The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Positive-case-for-the-Union update #3

Posted on December 11, 2011 by

(See here for the whole story.)

The Scottish Conservatives website runs a promisingly-titled piece today, headlined "Davidson: Scotland is better in Britain". The introduction makes a seductive pledge:

"Scottish Conservative leader, Ruth Davidson has urged the SNP to break its silence and set out the cost of so-called Independence in Europe and the Euro as she, in contrast, sets out the positive case of why Scotland is better off in Britain." [our emphasis]

Unfortunately, a technical glitch appears to have caused this apparent "positive case" to fall off the page, because all Davidson actually goes on to say in a few brief paragraphs is that "The cost of independence is frighteningly high", claiming that an independent Scotland might raise interest rates – a figure of £1000 per year extra for the average mortgage if rates rose by 1% is plucked from the ether – and that were said independent Scotland to join the Eurozone (something that's an absolute minimum of 10 years away, were it to happen at all) our corporation tax might be "increased by Brussels or Bonn" rather than controlled in Edinburgh.

In other words, Ms Davidson's latest stab at the fabled "positive case for the Union" turns out to be "if Scotland was independent our taxes would go up, your mortgage payments would rocket and our economy would be run by foreigners". To be honest with you, readers, we're not absolutely sure which part of that is supposed to be the "positive" aspect. At this stage, frankly we're wondering if perhaps all the Unionist parties have bought a faulty dictionary. It would explain a lot.

1 to “Positive-case-for-the-Union update #3”

  1. Scottish republic says:

    There is no positive case for the union.
    It's clear, they have no argument other than some misty-eyed teary drunken hazy image of when Britain once ruled the world (or if interpreted otherwise – invaded and exploited all sorts of countries around the world till their asses were unceremoniously kicked out of these countries).
     
    There is no positive case and they know it, we know it and the ginger rodent knows it too.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,779 Posts, 1,220,483 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Aidan on A different school: “Whether the ToU was lawfully executed or whether England simply invaded is a very interesting historical subject, for a historian.…Jun 23, 16:03
    • Hatey McHateface on A different school: “Hats off to you, Confused. The regular poster with the most truthfully descriptive user name by a country mile. Respect!…Jun 23, 15:52
    • Northcode on A different school: “What is internalised oppression? “Internalized oppression is when the oppression that permeates the environment is able to seep into oppressed…Jun 23, 15:49
    • factchecker on A different school: “Correct; they are still extant. Many people posting on this blog insist that the ToU is invalid because it was…Jun 23, 15:49
    • Insider on A different school: “Great stuff, “confused” ! Keep you comments coming….pure comedy gold !Jun 23, 15:49
    • Aidan on A different school: “Read the article above: Tommy Sheridan’s view is that this is what will mobilise the current non-voters. As if “we…Jun 23, 15:44
    • aLurker on A different school: “@Colin Dawson Aye so there’s twa guid ideas straight off. Use the list vote to indicate a majority for action…Jun 23, 15:42
    • Hatey McHateface on A different school: ““Every other country that has taken its independence since the end of WW II has had to endure a few…Jun 23, 15:39
    • Hatey McHateface on A different school: “Of course you missed it. You would have had your hands full.Jun 23, 15:35
    • Hatey McHateface on A different school: “One of the regulars forever telling us that Indy support is above 55%, 60% or higher, needs to have a…Jun 23, 15:32
    • Confused on A different school: “Listen to me, you absolute fucking tit, on here every day with your “it’s all ancient guff and doesn’t matter”,…Jun 23, 15:27
    • Hatey McHateface on A different school: “It defies belief that any aspirational national government could have avoided discussing the ever-escalating war. In fact, I don’t believe…Jun 23, 15:22
    • James on A different school: “When did the economic, political and governance arguments “stop working”, “Aidan”? Must have missed that one.Jun 23, 15:17
    • Lorn on A different school: “Actually, the Treaty and the CoR are still extant. That means that they exist legally. Time has not withered them.…Jun 23, 15:13
    • Hatey McHateface on Holiday Relief: “I wouldn’t believe thon Douglass boy, Northcode. He writes in English, the whiny tongue of the lying, colonialist oppressor. He…Jun 23, 15:03
    • James Cheyne on A different school: “If there is one or two things the modern politicians do not have, is integrity, intelligence, and honesty. At least…Jun 23, 14:28
    • Aidan on A different school: “It defies belief that any thinking person could imagine the Claim of Right, a document written hundreds of years ago…Jun 23, 14:25
    • James Cheyne on A different school: “Independence of Scotland is more likely to come through the supidity errors of the tory party ( which is more…Jun 23, 14:22
    • lothianlad on A different school: “The SNP are brit infiltrated careerist, cowardly liars!Jun 23, 14:20
    • sarah on A different school: “How hard can returning to self-governing nationhood be? 60 countries have come from nowhere to nationhood since 1945 – they…Jun 23, 14:12
    • James Cheyne on A different school: “The SNP have had plenty of mandates that they threw and squandered away because they are woke globalists first, yoonist…Jun 23, 14:01
    • 100%Yes on A different school: “We either destroy the SNP or allow the SNP to destroy Scotland.Jun 23, 13:57
    • Confused on A different school: “Some Traynor-esque spin from Sheppard there.Jun 23, 13:41
    • Debatable Lands on A different school: “No politician wants to own the actual delivery of independence. They know it will be hard with a lot of…Jun 23, 13:33
    • lindsay on A different school: “Liberate Scotland is the body offering just that in 2026 Colin. Check them out. But bear in mind that SNP…Jun 23, 13:25
    • David Beveridge on A different school: “That’s a brilliant idea. Bet the SNP would sh*t themselves at the very mention of it.Jun 23, 13:20
    • David Beveridge on A different school: “The SNP can beg, plead, whatever for me to lend them my vote but they can GTF. I won’t vote…Jun 23, 13:19
    • Peter McAvoy on A different school: “As I have stayed before. Prevent the closure of Alexanders Abolish the UK supreme court and house of lords Stop…Jun 23, 13:10
    • Confused on A different school: “I couldn’t read all that, my tolerance has evaporated. Was it along the lines of : “dig up the claymores”…Jun 23, 13:04
    • robertkknight on A different school: “Biggest obstacle to independence is the SNP, which like the zombies of countless crap movies, is dead, but just doesn’t…Jun 23, 12:56
  • A tall tale



↑ Top