The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Kenny Dalglish for Prime Minister?

Posted on April 28, 2010 by

One of the most striking things about the current election is the BBC's total abandonment of even a pretence at impartiality with regard to the nationalist parties in Scotland and Wales (and other smaller parties like UKIP too), which is most obviously visible in the Corporation's determined exclusion of them from the defining theatre of the campaign – the leaders' debates.

In the light of protests pointing out that excluding what Ofcom defines as "main parties" in Scotland and Wales during an election is against broadcasting regulations, the BBC (and ITV and Sky, although the latter subsequently broke ranks – see above) hastily rebranded the programmes as "Prime Ministerial debates", and insisted that they were only for the politicians contesting the keys to 10 Downing Street.

The gigantic irony, of course, is that it looks increasingly as if NONE of the participants in the debates will actually be the next Prime Minister.

Indeed, only one of them even has a vaguely realistic chance. Nick Clegg won't be the next PM, because our crooked electoral system ensures that the Lib Dems will have by far the smallest number of seats. Gordon Brown has no chance of achieving a majority, and Clegg has already explicitly ruled out supporting Brown as a minority PM.

So right away, of the three debaters, we're down to David Cameron. His chances of achieving a majority also look slim, but are still just about within the realms of possibility, especially with the support of the Ulster Unionists. But time is running out for the Tories to build the sort of margin they need to secure a majority against the Labour bias built in to the constituency system.

If the polls stay roughly where they are, the most likely next Prime Minister of the UK is a Labour MP who isn't Gordon Brown. The exact identity of this hypothetical person is currently unknown. Alan Johnson has considerable support within the party, and has recently made fairly unambiguous overtures towards the Lib Dems about PR – something he also has a previous record of favouring and seems to be genuine about.

But other candidates including David Miliband and Ed Balls might also challenge for the leadership in the event of Clegg demanding Brown's head as the price of his support. The one thing that seems certain about this least certain of elections is that one way or another, Brown is going to require the services of a removal firm come May 7th.

An interesting thing about the governance of the UK is that the Prime Minister, like other ministers, doesn't have to be an MP at all. (Which negates another of the BBC's attempted defences, namely that Alex Salmond isn't standing for a Westminster constituency this time round.) If a ruling party – or coalition – wants a particular person in its Cabinet and they haven't been elected, all that's required is a swift ennobling so that they're a member of the House Of Lords, and they can serve in government.

In such a way was the Sith Lord Baron Mandelson elevated to a position of administrative power, and so could anyone else be. Were Labour to find itself with the fewest votes but the most seats, and with Clegg blackballing Brown, they could anoint anyone they liked as their leader. They could go for national treasure Dale Winton as a unity candidate if they wanted, and with Lib Dem approval Lord Winton of Sweepshire would find himself discussing the next Queen's Speech with Her Majesty.

Alternatively, they could go for a sporting hero loved in many parts of the UK. Kenny Dalglish would have support in Scotland, in the North-East (Blackburn, Newcastle), the North-West (Liverpool) and more, and he certainly has top-level managerial experience.

He's a born winner, but also statesmanlike in a crisis. The SNP would back him if their votes were also needed in the new coalition. (He's a national hero, and imagine how much it would upset all those Union-loving Rangers fans.) And he'd be at least as honest and straightforward in debates and interviews as the candidates we have now.

"Prime Minister, are you going to renew Trident?"

"Mibbes aye, mibbes naw."

We can but dream our dreams.

0 to “Kenny Dalglish for Prime Minister?”

  1. Dean says:

    I think it'd be hugely un-satsifying for me (and much of the UK) if they included the SNP, etc. For the simple reason that: even if we wanted to, we can't vote for them.

    So the SNP are on, they win the debate, they're clearly the best party… oh.
    If they stood people in every constituency I imagine they'd have a claim that couldn't be challenged.

    Reply
  2. Grant says:

    I'm beginning to worry about what's going to happen.
    Take a look at this page, written by an Nate Silver, an American statistics nerd(who correctly forecast 49 out of 50 of the state results in Obama/McCain and whose prediction came within 0.1% of the popular vote):
    link to fivethirtyeight.com;
    Look at the second table in particular. Based on some very realistic assumptions, he has the Tories really close to victory with Ulster support. This, or anything worse (just 10 more seats for the Tories) and we have the nightmare scenario of a Tory win, and the end of the electoral reform debate. Because you can be sure the news narrative will be that the people have spoken, we wanted the Tories, and in the end we didn't want a hung parliament. Your average joe will go back to being totally disillusioned, and probably voting Labour again in 5 years time for more of the same.
    It's probably too difficult to finesse this now, but I believe that if you're in a Labour/Tory marginal, no matter how much you want to up the Lib Dem vote to make a statement, you have to vote Labour to keep the Tory seat total down and bring about the Lib Dem/Labour coalition we want. I
    For what it's worth, this guy makes the same argument:
    link to guardian.co.uk

    Reply
  3. Grant says:

    That first link should have been:
    link to fivethirtyeight.com

    Reply
  4. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    "I think it'd be hugely un-satsifying for me (and much of the UK) if they included the SNP, etc. For the simple reason that: even if we wanted to, we can't vote for them."

    The sensible solution is to have a half-hour show after the debate, shown only on BBC Scotland, in which Alex Salmond is asked the same questions the other leaders were asked.

    Reply
  5. Dean says:

    That sounds perfectly reasonable. I'd also have been in favour of a fourth debate with the three of them plus the Scottish and Welsh ministers.

