The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



A different parallel 143

Posted on July 09, 2014 by

Last month we carried a view of the Scottish independence debate from the Canadian province of Quebec. Today we hear from the English-speaking side of the country.

In English-speaking Canada, few people seem to be aware of Scotland’s independence referendum. It doesn’t register much in the papers, much less our cheerfully oblivious TV news. The couple of friends I’ve told about it were interested, but mainly viewed the event as they would the World Cup: a distant, if intriguing, foreign phenomenon.

Conversely, Scotland’s view of Canada has been quite the opposite. Commentators on both the Yes and No sides have drawn explicit parallels with the Canadian experience, especially Quebec’s fraught history of referenda and sovereignty debate.

montreal

As a Canadian-American who’s spent a good deal of time south of the border, however, I think there’s a much more apt comparison to be made.

Canada’s bizarre love-hate relationship with our dysfunctional, arrogant, yet somehow still likeable neighbours and friends in the United States of America is both cautionary and optimistic. And it indicates the absolute need for a Yes vote.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,765 Posts, 1,218,925 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Alf Baird on The Blackout: “In a colonial society the issue is not simply where one is born, tho that is important, but whether they…May 31, 13:30
    • Mark Beggan on The Blackout: “Dornan wanted to be a gangster when he was growing up in Glasgow. But he wasn’t hard enough. So he…May 31, 13:30
    • Mark Beggan on The Blackout: “Dornan spirs his dummy because the wee Neddy Irish Arsehole Rappers have been removed from TRNSMT. And this prick is…May 31, 13:14
    • Ian Stewart on Tell Them You’re Frightened: “Ah Larkhall! Fond memories as the place of my childhood, and the butt of so many jokes from my catholic…May 31, 13:08
    • Stoker on The Blackout: “Road reopens and motorhome recovered after overturning Peter Murrell found…May 31, 13:01
    • Mark Beggan on The Blackout: “‘crass lack of judgement ‘ More like Cold Calculated Conspiracy from Dikola and her bum boys.May 31, 12:55
    • Dan on The Blackout: “Aye, I guess agent x has had a wee memory lapse and forgotten about the rainbow coloured bare butt dildo…May 31, 12:53
    • Confused on The Blackout: “James list of treatments looks to be priced on the low side from what I have read. For the n-teenth…May 31, 12:45
    • Northcode on The Blackout: “Lo, ther dae a see ma faither. Lo, ther dae a see ma mither, an ma grannies, an ma grandas.…May 31, 12:37
    • Mia on The Blackout: “Yeah, and who was in UK government when the nonsense of trans ideology and stonewall infiltrated every UK public service…May 31, 12:23
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blackout: “Sorry, James, I didn’t see lobotomy on your list of work you’ve had done. You do always seem to be…May 31, 12:16
    • Nae Need! on The Blackout: “This is a good idea. Business card size, with URL and QR code. I’d happily contribute to a crowd-funder. And…May 31, 12:09
    • James on The Blackout: “Shiteface; “…Born in Scotland. Apart from 6 months south of the border working a contract, have spent all of my…May 31, 12:06
    • agent x on The Blackout: “NHS Fife’s ‘culture of secrecy’ blasted as its trans policy meetings not recorded Exclusive: The health board initially claimed it…May 31, 12:03
    • Nae Need! on The Blackout: “Defo worth investigating. It’s not just they’ve NOT been rounded up, it’s the fact that they are being actively facilitated/encouraged…May 31, 11:59
    • agent x on The Blackout: “People should not forget that is was the UK Colonial Masters Tory party that blocked the The Gender Recognition Reform…May 31, 11:57
    • James on The Blackout: “Was your lobotomy, Shiteface?May 31, 11:57
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blackout: ““We are no more “free” than your average North Korean” It is quite impossible for you to not know that…May 31, 11:48
    • agent x on The Blackout: ““financial theft, illegal work practices, and misappropriation of funds.” Those matters should be reported to the Police.May 31, 11:47
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blackout: “Hmmm, let’s see. Born in Scotland. Apart from 6 months south of the border working a contract, have spent all…May 31, 11:41
    • Maxxmacc on The Blackout: “I worked for a Glasgow charity pairing poor Africans (Uganda) with Scots who paid money to individuals to try to…May 31, 11:12
    • Marie on The Blackout: “The political classes do not represent ordinary working people. The political classes are captured and they shill for a vanishingly…May 31, 11:09
    • Alf Baird on The Blackout: ““chattering intellectual born stinking out of the thigh of Nietzsche” Yes, it would seem to fit well on any colonizer’s…May 31, 11:08
    • Andrew on The Blackout: “Any “independence” supporter who votes for a unionist party is a traitor to the cause. I can completely understand not…May 31, 10:58
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blackout: ““chattering intellectual born stinking out of the thigh of Nietzsche” That one has a certain je ne sais quoi, Alf.…May 31, 10:43
    • Willie on The Blackout: “This article exposes on detail just how utterly ineffective and rotten the OSCR is as a regulator. It makes a…May 31, 10:28
    • Doug McGregor on The Blackout: “https://www.oscr.org.uk/about-oscr/who-we-are/oscr-board/ For those who want to know a bit more about OSCR , another well heeled quango.May 31, 10:19
    • Mia on The Blackout: “If a QR code for this article is added to the leaflet, there is no need for the reader to…May 31, 10:14
    • Alf Baird on The Blackout: “There are plentiful ‘goitrous academics’ in Scotland who are naturally opposed to, or at best ambivalent about the liberation of…May 31, 10:10
    • Stoker on The Blackout: “sarah says on 30 May 2025 at 10:10 pm: “Rev, I have revised my suggestion made at 3.31. To make…May 31, 09:04
  • A tall tale



↑ Top