The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Author Archive


The unionist case for independence 149

Posted on May 15, 2014 by

The unionist case for Scots voting No in the independence referendum is encapsulated in the following quote from the website of “Better Together”, the official No campaign:

“Devolution offers us the best of both worlds: we have a strong Scottish Parliament taking important decisions about schools, hospitals and jobs AND we benefit from the strength, security and opportunities we can take advantage of being part of a bigger United Kingdom.”

The main problem with this argument is that there’s an alternative Union which would provide the Scottish Parliament with more powers to “take important decisions about” things and allow Scotland to “benefit from” and “take advantage of’” the “strength, security and opportunities” of being part of something far bigger than the UK itself.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,759 Posts, 1,217,991 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • ScottieDog on The Ace Attorney: “It would be really refreshingly honest if the SNP campaigned as such – English sovereignty over Scots. So even with…May 19, 17:33
    • James Cheyne on The Ace Attorney: “Tommy Sheppard, Ace Attorney, another one of the begging bowl great pretenders, that will ask for a pension from Scottish…May 19, 17:30
    • Mia on The Ace Attorney: “For as long as any politician who claims to pursue independence continues to hide like a disgusting coward behind the…May 19, 17:24
    • Ian McCubbin on The Ace Attorney: “I have heard bullshit, grifter talk and then there is Tommy Shepherd. The UK aka English government has no say…May 19, 17:21
    • Shug on The Ace Attorney: “Poke of chips for ShepherdMay 19, 17:20
    • Colin Dawson on The Ace Attorney: “It’s hard to tell whether Tommy Sheppard is completely thick, totally disingenuous, a quisling or something else. Any of these…May 19, 17:19
    • Mark Beggan on The Ace Attorney: ““You can’t handle the truth”May 19, 17:14
    • Jon Drummond on The Ace Attorney: “Thomas Sheppard has been one of the most duplicitous SNP grifters ever. He left Labour to follow the money as…May 19, 16:50
    • sarah on The Ace Attorney: “Send Tommy the Manifesto for Independence. I’m sure he will be grateful to be shown the exact steps to take.…May 19, 16:42
    • duncanio on The Ace Attorney: “The Cross Your Fingers Strategy for the umpteenth time. It’s ridiculous on another more important count: By simply accepting that…May 19, 16:41
    • Oneliner on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “And some serious sword falling required by the unelected civil disservants who overruled Calmac. The hybridistas who are intent on…May 19, 16:22
    • James Cheyne on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “I do not need to publish any of my comments over the many years here on wings regards the treaty…May 19, 15:06
    • Young Lochinvar on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “Wow! Latest smoke signals is quoting a £750m bill for the ferry fiasco! Double wow!! Another £250m and this farce…May 19, 14:53
    • Bob W on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “I’ve found https://xcancel.com/WingsScotland/with_replies to be very reliable.May 19, 13:13
    • Anthem on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “Oh I don’t know, the “magic bullet” seems to be working for Farage at the moment. ?May 19, 13:04
    • David on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “I wonder if you’ve got time, to do an article on the Labour Party performance. Every time I read the…May 19, 11:37
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “Attention is drawn particularly to the DEFINITIVE KEYNOTE SPEECH BY PROFESSOR ROBERT BLACK KC starting at 1.46.35 into youtube version…May 19, 11:11
    • Stuart MacKay on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “The “Cookie Law” does not cover cookies that are used for the normal functioning of the site – login sessions,…May 19, 10:57
    • Stuart MacKay on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “My point sailed in one ear and out the other. I posted a link about the American constitution – you…May 19, 10:51
    • Hatey McHateface on Well, this is a little embarrassing: ““always wish to close down the treaty of union topic by any means possible, even threats to Scotland” Hmmmm. I’m…May 19, 10:42
    • James Cheyne on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “Hatey McHateface, I recognise your point on how vunerable infrastruture is especially wire,cables and pipe lines, This does seem to…May 19, 10:24
    • James Cheyne on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “Englands parliament will manage to end the so called union, merger annexation by its presumptive arrogance, It does not need…May 19, 09:56
    • Breastplate on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “Make sure to check under your bed before going to sleep tonight, John.May 19, 09:49
    • Hatey McHateface on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “If you say so, James. I’m not really understanding who is threatening who. YL Sah! seemed to be suggesting that…May 19, 09:43
    • James Cheyne on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “If the Act of union was never signed does imply that the UK and intel are an illegal entity, that…May 19, 09:31
    • James Cheyne on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “Your statement at 7.36 am regards resources and assets is helpful to the independence supporters in confirming that Scotland is…May 19, 09:11
    • David on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “The haters gonna hate! It never fails to amaze me the amount of hate mail you get from all different…May 19, 07:48
    • Hatey McHateface on Well, this is a little embarrassing: ““How about a draft constitution? A set of well defined rules” How about you explain why any Sovereign Scot should…May 19, 07:42
    • Hatey McHateface on Well, this is a little embarrassing: ““these resources are only vulnerable if we are independent” It’s not exactly rocket science, YL Sah! At the moment these…May 19, 07:36
    • Young Lochinvar on Well, this is a little embarrassing: “You are left to (academically) wonder how the comfortable status quo for UK/US might alter completely if; 1. Dump the…May 19, 03:01
  • A tall tale



↑ Top