The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



A different parallel 143

Posted on July 09, 2014 by

Last month we carried a view of the Scottish independence debate from the Canadian province of Quebec. Today we hear from the English-speaking side of the country.

In English-speaking Canada, few people seem to be aware of Scotland’s independence referendum. It doesn’t register much in the papers, much less our cheerfully oblivious TV news. The couple of friends I’ve told about it were interested, but mainly viewed the event as they would the World Cup: a distant, if intriguing, foreign phenomenon.

Conversely, Scotland’s view of Canada has been quite the opposite. Commentators on both the Yes and No sides have drawn explicit parallels with the Canadian experience, especially Quebec’s fraught history of referenda and sovereignty debate.

montreal

As a Canadian-American who’s spent a good deal of time south of the border, however, I think there’s a much more apt comparison to be made.

Canada’s bizarre love-hate relationship with our dysfunctional, arrogant, yet somehow still likeable neighbours and friends in the United States of America is both cautionary and optimistic. And it indicates the absolute need for a Yes vote.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,754 Posts, 1,217,670 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • ross on The Blindness Of Hatred: “on a vote share of circa 30% there are plenty seats more up for grabs than you are making out…May 13, 17:09
    • Owen Mullions on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Day 5 of James ‘I’m not obsessed’ Kelly posting about Rev Stu rather than independence. Thankfully, Eurovision should take his…May 13, 16:28
    • agent x on The Blindness Of Hatred: ““some of my posts are being delayed or not appearing at all,” ——————————————————– As you seem determined to take over…May 13, 16:19
    • James Cheyne on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Stu. Is everyone having problems posting today, or just a few, do you know,May 13, 14:18
    • James Cheyne on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Amthem some of my posts are being delayed or not appearing at all, but I did respond to your last…May 13, 14:13
    • James Cheyne on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Anthem, It is the ability of Westminster having two two governing bodies over Scotland bringing in two tiers of laws…May 13, 14:05
    • James Cheyne on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Xaracen. How do you square the voting system for Scots to have representatives in the parliament of Great Britain, Westminster…May 13, 13:42
    • Anthem on The Blindness Of Hatred: “But surely Westminster/English based parties can’t vote on Scottish only matters. As in the similar unwritten rule in Westminster? If…May 13, 13:34
    • Mark Beggan on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Blinded by power and control. The only cure for the far left is the far right.In the land of the…May 13, 13:25
    • Xaracen on The Blindness Of Hatred: ““The concept of the ‘sovereign Scots’ is interesting.” It is, you should look into it. A Real and Ancient ConstitutionMay 13, 12:20
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Haven’t you decided we’re all doomed? It’s obvious enough that your real gripe is that you disagree with what a…May 13, 12:11
    • factchecker on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Actually, Marie, I’m not sure they have ever decided anything. You can’t really make a decision on something you haven’t…May 13, 11:39
    • Skip_NC on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Ah, but it depends a lot on how you define “get who you voted for.” Local? National? Mixture? If local,…May 13, 10:57
    • Marie on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Scots don’t decide anything – they haven’t decided anything for hundreds of years.May 13, 10:47
    • Rob on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Are folk here making the claim that the existing SP voting system works and is somehow better than WM? Really?May 13, 09:49
    • James Cheyne on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Which hat will the parliament in Scotland be wearing when it votes for the assisted dying bill in or out…May 13, 09:48
    • James Cheyne on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Governments are there to govern the people within reason, not to make a personal profits from the proceeds of selling…May 13, 09:26
    • James Cheyne on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Skip-NC, No Skip I do Not, Iam am just suggesting that we simplify the system in Scotland so you actually…May 13, 09:01
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Today’s vote on the assisted dying bill will hold up a mirror to the true opinions of our legislative elite.…May 13, 07:33
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Not just yoons. Anybody who even looks like they might not see eye-to-eye with you on everything. Why take chances?May 13, 07:22
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blindness Of Hatred: “You’re 74 TH, so surely ideal guinea pig material. Why don’t you step up to the plate and give the…May 13, 07:15
    • GM on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Yes, a good writer. I don’t know here bu A genuine person I believe. I read her articles.May 12, 22:45
    • Anthem on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Totally agree James. I’ve suggested many times that it will be English mps at Westminster that’ll cause the union to…May 12, 21:17
    • Dan on The Blindness Of Hatred: “I’m appreciative of a lot of Leah Gunn Barrett’s output. https://dearscotland.substack.com/p/privatisation-foreign-ownership-and It sure beats a pair of dung beetles argybargying…May 12, 20:14
    • Robert Matthews on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Great idea sarah, i think i will too.May 12, 19:44
    • Skip_NC on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Sarah, ach, I wonder if Alba senior leadership is still struggling with Alex’s death. There is a lot of talk…May 12, 19:32
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Dishonesty is the hallmark of how he handles all interactions with anyone.May 12, 19:27
    • Skip_NC on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Do you really want a system where two main parties take turns at being an elective dictatorship? It’s all very…May 12, 19:19
    • George Ferguson on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Good article Stu on the Electoral Stats. One thing I would have commented on was the win versus expenses ratio.…May 12, 18:53
    • James Cheyne on The Blindness Of Hatred: “MaryB, When we get around to running our own parliament perhaps it would be wiser to just count a single…May 12, 18:29
  • A tall tale



↑ Top