The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


When you’re in a hurry

Posted on December 19, 2013 by

…and you haven’t got time to think of a misleading headline or laboriously rewrite a “Better Together” press release into something that might just about pass for actual news reporting if viewed fleetingly in poor lighting conditions, you can do nearly as good a job of distorting the truth with just a quick C-switched-for-W keypress.

wouldcould

It’s a real Scottish-media time-saver!

We still need a good name for the phenomenon, though.

wouldcould1

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

71 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
colin mccartney

“Unionism” ?

naebd

“talking shite”?

Neil Mackenzie

Remember when John Major used to say “wunt” a lot and everyone thought he meant “want”?

Mike

“cwoulding”

steven luby

‘ahem’ shit,duck….lightening !

Bugger (the Panda)

The WC effect.

JPFife

So the first sentence says problems with Scotland being in a monetary union and the second sentence says problems with Scotland leaving a monetary union. Kind of sums up the Hootsman, Maddox et al.

ronnie cowan

Jabbertalky !

Alba4Eva

Ach, we all know its a load of CWap!

JPFife

Anyone actually seen this Fitch report they’re all quoting from? I haven’t been able to find it online, references in quote news unquote stories just say a report. Maybe it’s a secret?

Doug Daniel

Might I suggest the phrase “lying”?

scaredy cat.

I’ve been searching for it too. No success. Not even on Fitch’s website. Very strange.

Jenny

OT but… feeling some Christmas cheer after I noticed the Better Together Facebook likes are at 100k and the YES’s are at 113k.
🙂

Bill McLean

Maddox doesn’t know journalism from a dog’s breakfast – which is what his article is. Did all these duff journos train at the same place – and where was it? Scotsman readership down again – no wonder these clueless journos since Neil’s time have destroyed what was a quality paper! Now in world status British newspapers are rated “fair”. Scottish titles must be below that unbelievably!

Beastie

Oh yes, I spotted this pearl on the BBC News app a wee while ago.

Interestingly, on searching the app for it now, it seems to have vanished into the ether. Funny that. Perhaps Fitch took offence at it; wouldn’t be hard to see how. But I had the foresight to post it to Facebook, so I’ll give you the headline our ‘impartial’ national news service used.

‘Pound Unstable Under Independence.’

We pay for this. I personally wouldn’t, but the wife pays the TV Licensing and she does. I resent contributing to a service which is completely and utterly against independence, the SNP, the Scottish Government, and quite conceivably even the Scottish Parliament, because their paymasters are in London and they’re pulling the strings.

JPFife

scaredy cat  prime source seems to be Douglas Fraser at BBC Scotland.

Papadocx

Brittain means Engerland. Engerland means ENGERLAND. Anything else means we’re paying for it.

IainB

found what I believe is source material last night
link to fitchratings.com

JPFife

Thanks Iain – report is over a year old. No wonder they were reticent to mention the source of it.

Although might not be the one they are referring to as quote mentioned in papers do not appear in the one from October 2012

Macart

Instead of Rosetta how about Campbell Stone. An essential guide to filtering and translating double speak, project fear mince.

pa_broon74

What Maddox doesn’t pass on is Fitch was talking about the rest of the UK after independence – not Scotland.

thejourneyman

Bull Shit or Water buffalo Crap ie the WC effect?

JPFife

Just checking Stu, you do have news sniffer in your armory don’t you?
 
link to newssniffer.co.uk

Hetty

O/T
This I just read in a bbc article about prisoners losing a court battle to be granted the right to vote in the referendum next year, on the grounds that it could affect their human rights, for the following reason.

“And they claimed that the blanket ban was contrary to EU law because the result of the referendum would or might lead to the loss of European Union rights”. 

This is what Lord Glennie said about that:

“There is no direct link between the independence referendum and any decision as to future membership or citizenship of the EU”.

NGH1875

You could always try using one of these:
link to thescottishscaremonger.blogspot.co.uk

Jingly Jangly

The Fitch report is nonsense, talking about reduced income from North Sea and unlikely that Geographical share of oil reserves, they must have been reading a IFR report.

BTW any news on that tweet last night which the Beebs Fraser said something that the IFR had revised their forecast on Scottish GDP upwards?

A2

CWying

Les Wilson

I wonder what tack the Unionists would take if we said OK, we will take a route other than Sterling?
 
