The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Jigging in the rigging

Posted on April 04, 2012 by

The agenda behind the Unionist parties and media's concerted smear campaign against the Scottish Government's independence-referendum consultation has become a little clearer today, with the publication of the full data regarding the UK Government's own survey on the subject. Which, purely for the purposes of local colour, we'll passingly note was impartially called "The Referendum on Separation for Scotland" and opens with the following words:

"We believe passionately in the United Kingdom and recognise the benefits it has brought to all of its citizens. For over 300 years the United Kingdom has brought people together in the most successful multi-national state the world has ever known. We want to keep the United Kingdom together."

(The Scottish Government consultation, in contrast, begins with the somewhat less partisan line "The people who live in Scotland are the best people to make decisions about Scotland’s future.")

Conducted by a committee on which no SNP representatives serve, the UK consultation attracted a dismal response by comparison. The Holyrood version, which is still ongoing, had as of Monday this week atttracted 11,986 contributions from members of the public so far. The Westminster report drew a pitiful 2,857 by comparison, but the picture is in fact even bleaker than that.

Of that 2,857 a staggering 1500 responses (or 53%) are believed to have come directly from the Scottish Labour website. Of those, almost half – 740 – used the exact pre-scripted wording written by Labour. (These numbers do not appear in the consultation document, but the latter was freely admitted by the Secretary of State for Scotland to several news sources this morning.)

Under the rules demanded by Labour this week for the Scottish Government's consultation, 739 of those submissions would have to be disqualified on the grounds of duplication, reducing the total number of valid responses to 2,118.

A further 101 respondents were anonymous, and another 118 were duplicate responses which didn't come from the Labour website. Removing those leaves the UK Government's consultation on the independence referendum based on just 1,899 responses from members of the public (that's one for every 34,229 people in the UK).

But perhaps more pertinent than this abysmal level of public confidence in the UK Government's consultation compared to the Scottish Government's one is the staggering degree to which Labour, rather than the general public, swamped the process in submissions. Of those 1,899 eligible responses, it would appear that 761 – or a tiny fraction under 40% – came directly from the Scottish Labour website.

So over half of all submissions, 40% of valid submissions, and an astonishing 25% of the entire consultation response made up of ineligible duplicate spam entries, came from Labour itself. Yet a compliant media has collaborated all week in creating a media portrayal of SNP "abuse" of the Scottish Government's consultation, based around just 3.5% of anonymous responses (contributions whose actual preferences, it should be noted, were not recorded, and which therefore may well in fact have been partly or even entirely from pro-Union supporters rather than nationalists).

We've said it before and we'll say it again – it's not paranoia if there really is a conspiracy against you. We doubt the electorate is all that concerned with the entire point-scoring business, but we're confident that those who are will have no difficulty in seeing the reality of what's been going on.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

11 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Peter A Bell

We also had Michael Moore claiming that the UK consultation provides "a good reflection of what people across Scotland think". How can such a claim be justified on the basis of such a small, self-selecting sample of the UK population?

Cybernat Depot

When they shout loudly in one direction, it usually because they are trying to distract you from noticing that the very thing they are accusing you of is exactly what's going on in their own camp.
 

Stevie Cosmic

Mr Moore, as it is also reported by the STV website, also thinks that the UK governement's consultation needn't be subjected to any independent scrutiny or verification.  Funny that. He also lied though his teeth on that website too with regard to Bruce Crawford 'having a problem' with the validity of the SG's consultation process. Quite breathtaking arrogance and hypocrisy that stretches the definition of 'brass neck'  to giraffe like extremes.

I have a feeling that there is a concerted effort to piss people off so much with  lies, bile and stupidity that eventually, we'll all just give up because we can't take these undignified levels of childlike discourse any longer.  It's tiring this, to say the least.

David Robertson

Think we're crediting them with too much sense. My thoughts after hearing results of the UK versions was that I imagine they would have rather not had so much attention being focused on either of the consultations.
Labour in Scotland is so desperate to try and "get something" on the Scottish Government that they grasp at anything without knowing the facts or that they are the ones who are up their necks in it.

Peter A Bell

You got it! "Scottish Labour's entire focus is on lashing out mindlessly at the SNP and Alex Salmond. They have nothing else.

tom

Yes, we can be confident there will be those "who have no difficulty in seeing the reality of what's been going on", but can we be confident that they are sufficient in number?

Peter A Bell

I'm already seeing examples of people saying we should "move on". But I totally disagree. So long as the mainstream media is colluding in passing off the UK referendum as valid, while casting aspersions on the real consultation, we have a duty to persist in trying to get the truth across.

I never expected Labour to do anything else and I have a brother in the Labour party and I feel ashamed that he is among such people.The main problem is getting the truth out there to everybody I know it is too much to ask for the media to be honest,they lost their integrity a long time ago.

MajorBloodnok

The thing is there are so many positive stories out there – e.g. renewables in Scotland:
 
link to jonathonporritt.com
 
And the announcements about all those new railway stations in Scotland (double page spread in today's Scotsman, no less). To name but two.

