The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Making your mind up

Posted on January 21, 2014 by

ukfacts2

(Source here.)

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

69 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Pedro

Did Anas Sarah write that leaflet? He’s got a different answer to the same question for each day of the week.

Ally

Yet another two reasons to vote YES

kalmar

Well, ‘as we know it’ includes Scotland. It’s not wrong, logically speaking, is it. Just pish.

Murray McCallum

There’s a simple known unknown in the pamphlet.

“Independence is the end of the United Kingdom as we know it” Correct.

“The UK would still go on without Scotland” Correct

Where “UK” = Unknown Kingdom.

Pedro

Woops! Sarwar, I meant.

Ericmac

I have just watched The Referendum Debate (coming from Greenock)
Alex Massie pretending to be unbiased and undecided.
Sarwar pretending to be honest.
Hislop pretending to debate
And some comedian pretending he knew something about politics.

As for the audience, apart from a few that managed to speak out, they were pretending to be informed.

What a disaster this country is turning out to be. Scotland really is too stupid. I’d blame Westminster brainwashing, but really it’s about the people getting off their backsides and getting informed about the whole debate.

Tonights programme was one complete pile of ignorance and I am disgusted.

Ericmac

We need a real debate with real people, not liars, comedians and pretentious tory bloggers.

Andrew Morton

I set the recorder for the debate but as usual cocked it up (where are all the ten year olds when you need ’em?).

Is it on IPlayer?

scottish_skier

“The UK would still go on without Scotland”

Is this leaflet not for people in EW & NI?

Derek

0/10 – See Me – (in red pen!)

“And works well.”

What kind of a sentence is that? It demonstrates the sacrifice of structure to try to convey speech on paper.

Please hire a new proofreader, if only for the sake of my sanity. And no, I’m not a teacher.

caz-m

@Scottish_skier

Did you see the poll on STV tonight. I think it is that Social Attitudes poll.

Marian

Ericmac:

If this is what the BBC plan to have as “debates” during the campaign then the people of Scotland will end up no wiser afterwards than they were before.

If I was a cynic I would suggest that it looks suspiciously like this outcome was what the BBC and their chums in Project Fear wanted.

cirsium

@Ericmac

Tonights programme was one complete pile of ignorance and I am disgusted.

It strikes me that this is the response which the BBC in Scotland was looking for.

The audience was vetted. What did you expect?

Alba4Eva

I dont watch TV, cos I don’t pay the TV tax… what was the Greenock, BBC debate programme called, so I can get in on iplayer or youtube? Thanks in advance.

creigs1707repeal

As usual – Better Together say one thing in public and then another thing in public.

Flower of Scotland

So Prof. Curtis slips from STV studios to BBC Newsnight with his doom and gloom . Is he the only Academic that they can find to discuss the Referendum ! It’s absolutely shameful !

Thepnr

The statements are of course contradictory but only one of them is true.

“Independence is the end of the United Kingdom as we know it”

Anybody any complaints?

HandandShrimp

I said this on the previous thread but I see the Social Attitudes poll pretty much ignores the ballot paper and still runs with a Devo Max option. That is fair enough but we already know there is a roughly equal three way split. Devo Max is not on the table. We need to ensure the Devo Max supporters realise that and take the most logical second option for them which is independence.

westie7

I still think the reason muppets like Curtis are including Devo Max is that it might become a unionist emergency fall back for when they think they are about to lose

caz-m

@Scottish_skier

Link to those poll results from ScotCen and Prof Curtis.

link to blog.whatscotlandthinks.org

westie7

Can someone tell me what hyslop said that has got BBC news and Sarwar jumping up and down over on BBC Scotland website?

X_Sticks

Alba4Eva says:
“what was the Greenock, BBC debate programme called”

link to bbc.co.uk

Hardly worth the bother Alba4Eva. Not a great debate.

Alba4Eva

Thanks Sticks.

Just made a wee post on Curtis ‘the only pollster in the wests’ blog.

link to blog.whatscotlandthinks.org

Ps. Im Bongobrian on the Disqus thingy.

Alan Mackintosh

Alba4eva

link to bbc.co.uk

And of course any others…

Chic McGregor

I think the problem AnSa has is that he says one thing in a sentence and another in the same sentence.