OH SHIT !  – I can hear it now from the corridors of power ! 

Neil

Cwunts

handclapping

I’d go for the CWap. Its probably a free download from the ap-store if you put the number of your “journalism” certificate in.
 
“Don’t be doubtful, be definite: use the CWap to make sure.”

Jamie Arriere

Obviously someone at Better Together just “found that Fitch report on the internet”…good job they removed the remark about keeping the AAA rating!

wee jamie

How about Blatant Unionists making massively erroneous remarks syndrome, or BUMMERS for short ?

beachthistle

My vote cwould go to ‘cwacking‘ – conflating the c-w interchange thing with the hacks that do it.
Works as a verb (to cwack)
noun (a cwack or cwacker) and
an adjective/whatever-it’s-called (ya cwacking so and so)

Jamie Arriere

If there is anyone…anyone with a shred of journalistic integrity left, might they ever ask the question why the recycling of a 14-month old report (obviously out-of-date since the UK AAA rating has since been lost) should constitute news!?

wee 162

Babblepish.

Buster Bloggs

What about nobbled / no-bbled

Training Day

You say ‘will’, and I say ‘could’
You say ‘might’, I say ‘definitely won’t’
Will, could, might, definitely won’t
Message to Westminster: LET’S CALL THE WHOLE THING OFF!

Alan Mackintosh

Dividing North Sea oil geographically would leave the residual UK with only 9% of reserves, if the split were made according to the Geneva Convention’s median line rules. But direct loss of government revenue to the residual UK could be offset by a reduction in fiscal transfers to Scotland. This, and the fact that UK oil revenue is forecast to decline in any case, would make the budgetary impact marginal.

The impact on the balance of payments of a geographical oil split could be bigger, making the residual UK a net oil importer of about 2% of GDP. However, an improvement in the non-oil trade deficit of the residual UK, reflecting the higher non-oil goods and services deficit for Scotland, could partly offset the loss of energy export receipts.

A geographical division of oil is an extreme outcome, as is a per capita division that would leave the residual UK with 92% of reserves. A compromise would be probably be reached.

From the Fitch report linked above. The last paragraph is a bit of a leap… Share the continental shelf per capita…
And how they think that ” A geographical division of oil is an extreme outcome…”

Aye, right

gillie

People should not forget the role that these credit agencies, like Fitch played in the banking and Eurozone crises. They didn’t foresee these crises. There ratings prior to these events were described as “catastrophically misleading”, and when they did act they all became “essential cogs in the wheels of financial destruction”.

Breastplate

Babblepish, I like it. Trips off the tongue rather nicely if you don’t know your unions.

gillie

Like a previous commentator said there seems to be no official documents and news releases on this from Fitch itself.
 
Has anyone tracked down the original news release? Was it issued from its New York or London offices.
 
It all seems mysterious.

Jimbo

“We still need a good name for the phenomenon, though.”
 
Dishonest?
Mendacious?
Duplicitous?

Vronsky

The charms of uncertainty, captured in the old rugby song:
 
I like the girls who say they will
I like the girls who don’t
I hate the girls who say they will
And then they say they won’t
But best of all I love the girls – you must agree I’m right
Who say they absolutely won’t – but look as though they might.

Jamie Arriere

Conlabdemious?

creigs1707repeal

O/T.
 
Has anyone else noticed that WoS has more access blips (downtime) than usual recently? I think I have found access problems to the site at least on 5 or 6 occasions over the past month. Just had another one 10 mins ago. Not sure what the cause is. Perhaps something to look into Rev.

Juan Pablo Del Roomigrant

Swaptalk, a handy writer’s tool.

creigs1707repeal

WCs

Jimbo

Maybe some-one could come up with an instruction book for Scots on how to interpret Unionist-speak. 
 
Unionism for Dummies?

Jingly Jangly

Yes I have noticed however its , probably due to the huge increase in traffic.
Also its not necessary WOS that’s the problem, may be your ISP has gone on a slowdown…
Many things can be the cause,
For example my WOS is ok just now but Facebook is slow as

Bertie K

CWisling BTrail

chalks
Chic McGregor

I recently coined an Orwellesque word to describe the behaviour of the dependency tendency somewhere but I forget where.  It was ‘Opspeak’ meaning to say something you know to be the opposite of reality.
 
