The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Devo max: not so hard to define after all

Posted on November 13, 2011 by

We hitherto haven't bothered adding the Caledonian Mercury to the Wings over Scotland link bar, because it appeared to be all but dead. After a promising start, updates had slowed to a trickle on Stewart Kirkpatrick's bold attempt at creating a new online-only Scottish quality newspaper staffed by proper journalists from all points on the political spectrum, and most of the ones that did appear – in the politics section at least – were in the form of the toe-curling "Friday song" posts.

However, we may have been a little hasty, as the CalMerc this week ran a really interesting and exclusive piece by Hamish Macdonnell about some parts of the UK which are already governed under arrangements strikingly similar to what most people would describe as "devo max". The Isle Of Man, for example, has full fiscal autonomy and cedes control of only immigration and defence to the UK, a status that you suspect the SNP would consider a very acceptable step along the path to full independence, and which has plainly not resulted in the Isle's sky falling in.

But enough spoilers. You can read the full story here.

Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,757 Posts, 1,217,860 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Hatey McHateface on Barbie Stories: “You start with the bus. After a few years you graduate to a motor home. The keys to the Ferrari…May 16, 13:13
    • Hatey McHateface on Barbie Stories: “I have it on good authority (ahem) that one of the defining characteristics of Barbie (besides having a void between…May 16, 13:06
    • Hatey McHateface on Some Attention For James: ““In what world does a brutal invading force suddenly become the victim?” Ah ken that ane, Barbs, it’s Middle Earth…May 16, 12:56
    • stonefree on Barbie Stories: “It’s quite sad that Barbie’s Ferrari is a Pink & Pale Blue Bus & not from ParksMay 16, 12:55
    • duncanio on Barbie Stories: “I live in Edinburgh Southern and … I never thought I’d say this … thank Christ for Daniel Johnson. Phew!May 16, 12:51
    • Alison on Barbie Stories: “This is utterly shameful. I thought they’d pretty much sunk as far as they could with the ‘vote sexy’ messages…May 16, 12:50
    • James Barr Gardner on Some Attention For James: “Whin it comes to it awe the weel kent tory faces that jig that back intae ther lists seats afore…May 16, 12:47
    • Andrew Morton on Barbie Stories: “I remember when Edinburgh South was a rock solid Conservative seat with Michael Clark Hutchison as the MP.May 16, 12:46
    • Hatey McHateface on Some Attention For James: “It defo makes any alert reader wonder about the mental smarts of the Wings BTL posters who, only a couple…May 16, 12:44
    • Rogueslr on Barbie Stories: “So, if meth users can act out their fetish of cross dressing and sexual assault when high, does this mean…May 16, 12:35
    • Hatey McHateface on Barbie Stories: “Still, it’s grand to finally be able to put a face to the name 🙂May 16, 12:32
    • Effijy on Barbie Stories: “The people of Edinburgh will “Ken” fine. The pop band Human League were very poor musicians so they asked two…May 16, 12:30
    • ScottieDog on Barbie Stories: “Thought the hidden pic was going to be an Angus Robertson POVMay 16, 12:25
    • James Cheyne on Some Attention For James: “No negotiations can be made between Westminster parliament and Westminsters devolved parliament in Scotland. It would have to be turned…May 16, 11:53
    • James Cheyne on Some Attention For James: “ScottieDog What hat would wear while negotiating, If the devolved pariament in Scotland is Actually ‘ one and the same…May 16, 11:48
    • Scott on Some Attention For James: “Hi Stu, Hope you’re keeping well, family okay… DO YOU CONDEMN THE EXPULSION OF CHRIS MCELENY!? That’s literally what it…May 16, 11:43
    • James Cheyne on Some Attention For James: “Hatey McHateface, Indeed it would appear that a lot of Scots are unaware why the Devolved colonial Holywood parliament was…May 16, 11:24
    • Aidan on The Blindness Of Hatred: “@Xaracen – you are arguing in direct opposition to both the historical record and the explicit language of the treaty,…May 16, 10:59
    • Geri on Some Attention For James: “English water has just had a £3 billion bail out too & the fleecing is allegedly to pay bonuses. Welcome…May 16, 10:22
    • ScottieDog on Some Attention For James: “Right/wrong, ANY vote for the SNP is simply as wasted indy vote. The flip side of the very welcome self-destruction…May 16, 10:06
    • Vivian O’Blivion on Some Attention For James: “I would advise entering the pitchfork retail market. The Boss of the body which is supposed to regulate Scottish Water…May 16, 08:50
    • joolz on Some Attention For James: “Kelly will never debate you. Your recent piece debunking him was well researched and details the truth. All Kelly has…May 16, 08:29
    • Geri on Some Attention For James: “That was a terrible move by Roddy & given his past differences & open irritation to Salvo I don’t think…May 16, 03:21
    • Geri on Some Attention For James: “Message for James Kelly SNP 1 & 2 delivers Unionists. If SNP is set to win the constituency vote then…May 16, 03:10
    • Geri on Some Attention For James: “You do know that the reason they got a state in the first place was because the other side was…May 16, 02:54
    • Geri on Some Attention For James: “They play woke games because Westminster stripped Holyrood of powers after indyref & then again after & during Brexshit. That…May 16, 02:42
    • Geri on Some Attention For James: “Salmond should’ve had that ‘gentleman’s agreement’ in writing from Dewar & Sturgeon should’ve had the Smith one written in stone…May 16, 02:28
    • Geri on Some Attention For James: “The only comments btl that I’ve seen that support Isr are yoons/ paid trolls. I take issue too with the…May 16, 02:10
    • Big Jock on Some Attention For James: “The trouble with James is that he has always been an SNP cheerleader. Sure he did dabble with Alba, but…May 16, 00:51
    • sarah on Some Attention For James: “100% Yes: para 5 typo – Roddy and others have organised Liberate Scotland as an umbrella grouping for candidates in…May 15, 23:52
  • A tall tale



↑ Top