The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Labour gets its story straight

Posted on March 21, 2012 by

Ed Miliband's speech to the Scottish Labour conference, 2nd March 2012:

"If we believe in the idea of Scotland as a progressive beacon, why would we turn our back on the redistributive union – the United Kingdom?"

John McFall, Baron of Alcluith, Scottish Labour MP until 2010 and ex-chairman of the House Of Commons Treasury Committee, on BBC News at 8.46am, 21st March 2012:

"The North-South divide is getting bigger, not smaller."

When Labour ask you to vote for the status quo of the "redistributive Union" in 2014, readers, remember which direction it is that the party – by its own admission – wants to keep redistributing the UK's money in.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

1 Comment
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Shodan

The magical thinking of the unionist parties. They go to great lengths to make out that Scotland is poor and needs money from the south because it is in a terrible state (or when they are under the light of facts and good opposition they imply it heavily to the same end) and then, scarcely a breath between, try to claim that Scotland is doing great and it's all thanks to them now. Meanwhile they ignore any financial reality, relying on scaremongering every which way.
 
You can almost understand the doublethink and blatant dishonesty of the MPs and party leadership, but it is harder to understand why the public or lowly party members put up with this nonsense. You'd think they'd be more interested in seeing the people they are paying to do a job do it right. I doubt many people would put up with someone else ostensibly doing something far less important or less well paid (working in a supermarket, putting up a shed or basic work in their garden, etc.)  trying the same sort of twisting and contradictory claims or efforts to back out of earlier promises.
I've seen some argue for a half hour on a 2 for 1 on beans or some other petty offer or mistake in a shop but then they don't bother to vote or think before they do. This is why I am going grey.
 
I think they can be sharp as knives so long as they think there's something at stake (even if it is just a single pound coin from their pocket), but for some reason they don't make the connection with politics having the ability to alter their lives to at least a single pound coin's worth…


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,697 Posts, 1,210,448 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • gregor on Saying sooths: “The KLF: Justified & Ancient: “You better not stop them ’cause they’re coming through… They’re justified, and they’re ancient And…Jan 29, 00:30
    • Alf Baird on Saying sooths: “Even the earlier Roman claim to have ‘devastated the Picts’ was found to be premature. Similarly there is little evidence…Jan 29, 00:19
    • gregor on Saying sooths: “World Economic Forum: Agenda: LGBT+ https://www.weforum.org/stories/2018/11/scotland-wants-schools-to-teach-lgbt-issues-in-world-first/Jan 28, 23:59
    • gregor on Saying sooths: ““Our book to mark 10 years since the independence referendum is now available to order!” https://x.com/ScotNational/status/1849858964663697457 #SNPWillsForIndependenceBonus https://archive.ph/tlH0wJan 28, 23:51
    • Mark Beggan on Saying sooths: “The Pictish language is just beginning to be understood or interpreted. The early findings are unraveling a highly complex society.…Jan 28, 23:48
    • Lorna Campbell on The Symbolist: “And if they tried to set up something that might be moderately successful and a good idea, it would be…Jan 28, 23:38
    • Dan on Saying sooths: ““Scotland only needed an absolute majority of anti-union MPs to end this union. We achieved that already THREE times. Yet,…Jan 28, 23:14
    • gregor on Saying sooths: “The Rockefeller Foundation: “Building on a legacy of employing many of the brightest thinkers of the 20th century, The Rockefeller…Jan 28, 23:05
    • Mia on Saying sooths: “Absolutely!Jan 28, 22:47
    • Mia on Saying sooths: ““and which would deprive MP’s from Wales and Northern Ireland of a say over UK constitutional matters?” And when exactly…Jan 28, 22:45
    • gregor on Saying sooths: “Gerry Rafferty: Get It Right Next Time: “Out on the street, I was talking to a man He said, there’s…Jan 28, 22:44
    • Mia on Saying sooths: “In case anybody is interested in reading Mr Martin’s article, it can be found by following the link below: https://www.bsg.ox.ac.uk/sites/default/files/2021-04/Scotland_Referendum_final.pdfJan 28, 22:39
    • Mia on Saying sooths: “Well, I got a positive vote. That means at least one person invested their precious time in reading it. That…Jan 28, 22:38
    • Xaracen on Saying sooths: “Why would an upside to the Scottish half of the Union be a downside to the UK government, Aidan? And…Jan 28, 22:32
    • Mia on Saying sooths: ““Nicola Sturgeon: vote for SNP is not vote for second independence referendum” And here is my question: What right did…Jan 28, 22:29
    • Hatey McHateface on Saying sooths: ““The Picts were maistly written oot o oor history for some reason” It’s hardly a mystery, Alf. The Declaration of…Jan 28, 22:25
    • Mia on Saying sooths: ““are likely to appeal to 20/25% of the Scottish electorate” Labour has the majority of Scotland’s MPs after getting support…Jan 28, 22:23
    • Hatey McHateface on Saying sooths: ““Politics is what has been used to force Scotland out of the EU despite the people of Scotland categorically voting…Jan 28, 22:16
    • Mia on Saying sooths: ““it’s not lawful and won’t be recognised” “lawful” according to whose laws? Those of the entity that has been for…Jan 28, 22:13
    • Xaracen on Saying sooths: “Wales and N. Ireland do have their say as they are both territories of the Kingdom of England as you…Jan 28, 22:12
    • Hatey McHateface on Saying sooths: ““Politics as a route of independence is dead” Oh well then, we’re doomed. Unless … Can we post stuff online…Jan 28, 21:58
    • ross on Saying sooths: “Stewart M16donald got cosy. Scottish independence should be a threat to the UK, no ifs no buts. Got cosy.Jan 28, 21:55
    • James Macnicoll on Saying sooths: “They have done absolutely nothing for independence since Salmond left,in fact Sturgeon and now Swinney are actively discouraging people from…Jan 28, 21:50
    • moixx on Saying sooths: “There might be a lot of people who’d vote for your ‘interim alternative’. At the very least, it’d be interesting…Jan 28, 21:46
    • gregor on Saying sooths: “M.I.A.: BORN FREE: “…I don’t wanna to be that fake Cause you can do it And imitators yeah stick it!..…Jan 28, 21:30
    • Alf Baird on Saying sooths: “Yes, the historical and archaeological record tells us a great deal aboot the Picts as descendants of the Neolithic people…Jan 28, 21:29
    • Insider on Saying sooths: “FFS ! Stop spamming Mia ! No-one is going to waste their time reading this verbal diarrhoea !Jan 28, 21:20
    • gregor on Saying sooths: “Mia is thriving with her independence and doesn’t require any parliamentary carrots to convince her that she doesn’t hold any…Jan 28, 21:15
    • Stevie on Saying sooths: “The SNP’s Scotland Fornever Campaign – I now hate the SNP ; I used to loathe them but now it’s…Jan 28, 21:07
    • agent X on Saying sooths: ““We ALREADY won that independence at the ballot box on the 8th May 2015” Sturgeon General election 2015 Nicola Sturgeon:…Jan 28, 21:03
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
66
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x