Not yet, to be fair, a behavioural feature of the MSM (those residual elements from ethics lectures can still, despite their best efforts, be troublesome inhibitors can they not?)  
However, it has been a noticeably growing tendency from the more deranged actors from BT and unionist politician fraternity.

faolie

cwik, as in a cwik reality check

Andy-B

Sounds to me like a clear cut case of punsterism
 
Def. The use of words that have the same sound(could would should etc) but have different meanings.

Dcanmore

Coulda, shoulda, woulda; ifs buts and kindathings; mebbies aye mebbies naw… that pretty much sums up the Scottish MSM today. No real journalism just press releases going through the MSM filter to suit the editorial line, and that line is pro-Union.

Bertie K

CWunterism

CWuurency union
CWuntative easing
CWarnett formula

CWite simple really…

Andy-B

O/T
 
The Daily (drivel) Record today, see’s the Laurel and Hardy of journalism Clegg and Crichton reduced to two narrow margin columns barely four inches long (how refreshing).
 
First up Torcuil Chricton slams the Westminster co-alition government for jeering Margaret Curran when she speaks out about foodbanks across the UK, Crichton convienently forgets to mention though, that Curran and his Canary Wharf masters, support Westminsters power over Holyrood, albeit through a Labour led government.
 
Next up is Clegg who bleats on about how 36.000 Scots have had their benefits stopped by the Tory/Lib/Dem co-alition Government, Clegg even has the audacity to quote Nicola Sturgeons comments, stating that these measures are pushing the poor further into poverty.
 
Yet Cleggy boy can’t see past Westminsters rule over Scotland, pathetic why bleat on about poverty in Scotland Mr Clegg when its patently obvious Westminster calls the shots, agreeing with the Deputy First Minister of Scotland,whilst supporting Westminster, only enforces what people in Scotland already know, that you and and your journalistic kin at the Daily drivel, care more about the union than your fellow Scots.

Bertie K

Westminster?
Cessminster.
 
 For when you’re in a hurry

Fab001

Has Douglas Fraser ever written anything positive about independence? I very much doubt it, I’m sure BT will call him a highly trusted and impartial reporter. I might keep track of all the independence scare stories versus staying in the Union scare stories that feature on BBC Scotland’s website. Since yesterday its 2-0 to you know who, I’m guessing it will be a rout.

msean

Why not call it like it is.It is propaganda.That is all.

msean

Mind you,babblepish is funnier.

Brian Mark

Crap, Crap and more Crap, being an economic journalist is a bit like being one of the witches from Macbeth. We are all doomed I tell you, doomed! 

handclapping

Is babbelpish the one you stick in your ear and everything becomes clear?
No that was the Babelfish.
So is babbelpish the one where you stick your fingers in your ears and go La La La?
No that is Scottish Labour.
So is …
Its nothing to do with your ears. Its about reading and writing.
Give us a break. I’m only 3.
That’s no way to talk to a impartial and respected journalist.
< end irony >

Dcanmore

@Fab001
 
Douglas Fraser hasn’t written anything positive on any subject… ever. Just look at his mug!

G H Graham

Confunionism      
 
Con-funion-ism    noun \?kän-fyün-y?n,?ni-z?m’\
 
the principle or policy of forming or adhering to one meaning that has a completely different meaning as in

Would instead of could

Might instead of will

Should instead of shall

Bertie K

@G H Graham
😀

David McCann

I see one of the so called trusted sources hasadmitted getting  it wrong.
link to archive.is

gordoz

Heres a few ideas Rev –

How about ‘flying’ ( sort of fly-lying as it were ) clear and simple?

Or ‘kwisting’ (kwik twisting of meanings to attain advantage whilst appearing as a minor edit error).

Juteman

I haven’t read all the comments, but it’s obvious. C and W?
CodsWallop.

Ewan MacKenzie

How about W and C-ing.
 
