The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Lies, damned lies and The Scotsman

Posted on November 07, 2011 by

The Scotsman presents a deeply twisted spin on the latest Scottish constitutional poll today as their headline story. Under the headline "SNP under pressure as Scots back change", they report the TNS poll for the BBC which shows the results of a three-option either-or question asking voters to pick their favourite from the status quo, devo max and independence. The poll essentially shows a three-way tie, but the paper reports it highly misleadingly, particularly in this passage:

"…independence, support for which, according to the poll, has fallen 11 percentage points from the 39 per cent backing in a survey published in September."

The September poll being referenced, however, asked a radically different question – it offered respondents just two options, independence or the status quo, with no devo-max. It's hardly surprising that independence scored higher in a two-option poll than a three-option one (the status quo did too), and as such the Scotsman's interpretation borders on an outright lie. Even by their normal standards, it's an unusually clumsy and blatant effort at misrepresenting the reality.

In fact, as quietly noted by the Herald in the middle of a piece on new Scottish Conservative leader Ruth Davidson, "The nearest comparison with the latest poll was a three question one by Ipsos-Mori a year ago which had 22% for independence, 44% for more powers and 32% for no change." In other words, the BBC survey represented support for independence growing significantly, at the expense of both devo max and the status quo – the exact opposite of the Scotsman's spin.

It's also interesting that a poll showing devo max as – albeit narrowly – the most popular option is described by the paper as putting the SNP under pressure. The SNP have repeatedly expressed their willingness to include a question on devo max in the forthcoming referendum, while all the opposition Unionist parties oppose one. It is they, not the SNP, who are refusing to countenance offering the people the thing they continue to favour the most, and one might imagine that it would be they rather than the nats who would therefore be placed under pressure by this poll.

2 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. 06 06 18 17:21

    If it goes, it won’t be missed, well not by me | Grumpy Scottish Man

  2. 10 06 18 19:49

    If it goes, it won’t be missed, well not by me | Grumpy Scottish Man


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,768 Posts, 1,219,135 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James on The Flip: “Excellent post.Jun 2, 15:46
    • James Cheyne on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “While anas and usaf whish to delete democracy and most alternative voting choices for people, I am for more political…Jun 2, 15:46
    • James on The Flip: “Watch you don’t choke. Prick.Jun 2, 15:42
    • James Cheyne on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “Its simply a matter of importing a war zone to where we live, Making people take sides, Divide and conquer.…Jun 2, 15:25
    • Andy Ellis on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “Well indeed: good to see that some folk do get it! The inchoate screeching and monomaniacal focus on forcing this…Jun 2, 15:19
    • Weechid on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “Makes me ashamed to be Scottish. I can feel an application for an I rish passport coming on. Imagine thinking…Jun 2, 14:56
    • James Cheyne on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “Alf, You explain that rather well, if I may say so,Jun 2, 14:47
    • Confused on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “https://archive.ph/c99i1Jun 2, 14:41
    • Hatey McHateface on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “Bless you Bob. Have 7 virtue signalling stars from me, to hang in your window, so that the whole world…Jun 2, 14:39
    • Hatey McHateface on A Butterfly On Absinthe: ““they will readily deny their own oppression and reject their own liberation” Is that right, Alf? Is that what’s going…Jun 2, 14:33
    • Hatey McHateface on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “Nailed it. Both sides consider the cost of keeping up the fight both bearable and worth while. Let me just…Jun 2, 14:23
    • robertkknight on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “Don’t think I’ve ever read such a telling response, shedding so much light on an individual’s psyche, as that. I…Jun 2, 14:14
    • Hatey McHateface on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “I blame the Romans for chucking the Jews out of Judea. Some of the Indy supporters here are forever asserting…Jun 2, 14:07
    • Alf Baird on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “Yes Robert, this is rather like asking a people who have been subject to colonisation if they think they are…Jun 2, 14:04
    • Northcode on The Flip: “I don’t have any faith in Alba or the NSP and I certainly have no faith in the honesty and…Jun 2, 14:00
    • Mark Beggan on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “I’m amazed the Useless brown boy has time for such things. One would think he/she/it would be busy with their…Jun 2, 13:57
    • Hatey McHateface on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “1946 – long before I was born. Jerusalem – a place I’ve never visited and never will. Manchester Arena -…Jun 2, 13:47
    • Jennifer Livingston on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “Now I want to try making a frosting out of midsummer nights dream and putting it on a vanilla cupcake.?…Jun 2, 13:46
    • Mark Beggan on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “For some Scots the Muslim Terrorists fill the void left by the IRAs complete and utter defeat at the hands…Jun 2, 13:42
    • Robert on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “It really doesn’t matter who started it, though if was probably Britain with Balfour. What matters is ending it now.Jun 2, 13:33
    • James on The Flip: “Aye, and now Frog Face is hinting at scrapping the Barnett formula. Get voting, lemmings!Jun 2, 13:27
    • Geri on The Flip: “Yessers need to get out of their permanent fixation with the SNP. They’re a Britnat unionist party. They already have…Jun 2, 13:25
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “For there to be peace in Gaza would require both sides to want peace. Neither is the least bit interested…Jun 2, 13:09
    • Dick Wall on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “Hamas and The Netanyahu govt. Are like a weird but bad version of a pair of organisms that need each…Jun 2, 12:59
    • robertkknight on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “…. futhermore, Hatey, your assertion that “Whilst the other side isn’t at all interested in killing us. And hasn’t” is…Jun 2, 12:55
    • Iain Mhor on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “You can only be dragged into something if you are interested in it, or perhaps trying to keep the wife…Jun 2, 12:49
    • Andy Ellis on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “His media goes to another school Stu…..but it definitely exists. And it absolutely proves his point because it’s uniformly bad…Jun 2, 12:48
    • Marie M on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “Excellent point,this is the way colonizers work.Jun 2, 12:34
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “If you blame Israel for the whole problem, then you blame them for the current conflict, because the current conflict…Jun 2, 12:32
    • JuneCalder on A Butterfly On Absinthe: “The poll question sounds to me like who stated the current big conflict. Hamas did on 07th Oct 2023. But…Jun 2, 12:31
  • A tall tale



↑ Top