The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Part of the Union?

Posted on November 19, 2011 by

The growing rift between Labour and the trade union movement in Scotland was highlighted yesterday by a statement from the STUC flatly contradicting the narrative spun by all three opposition parties this week, namely that that uncertainty over the date of the independence referendum was damaging the prospects of business investment in Scotland.

In a statement striking for its lack of ambiguity, an unnamed spokesman for the congress was reported by the Scotsman as saying that the unions "had come across no evidence that the forthcoming poll was deterring investment in the country", and that as a result it "did not believe it was necessary to hold a referendum as soon as possible, as is being urged by both the UK government and opposition parties", adding that "There are far more immediate problems that need to be looked at."

Oddly, this fairly dramatic divergence of opinion was afforded just 126 words by the paper, compared to the 2,348 devoted to Douglas Alexander's rather less newsworthy speech to a Labour youth conference.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

2 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Captain Caveman

… Interesting Blog, Stu, well worth a read for Sassenachs such as I who (infamously) know bugger all about the various dynamics of Scottish politics. My sentiments differ largely entirely of course, but a good read is a good read, most especially an off-script, off message one that isn't borne of the lapdog, mainstream media.
 
As far as this piece goes, I did chuckle at the '…there are far more immediate problems that need to be looked at' observation from the union spokesperson – ain't that the truth. (In fact, I genuinely believe the catastrophic unravelling of the Euro, the now demonstrable beyond any reasonable doubt abject failure of Social Democracy, left-of-centre politics of Europe and all the rest will make the average Scots citizen far, far more wary of full independence and the 'spend, spend, spend' old-Labour politics of the SNP in general, and I reckon the SNP are well aware of this. Hence their 'easy does it', distinctly un-bullish stance in all of this, viz a vie their independence referendum? Albeit, I could have misinterpreted the mood music entirely, wouldn't be the first time).
 
Mind you, "incertainty"…? Tsk old chap, tsk. 🙂


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,684 Posts, 1,207,455 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Cynicus on Where We Stand Now: ““Nobody remotely connected with reality is buying the nativist snake oil.” ===== Don’t be unkind. In this postmodern age there…Jan 6, 00:37
    • Shug on Where We Stand Now: “Can you name the plants that drafted this nonplan. We need to list the kompromatsJan 5, 23:52
    • gregor on Where We Stand Now: “The video I posted in response to your post, appears to have vanished from my feed (hopefully just a glitch…Jan 5, 23:45
    • gregor on Once more around: “Cheers Fearghas. Informative video. re. “So many issues discussed are common to Scotland.” Without doubt.Jan 5, 23:30
    • gregor on Where We Stand Now: “Patriot: “A person who loves their country and, if necessary, will fight for it.”: https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/patriot #LoveYouScotlandJan 5, 23:12
    • gregor on Where We Stand Now: “Medium: The Relationship Between Personal Beliefs And Reality, Reality And Personal Reality: “Reality as we know it seems to have…Jan 5, 22:56
    • Geri on Where We Stand Now: “You aren’t a Scot. You’re a British nationalist. I expect unionists will move to what’s left of their mother ship.…Jan 5, 22:43
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Once more around: “This interview with Pierre Poilievre suggests what a post-Trudeau Canada might look like. So many issues discussed are common to…Jan 5, 22:42
    • Geri on Where We Stand Now: “They’re not interested in Independence. If they had 99% of the entire electorate voting for them they’d still bottle it.…Jan 5, 22:21
    • gregor on Once more around: “Toronto Sun (2025): Mississauga mayor says radical Islam conference not welcome: “While scheduled to be held Jan. 18, so far…Jan 5, 22:19
    • David Hannah on Where We Stand Now: “Only Alex Salmond’s family, can deliver justice for Scotland by exposing criminal conspirator Nicola Sturgeon and her partner in crime,…Jan 5, 22:07
    • Andy Ellis on Where We Stand Now: “Why would they magically do this now having not done so before? It’s the elephant in the room for the…Jan 5, 22:01
    • Campbell Clansman on Where We Stand Now: “After 30+ years of agitating, only 18% of eligible Scottish voters voted for Indy parties in 2024.Jan 5, 22:00
    • Mia on Where We Stand Now: ““The layers of deception are beginning to peel off” Absolutely. I agree 100% on the above. What I am not…Jan 5, 21:50
    • Young Lochinvar on Once more around: “Once Branchform is done, and if there is any justice, the NuSNP will be truly finished- dead on the altar…Jan 5, 21:49
    • Geri on Where We Stand Now: “The West is a minority. They have the biggest mouth, for now, due to coercion & illegal sanctions but that’s…Jan 5, 21:34
    • alan scott on Where We Stand Now: “As a twat and a piece of despicable scum who does not support breaking up the United Kingdom you tell…Jan 5, 21:30
    • Geri on Where We Stand Now: “Everyone except the G7.Jan 5, 21:27
    • James Gardner on Where We Stand Now: “The fact that there is a large number of non-voting electorate yet the SNP still trying to get so called…Jan 5, 21:16
    • gregor on Where We Stand Now: “Express it allJan 5, 21:14
    • gregor on Where We Stand Now: “Sorry to disappoint you, Evil_c #FreedomJan 5, 21:13
    • Aidan on Where We Stand Now: “Could you provide me with a list of countries who are highly regarded on the International stage?Jan 5, 21:04
    • Aidan on Where We Stand Now: “Don’t be so dismissive, those 186 votes could easily affect the outcome of a parish council election. Causes that enjoy…Jan 5, 21:00
    • Geri on Where We Stand Now: “The delusion is strong in you. The UK is a joke on the international stage & they know all too…Jan 5, 20:49
    • willie on Where We Stand Now: “Away with ye Peter McAvoy. Stripping the pensioners of the winter heating allowance is a wizard idea. If they are…Jan 5, 20:46
    • Geri on Where We Stand Now: “Suck it up , sunshine. That’s the Union for you… independence supporters voted to leave that set up & keep…Jan 5, 20:39
    • Aidan on Where We Stand Now: “Liberation is not going to get Scotland listed as a non-self governing territory though so all of the consequences that…Jan 5, 20:39
    • Republicofscotland on Where We Stand Now: “The Scottish taxpayer is bank rolling this known sex pest. “A shamed former SNP MP who sexually harassed a teenage…Jan 5, 20:37
    • gregor on Where We Stand Now: “Kid: “A child: He took the kids to the park while I was working.”: https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/kidJan 5, 20:24
    • Confused on Once more around: “– that “rodent” is a civic animalist and is a “new squirrel”. Dan should be minister for offgrid, come the…Jan 5, 20:22
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
141
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x