The Penman

Let’s be realistic here. What we saw there tonight was a reflection of:
1) Where the uninformed public are at (Sanjeev Kholi) – uninformed, not taken the time took into it, open to a good argument but politically lazy.
2) where the informed public are at (the audience) – calling Anas’ bullshit for what it is, able to cut to the salient facts and points. Passionate, persuasive, and turning Yes rapidly.
3) Where the politicians are (Anas, Fiona, Alex – who is the Scottish Tory voice there) – well-entrenched battle grounds, able to lose punters’ interest quickly.
4) where the BBC thinks the debate is at – low info, first pass at the big issues, missing the key points, patronising Burns question to wrap up.

That’s our fight now – to turn the “Kholis” into “audience members” and leave the politicians to the BBC game.

Alba4Eva

Many thanks Alan… also, that was a nice example why no one needs to pay for the BBC and still always get to see what they are interested in. I actually found a BBC page that said it would be available a week after broadcast. Obviously change of mind at the BBC then. Sticks mibbes right, but if I fall asleep during it at this hour, then happy da… nights 🙂

Doug Daniel

The Penman – spot on. I reckon any undecided voter watching tonight would have noticed that the informed audience members were all pro-Yes and the dimwits were all No. Not only that, but there was a variety of folk who were for Yes, whereas all the No folk seemed to be old baldy stuck-up blokes.

I dunno what people are expecting – the pro-indy audience members got a very fair crack at the whip tonight. You can hardly expect them to have NO unionist dunces asking stuff. Let’s be realistic about this – the BBC and co are not simply going to say “hey, let’s have a whole audience of Yes voters!”

X_Sticks

The Penman says:

“That’s our fight now – to turn the “Kholis” into “audience members” and leave the politicians to the BBC game.”

Pretty good analysis Penman.

Disappointed in Khohli. Didn’t he say he was pro indy at the rally in Edinburgh? He certainly came across that way. Maybe just my failing memory.

Chic McGregor

@Alba4Eva

Nice one. 😉

Doug Daniel

Also, maybe worth pointing out that while the media does rely on Curtice FAR too much, there was at least a fairly good reason for him being on both programmes tonight – it was the annual Scottish Attitudes Survey which he presides over.

Of course, you could easily argue that this is actually an argument for NOT having him on, since he’s hardly going to he objective about his own research…

Doug Daniel

X-Sticks – that was his brother, Hardeep.

Dave McEwan Hill

X Sticks
That was his brother

Trevor the Squirrel

O/T

Hi I am a rather regular lurker here and YES voter, on the subject of BBC debates I am due to attend the one being recorded tomorrow at Dundee for Question Time, I know…….Anyway I appear to have to supply two questions which may or may not be used. I was considering one might be, “What if any new powers is the Scottish Parliament GUARANTEED if we vote no?”

This is probably a less than cunning plan but was hoping it might expose false promises etc. No idea why I got selected, possibly because I am a woman/SNP voter? Anyhow any other suggestions?

BBC Scotlandshire

The problem is that when you just make it all up, it can be devilishly hard to keep it consistent. We make it up all the time, but BT are simply not as good at it.

Derek

Regarding Sanjeev; it’s probably not a bad thing to have someone fairly media-savvy in the “undecided” camp. If they’re on the TV often enough (and questioned), then that might influence others.

Whether that’s a good thing depends on which side of the fence he chooses…

boglestone

I like the idea of Yachting Together.

Les Wilson

I watched the debate from Greenock tonight, it was still weighed to a NO vote, Sanwar was allowed to go from a question, into other areas in order to attack the SNP. Several times when Fiona tried to answer him back, the chair would not allow it, ” oh we need to get on!”.

It was a exceedingly poor debate, and to me it still seemed 3-1,against Fiona.The “comedian” was not funny at all, just showed he knew FA about the subject.

CJ

Doug Daniel I’m with you here, I think seeing normal passionate people in these debates is a big vote winner as long as they are informed enough. I was surprised just how informed some of the audience were to be honest. Here’s hoping some more average punters in future debates don’t hold back in calling the Westminster lot a bunch of lying thieves hell bent on destroying Scots self confidence for their own narrow British nationalism and perks.

James123

I rarely watch these debates and I didn’t watch this one. They’re usually a complete and utter disappointment, mostly uninformative, tepid and facile affairs. This is the most interesting time in our country’s history but you would barely know it after watching this kind of drivel.