Or wancing for short.

theycan'tbeserious

They speak with “furcked tongue”


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,666 Posts, 1,201,570 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Confused on How it happened: “kaku is a salesmen, and not a good one www.youtube.com/watch?v=cYv41WAtUooNov 8, 13:19
    • sam on How it happened: “God invented economists to make astrologers look good. Another financial crash?Nov 8, 13:18
    • TURABDIN on How it happened: “as someone intending to have a career in «physics» i like this quote which i consider has universal application. «There…Nov 8, 13:02
    • Young Lochinvar on How it happened: ““He”.. Your place of residence will be no defence when the hate police come calling for that piece of “hateful…Nov 8, 12:40
    • Young Lochinvar on How it happened: “No don’t think so, Mac is about right on reading the situation. Regarding end-ex being called upon release of hostages;…Nov 8, 12:31
    • Skip_NC on How it happened: “When Trump takes office and his political opponents criticize his policies (as they surely will, for that is the nature…Nov 8, 12:27
    • Umpteenth Steve on How it happened: “I used to say that the mainstream media’s power lies less in what it reports than in what it doesn’t…Nov 8, 12:20
    • Young Lochinvar on How it happened: ““The Goatfuck”.. What’s this got to do with David Cameron? Oh, sorry, my bad! It was pigs that he fucked…Nov 8, 12:17
    • sam on How it happened: “Dan, Just a little off your topic but maybe still of interest to you. Apology if not. https://climateaudit.org/?mod=588Nov 8, 12:05
    • Alf Baird on How it happened: “No surprise here whilst supposedly pro-independence intellectuals and ‘think-tanks’ remain in denial about our colonial reality. The penny will mebbe…Nov 8, 11:53
    • robertkknight on How it happened: “Plenty of proof out there if you care to look that the SNP has for nearly a decade been corrupted,…Nov 8, 11:40
    • Aidan on How it happened: “I don’t even get what the substance of your argument is here, you quote the same passages and lines about…Nov 8, 11:16
    • Dan on How it happened: “More on climate Armageddon… Ach,if we’re all doomed at least Robin had that nice holiday on the other side of…Nov 8, 11:09
    • Ruby on How it happened: “When you run out of things to say there’s always ‘The Franchise’Nov 8, 11:09
    • Tinto Chiel on How it happened: “Oh, I don’t know, Robert. maybe there’ll be a Dance The Wokey Cokey segment to give us all a good…Nov 8, 11:06
    • Mac on How it happened: “The stitch-up was fashioned around all the ‘Me Too’ stuff in the US, they borrowed heavily on that as that…Nov 8, 10:48
    • Alf Baird on How it happened: “His writing suggests rather a dislike of Scots, even great Scots; which is probably as good a reason as any…Nov 8, 10:47
    • TURABDIN on How it happened: “Scotland’s geoposition is too important for notions of anglospheric security. The half Scot President elect sees Scotland as a romantic…Nov 8, 10:45
    • Ruby on How it happened: ““‘someone’ was bringing in large numbers of ‘non-citizens’ to these swing states in an effort to turn them permanently blue”…Nov 8, 10:44
    • Robert Hughes on How it happened: “Aye , T.C ,It will no doubt be an evening of * Woke * Comedy : y’know that new style…Nov 8, 10:30
    • Skip_NC on How it happened: “This has been debunked. There are a few cases at each election where non-citizens, or convicted felons who have not…Nov 8, 10:28
    • Robert Hughes on How it happened: “Yes , and this from the Party screaming hysterically about ” Trump the Fascist ” intending to end * Democracy…Nov 8, 10:24
    • Mia on How it happened: ““do you doubt for a second they would have interfered in 2014” No. Not even for a millisecond. I am…Nov 8, 10:22
    • Mac on How it happened: “Yeah I think that is exactly what has happened. Is happening.Nov 8, 10:18
    • Mac on How it happened: “The results also confirm 2020 was rigged. Meaning Trump has now won three presential elections in a row. When was…Nov 8, 10:12
    • Mia on How it happened: ““‘someone’ was bringing in large numbers of ‘non-citizens’ to these swing states in an effort to turn them permanently blue”…Nov 8, 10:05
    • Mark Beggan on How it happened: “No.Nov 8, 10:01
    • TURABDIN on How it happened: “It’s PittsBURGH with an aitch. Pittsburgh was named in 1758, by General John Forbes, in honor of English statesman William Pitt. As…Nov 8, 09:54
    • Ruby on How it happened: “It’s Spanish! It means dawn in Spanish. Common name in Spain See Countess of Alba + Alba is a municipality…Nov 8, 09:37
    • Mac on How it happened: “Did anyone listen to any of Elon Musk’s talks in Pittsburg pre election or on Joe Rogan. The reasons he…Nov 8, 09:33
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
52
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x