…Aug 1, 18:52
    • Colin Alexander on The Empty Hearse: “Even simpler for me: No votes for any candidates / parties that will swear fealty to the English Crown /…Aug 1, 17:48
    • 100%Yes on The Empty Hearse: “It would appear the SNP branches are taking action on Independence. Have a read, not before time. https://grousebeater.wordpress.com/2025/08/01/snp-branches-rebel/Aug 1, 17:45
    • The Flying Iron of Doom on The Empty Hearse: “Meet the new carrot, same as the old carrot… 🙄Aug 1, 17:45
    • agent x on The Empty Hearse: “Headline: “SNP rebels challenge John Swinney with radical independence plan” “Rebel SNP members have laid down the gauntlet to John…Aug 1, 17:30
    • twathater on The Empty Hearse: “Very seldom I disagree with any of your comments NC but I disagree with NOT voting at all in the…Aug 1, 17:29
    • George Ferguson on The Empty Hearse: “Sir Keir Starmer is a seasoned barrister apparently accomplished in International Law. He has never heard of Inalienable rights and…Aug 1, 17:04
    • Mark Beggan on The Empty Hearse: “Fearghas Kenny Smith article. Thanks for that interesting read. It seems to me the Stuart’s like the Romanovs failed to…Aug 1, 16:54
    • James Cheyne on The Empty Hearse: “As far as I can surmise, The Scottish “Claim of Right ” is stating that there was no personal union…Aug 1, 16:04
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Empty Hearse: “Hi Aidan, I respect the fact that you have academic credentials in International Law. My own formal qualifications are in…Aug 1, 13:16
  • A tall tale



↑ Top