Alba4Eva

Ps. Still awake… damn! LOL… Just finished watching the debate and the one thing that struck me was that there was quite a number of young women who were either obvious yessers or going in that direction… and as Doug Daniel elequently stated above;”All the No folk seemed to be old baldy stuck up blokes”

…i’m buying right into the belief that the recent past reports of women being less inclined to independence was infact another total unionist-media-propaganda lie.

Truth

@The Penman

That was his brother Hardeep at the Edinburgh Rally.

Thanks for the links and I just spent the last hour watching the debate. I was actually reasonably uplifted by the programme.

The audience were vocally pro-yes, and Sarwar got savaged on several occasions. Hyslop came over well, and I think would appeal to the female vote, and the variety of people backing yes in the audience was excellent.

On balance, I believe an undecided watching that would be leaning more to yes afterwards.

Truth

Sorry, my screen was out of date and I see others have advised a different Kholi was at the Edinburgh Rally.

Also noticed I should have @x-sticks, so apologies to penman.

Off to bed for me!

Andrew Morton

@Alba4Eva

Watching this reminded me of the Better Together meeting in Musselburgh. All the old buggers ranting are yer actual Tories. Their world view is a frightening one based on class and ‘Imperial Values’. They probably toddled off home to have a pre bedtime Chota peg.

Andrew Morton

The trouble with Hyslop is that she can’t do a killer punch line, it’s all “On the one hand this and on the other hand that.”

Alba4Eva

Thanks Chic. 🙂

…and James123; I agree with you however, there was a couple of good highlights. The lass that got tore right into Sarwar was classic. I did find myself shouting at my phone (happened to be where I watched it… and musta looked quite bizarre lol), cos Fiona had opportunities to rip right in and score points, but missed them.

I fully agree with Les Wilson. How many times is the ‘undecided’ partnered with the pro-independence guest? Have you ever seen 2 pro-independence proponents pitted against a solitary unionist and an undecided? If not, then why?

Andrew Morton

The one positive thing about all those old Tories is that statistically, more of them will die before September than Yes supporters, who seem to have a younger age profile.

James123

@Andrew Morton

The one positive thing about all those old Tories is that statistically, more of them will die before September than Yes supporters, who seem to have a younger age profile.

That is a dark comment Andrew, made me laugh though.

Alba4Eva

Haha… must be good for at least 0.5% over the next 8 months. LOL

john king

Andrew Morton says
“The one positive thing about all those old Tories is that statistically, more of them will die before September than Yes supporters, who seem to have a younger age profile.”

Yes but what guarantees do we have of that? 😉

Baring in mind we as a country are aging faster do you think we can breed a million new yes voters before September?

Lets get to it troops 🙂

Eric McLean

@doug Daniel
I dunno what people are expecting – the pro-indy audience members got a very fair crack at the whip tonight. You can hardly expect them to have NO unionist dunces asking stuff. Let’s be realistic about this – the BBC and co are not simply going to say “hey, let’s have a whole audience of Yes voters!”

With respect, I think you watched another program. I am not one to cry ‘foul’ at every tough debate or throw my toys out the pram because the audience wasn’t full of Yes voters.

This debate purported to be balanced. From the beginning it was biased, by giving Massie an undecided platform from which to preach unionist propaganda. Sarwar was allowed repeatedly to makes false political soundbites way beyond the original question…

Need I go on… I think that’s probably enough.

What we need is a proper debate without MPs, comedians and Tory bloggers masquerading as undecided (have you ever read any of his column?) ….

In any case, that was the last time I will watch this sort of crap. It was worse than reading the Scotsman, listening to Lola on FMQT and a dose of the skitters all at the same time.

CameronB

Looks like the NatWest has thrown its hat into the ring. Got this sent to me yesterday. 🙂

NatWest
To Me
Jan 21 at 10:32 PM

What’s the most powerful word?

We’re all about being helpful. Let us tell you about things you’d like.

Being a NatWest customer has its benefits. Let us share them with you.

Great things happen when you say ‘yes’. You go on a date. You move house. You discover a food you love. And now we’d like you to say yes to us.

We’d like to send you emails about things you could be interested in. Things like helpful tools, exciting rewards and latest offers.

At the moment we can’t tell you about these things because we don’t have permission to send you marketing emails about your banking*.

Stay in the know and simply update your settings in just one click below.

Say YES
You can always say no later.

Albalha

Re the BBC ‘debate’ last night.

Over on twitter A Massie is saying he told them he was a’persuadable'(NO) not an undecided, quite different.

S Kohli seemed disinterested to me. He’s not even that much of a name, odd choice.