Dubbieside

MajorBloodnok

Many thanks for the link to the jonathonporritt blog. Very well written and a joy to read such a positive article about Scotland.

Pity we are not able to get this promoted more in the main stream media.

Is there any way this could be linked to Newsnet Scotland to try to find a bigger audience?


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,673 Posts, 1,203,290 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Mia on A Personal Best For Kezia: ““Logically, Indy supporters should be willing to extend to Fife (and Orkney) the same principles they claim for Scotland” Why?…Nov 26, 17:10
    • Jay on A Personal Best For Kezia: “queer Squirmer?Nov 26, 16:48
    • Republicofscotland on A Personal Best For Kezia: “The obedient little Mayor of Scotland Swinney – follows his London/Washington master narrative. “Likewise, what on earth is Swinney doing…Nov 26, 16:41
    • Captain Caveman on A Personal Best For Kezia: “I have it on good authority that I’m you, apparently CC. I mean, you just have to laugh.Nov 26, 16:26
    • Confused on A Personal Best For Kezia: “are you agreeing with me for once? is this a stopped clock situation? But I don’t think voting preference is…Nov 26, 16:23
    • Confused on A Personal Best For Kezia: “main, your main-talent seems to be to miss the point in several directions at once  I have never put in…Nov 26, 16:13
    • Confused on A Personal Best For Kezia: “he’s pissed because merrie olde england will break up long before scotland does – the point of indy is to…Nov 26, 16:12
    • diabloandco on A Personal Best For Kezia: “So if your days are filled with agony which persists over months even years , unable to take basic care…Nov 26, 16:05
    • Republicofscotland on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Apologies – the Mayor of Scotland’s ramblings will take place this week and not on our patron saints day.Nov 26, 16:05
    • Republicofscotland on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Sound bites – written by an obedient minions on the payroll to make this treacherous b*stard look good in the…Nov 26, 16:03
    • gregor on Telling the truth by mistake: “re. “The fact that he openly stated this tells us what his real priority is and whose agenda he is…Nov 26, 15:59
    • Robert McAllan on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Fucksake ah’m runnin’ oot o’ red ink!!!!Nov 26, 15:56
    • Republicofscotland on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Surprisingly Tammany Hall (Glasgow City Council) golden hands shakes to be looked into. “Glasgow council is hiring a KC to investigate…Nov 26, 15:50
    • Campbell Clansman on A Personal Best For Kezia: “You seem blithely unaware of “sarcasm” (as well as lots of other things). Any two year old could realize that…Nov 26, 15:47
    • Michael Laing on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Utterly unhinged garbage, Bellend. Which lump of steaming nonsensical yoon excrement are you going to regurgitate next? I think you’re…Nov 26, 15:45
    • Hatey McHateface on A Personal Best For Kezia: “That’s a good post, Confused. So what’s the previous one about? You been re-reading Jekyll & Hyde? Labour is going…Nov 26, 15:43
    • Republicofscotland on A Personal Best For Kezia: ““KATE Forbes is to take on a new role as Scotland’s “investment champion,” the Scottish Government has announced.” This is…Nov 26, 15:40
    • Michael Laing on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Fife, unlike Scotland, is not and never has been an independent nation, you utter moron. Fife, unlike Scotland, has no…Nov 26, 15:37
    • James on A Personal Best For Kezia: “That right, aye?Nov 26, 15:34
    • Young Lochinvar on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Gloriana; Oh heck! Fife (hypothetically)wants to go it alone.. Oh well that’s it then, let’s shelve the idea of Independence…Nov 26, 15:33
    • Hatey McHateface on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Bless. Another Scottish patriot who believes Indy is simply a case of waving your saltire. And if that doesn’t work…Nov 26, 15:29
    • James on A Personal Best For Kezia: “The Site Prick’s found a wee friend. Bless.Nov 26, 15:20
    • James on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Right on cue!Nov 26, 15:18
    • James on A Personal Best For Kezia: “They do say that you’re never more than 9 feet from a rat….there’ll be another one along any minute…..Nov 26, 15:17
    • James on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Never trust a Tory, Zander. Big LOLZ. Chief of the pudd’n race, Klan Klansman.Nov 26, 15:13
    • Campbell Clansman on A Personal Best For Kezia: “So you think Alba’s finding candidates in only 25.8% (8 of 31) of the council by-elections this year is a…Nov 26, 15:13
    • Confused on A Personal Best For Kezia: “assisted dying – the latest BBC news propaganda “current thing” another fucking brilliant idea, which won’t go wrong. Let’s rename…Nov 26, 15:10
    • Confused on A Personal Best For Kezia: “fife as an independent state has little reason or precedence, almost as poor a case for nation status as youkrine …Nov 26, 15:06
    • James on A Personal Best For Kezia: “R*ssians have already saved the world on two separate occasions (Nikita Khrushchev, Vasili Arkhipov) let’s hope (pray?) for a third.Nov 26, 15:03
    • Zander Tait on A Personal Best For Kezia: “How many council by elections did Alba actually contest, so far this year. Campbell? Try number 8Nov 26, 14:55
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
125
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x