    On the other hand, it's amusing that the Tories were part of the Scottish debate – do they even bother standing candidates there anymore?!

    Reply
  6. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    Mm, indeed. The SNP's proportion of Westminster seats is only about 1% below the Tories' proportion of Scottish seats, despite the Tories standing in 100% of Scottish seats and the SNP only standing in about 8% of Westminster seats. So it's hard to see by what criteria the Tories were allowed in the Scotland-only debates, if the SNP weren't allowed in the "British" (actually English) ones…

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,910 Posts, 1,242,492 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Young Lochinvar on Only An Excuse: “Brother As I have discovered, not just here, there is no respect given for your service. None. Sad. Makes you…May 24, 03:41
    • George Ferguson on Only An Excuse: “For completeness a Yellow Card was your rules of engagement. A standard military procedure.However 50 years later that’s no defence…May 23, 22:57
    • George Ferguson on Only An Excuse: “@Dan I don’t know if I will be a recipient of the new Sir Keir Starmer rules on what constitutes…May 23, 22:21
    • Ebok on Only An Excuse: “‘That Green MSP shouldn’t even be allowed to take up office’ If it hadn’t been that Green, it would have…May 23, 21:40
    • Dan on Only An Excuse: “George’s 600m targeting skillz may be somewhat overstated going by his ability to find and click on the correct reply…May 23, 21:40
    • Young Lochinvar on Only An Excuse: “Uncalled for Dan He’s referring to his army days back when weapons weren’t pop guns and still of a decent…May 23, 21:07
    • Aidan on Only An Excuse: “Oh yeah Dan I’m sure Geri is a normal person keeping society functioning. That’s definitely the impression I’m getting. I…May 23, 21:02
    • Young Lochinvar on Only An Excuse: “Fat Slag Wilma Flintstone @ 1.17 Jesus H. Christ! The social media lifestyle influencer/ dating site catfisher is back at…May 23, 21:01
    • Geri on Only An Excuse: “Whit exactly is the point of SpaceX rocket? Yet more debris in the Indian ocean. Probably killed loads of marine…May 23, 20:52
    • Geri on Only An Excuse: “Ach, dinnie be like that..May 23, 20:40
    • Geri on Only An Excuse: “Well who disnae love a roastie with herbs – lush! Just follow the correct strength tho or it’ll be yer…May 23, 20:38
    • George Ferguson on Only An Excuse: “@Dan Missed the point again Dan as always. You save Scotland I know you want to. The only reason I…May 23, 19:59
    • Dan on Only An Excuse: “AiDan struggling to comprehend that “normal” people that keep society functioning may work night shift or live / work in…May 23, 19:50
    • Dan on Only An Excuse: “Hitting a target at 600m… Whit’s this aw aboot? Are Scotland’s issues somehow going to be resolved through a long…May 23, 19:39
    • George Ferguson on Only An Excuse: “@Geri I have given you the heads up on where this is going. We the people have given a Scottish…May 23, 19:13
    • TURABDIN on Only An Excuse: “A quote from D.H. Lawrence “All the lot. Their spunk is gone dead. Motor-cars and cinemas and aeroplanes suck that…May 23, 19:02
    • Geri on Only An Excuse: “Then scroll by. Fuck off. Don’t comment. It’s not exactly rocket science is it? It’s you that seems troubled &…May 23, 19:02
    • Geri on Only An Excuse: “But you can at least vote out a presidente, George. & I’d assume an independent Scotland would have a constitution…May 23, 18:53
    • Aidan on Only An Excuse: “The things that you post on here Geri are deranged, and the fact that you post them in the early…May 23, 18:32
    • George Ferguson on Only An Excuse: “@Geri We are monarchists because we don’t want Nicola Sturgeon as El Presidente in charge of a Country that doesn’t…May 23, 18:11
    • Geri on Only An Excuse: “I do know that, AI Dan. I just dunno WTF some sad wanker would think to check it & then…May 23, 18:05
    • Aidan on Only An Excuse: “I don’t know if you know this Geri – but at the bottom of each post it shows what time…May 23, 17:43
    • Geri on Only An Excuse: “I dunno. There was nothing like going off to fight for king & country to come hame tae yer entire…May 23, 17:42
    • Tinto Chiel on Off-topic: “@Marie. In that case, may The Force be with you!May 23, 17:35
    • George Ferguson on Only An Excuse: “Well thats the Trongate trashed tonight. And most Celtic supporters won’t be able to tell you why. It was Father…May 23, 16:49
    • Alf Baird on Only An Excuse: “Hatey, in a colony we are all colonised to some extent, some groups more, some less, and those exhibiting denial…May 23, 16:47
    • Geri on Only An Excuse: “Shiteface, Do you need a hanky?May 23, 16:45
    • Geri on Only An Excuse: “AI Dan, It’s quite easy to call you a sad bastard. You & Shiteface give so many opportunities. Whit other…May 23, 16:32
    • Young Lochinvar on Only An Excuse: “I’mnogay McI’mnogayface @ 8.11 Well well well! 😉 What a Julian Clareyesque rant! Raw nerve hit eh.. I think you’ll…May 23, 15:56
    • Young Lochinvar on Only An Excuse: “I’mnogay McI’mnogayface @ 8.46 Your projecting again “old boy”.. And not one reference to oaths either, you’re slipping..May 23, 15:39
  • A tall tale



↑ Top