And why is Mentorn producing it? Thought BBC Scotland had a shiny new referendum unit headed by some crack former newspaper editor.

Ken500

Why do people watch this crap and then complain about it?

Don’t watch it!

Easy

Eric McLean

“Does the panel agree that independence would massively revitalise Scottish politics, and if not why not?”

To what extent is Westminster responsible for the dire economic circumstances of Scotland and how would remaining in the union guarantee improvement?

How does the panel justify the enormous disparity in wealth and health, including life expectancy between Glasgow and London?

Do the panel agree that there is too much, big society, one nation, all together, rhetoric from southern political parties, and not enough action to fix the things that matter in people’s communities?

john king

Eric McLean says
“listening to Lola on FMQT and a dose of the skitters all at the same time.”

Oh I dont know a dose of the skitters can be a very cathartic experience 🙂

O/t
BBC Scotland news @ 07.00 gives the labour spokesman (Drew Smith MSP) free kick at the ball with no response ref the social attitudes survey, but @ 07.30 lo and behold Nichola Sturgeons input suddenly appears, anyone keeping score?

john king

@ME baring? d-oh meant bearing mea culpa

Alastair wright

That headline made me think of Darling, Carmichael, Lamont and Davidson (Ruth) doing a karaoke number only it was the Alastairs having their kilts ripped off to reveal they weren’t true Scotsmen. Sorry for the image folks!

Brian Mark

Watched the debate last night, the quality of speakers on the panel ranged from aright to piss poor. What we need is a punters panel so we can have a proper debate.

Robert young

Watched the debate last night. Sarwars a liar trying to claim he didn’t miss the vote on the bedroom tax, Alex” right wing tory” was so obviously a no he was more a no than anus. I thought for a moment the lass shouting at anus was about to get out of her seat and lamp him. Also anyone notice the dirty looks he was giving anyone who dared question him? It looked like don’t question me I’m an mp

SoDa

“Fourth panel member, journalist Alex Massie, described the Trident debate as a “non-issue”, adding: “That idea that anyone would base your vote upon independence in the referendum on it strikes me as being banal, trivial and tedious.””

I dont see the Trident situation as trivial. I dont think its banal to oppose their existence a stones throw away from Glasgow. I dont think its tedious to voice my concern that it naturally makes us a target or that the substantial amount of monies spent on them is unworthy of debate. I also think it is an important issue in regard to independence from Westminster. Maybe that’s just me tho…

SoDa

So even after yesterdays boot on the stovies, the BBC is still at it. Not sure which debate they watched but i’m sure i saw a different one!

link to bbc.co.uk

Ericmac

Stu

“To what extent is Westminster responsible for the dire economic circumstances of Scotland and how would remaining in the union guarantee improvement?”

There is another way of reading this… If the UK takes no responsibility for Scotland’s current status, then the reverse of that coin is, why would staying with the Union be beneficial?

No matter what question’s asked we will always get labour whinging. But given the recent debate and the polls discussed on the next thread, we should be concentrating on the ‘What have you done for me lately?” argument and contrast with what we could do for ourselves.

Hetty

I tried to post a comment her last night, several times as each one just disappeared, so trying this just to see if it works. My comment was about how westminster really should be starting to think about negotiating with Scotland in the likelihood of a YES for Independence, but they bury their heads in the sand while burying the facts and twisting the truth to suit themselves, it is utterly disgraceful.

Grendel

Can we take the blinkers off a bit? The debate was pretty fair, the panel probably was too (although I think they may have mixed up Sanjeev with Hardeep and booked the wrong one). After Eddi Reader’s tired and emotional performance on Question Time, this really proved that having celebrities debating simply because they are celebrities is a pointless exercise.

Eric McLean

@grendel
Genuinely surprised that you though the debate was fair. I am a psychologist. Objectivity is familiar to me. This debate was a farce.

Grendel

“This debate purported to be balanced. From the beginning it was biased, by giving Massie an undecided platform from which to preach unionist propaganda. Sarwar was allowed repeatedly to makes false political soundbites way beyond the original question… ”

Hyslop had plenty of opportunity to nail Sarwar on any one of his flights of fancy, and failed to do so. In fact it was left to the audience to do what she couldn’t. and to be fair, they did.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,668 Posts, 1,201,930 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Alistair on The People You Most Suspected: “The privately educated covers all of the above.Nov 12, 19:21
    • Chas on The People You Most Suspected: “Throughout history smaller disciplined groups of people all too easily defeated the disorderly masses. The elite (not necessarily politicians) knew…Nov 12, 19:14
    • Willie on The People You Most Suspected: “Forgive me but are Boaby extenders legit. Cock stretchers for those he think Boaby is a girl. Or what about…Nov 12, 19:10
    • Martin on The People You Most Suspected: “This will only continue with sturgeon controlling everything. The fact that she has submitted an application for Holyrood 2026 means…Nov 12, 18:20
    • twathater on The People You Most Suspected: “And that is the rub of the matter Liz ,these clowns ,and I mean ALL of them throw our money…Nov 12, 18:08
    • twathater on The People You Most Suspected: “WHIT? a good man , a fucking corrupt ,spineless, deviant and pervert supporting piece of faeces, nae wonder Scotland is…Nov 12, 17:58
    • Hatey McHateface on The People You Most Suspected: “before someone in authority finally says “no more” Hang on – it’s the ones in authority who are saying “more…Nov 12, 17:46
    • Hatey McHateface on The Show Goes On: “I suppose it’s harmless enough, if it’s working for you – it is 2024 after all, even in Scotland. Nothing…Nov 12, 17:33
    • Hatey McHateface on The Show Goes On: “Good gravy! Another poster with pricks on his mind. Take a cold shower, in case you start slavering about Zelly…Nov 12, 17:28
    • James on The People You Most Suspected: “And to you, ya fud.Nov 12, 17:25
    • Effijy on The People You Most Suspected: “Perhaps if the SNP leadership tried binding their heads things could get better.Nov 12, 17:24
    • twathater on The Show Goes On: “Chas do you get HARD every time you think about Professor Baird , you seem to focus on his every…Nov 12, 17:17
    • Liz on The People You Most Suspected: “We the public have no way to curtail the Scot gov. It’s our fucking money and they spend on the…Nov 12, 17:12
    • Robert Matthews on The People You Most Suspected: “FYYFCNov 12, 17:05
    • twathater on The Show Goes On: “Thir aw getting panicy that their place on the gravy train might be at risk, the comments on the daily…Nov 12, 17:00
    • Mark Beggan on The People You Most Suspected: “Visiting some friends over the Halloween period I seen their kids dressed up to go to a party. The average…Nov 12, 16:52
    • James on The People You Most Suspected: “Because the unionist parties are all signed up to this stuff. In fact it was ‘Labour’ that started the ball…Nov 12, 16:41
    • James on The People You Most Suspected: “Labour. LibDems. Greens. SNP. LEFTIST!? ROTFLMFAO!!Nov 12, 16:38
    • Campbell Clansman on The People You Most Suspected: “Leftist governments throughout the western world take hard-earned money from the taxpayers to fund this nonsense.Nov 12, 16:25
    • James on The Show Goes On: “Aye they’ll be splitting their time between there and here. Couple of candidates just a few posts above yours….the usual…Nov 12, 16:24
    • James on The Show Goes On: “Well said, Robert!Nov 12, 16:19
    • James on The Show Goes On: “As always more like.Nov 12, 16:17
    • John C on The People You Most Suspected: “Trump picked up loads of votes on this issue and yet, the Democrats refuse to engage with the issue which…Nov 12, 15:39
    • Iain C on The People You Most Suspected: “If populist means not mutilating kids then I’m all fo it.Nov 12, 15:38
    • John C on The People You Most Suspected: “A friends daughter (transman even though she’s 5 foot and clearly female) used binders before she had surgery. She has…Nov 12, 15:33
    • Shug on The People You Most Suspected: “What gets me is the unionists in the parliament are not kicking this ball straight into the face of Swinney.…Nov 12, 15:12
    • Jason Smoothpiece on The People You Most Suspected: “Outrageous behaviour by a school children safety should come first in schools. the problem may be that the head teachers…Nov 12, 15:03
    • Geoff Anderson on The People You Most Suspected: “Labour, LibDems, Greens and the SNP all worship and support this Ideology…….with our MONEYNov 12, 15:02
    • Den on The People You Most Suspected: “If I go into a shop an buy cigarettes or alcohol for anyone under 18 I’d be charged by the…Nov 12, 15:01
    • Betty Boop on The Groomers’ Union: “Where are parents in all of this rotten mess? Why aren’t parents knocking on the school doors? Surely parents know…Nov 12, 15:01
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
180
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x