The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Legal, decent, honest and truthful?

Posted on August 03, 2012 by

After several weeks asleep, the Scottish political scene has stirred itself into a bit of life today with several interesting bits of news. The one that most caught our eye was a piece by Michael Crick for his Channel 4 blog, which noted the catastrophic collapse in Lib Dem party membership numbers – down an eyewatering 25% in a single year since entering a coalition government with the Tories.

The post is chiefly concerned with UK party membership, pointing out that Labour had gained all of 39 members in the same period (despite Harriet Harman putting the figure at a slightly more impressive 65,000) and also noting that the Tories didn’t release any UK membership stats. Buried away in the second-to-last paragraph, however, is the fact that SNP membership grew by a hefty 24% over the same 12 months, and has apparently jumped a further 16% in the first half of 2012 to stand at 23,376. That’s a massive 44% increase in 18 months.

(On current trajectories, the SNP will overtake the UK-wide Lib Dems well before the next UK election, and indeed before the independence referendum.)

Scottish Labour, meanwhile, are inexplicably shy of revealing their membership, and have been for some time. A couple of years ago the Caledonian Mercury looked into some odd discrepancies in their stats, and concluded that while Labour were claiming to have 20,000 members in Scotland, some extremely creative counting meant that the real number was likely to be much closer to half that.

In any event, it seems certain that the SNP has now overtaken even Labour’s wildest and most Stalinist estimates of its own membership in Scotland, which means that we won’t be hearing any official figures from Labour any time soon. We can’t blame them for that – we’d want to hide the fact that our main rivals were now twice our size too. But given that Scottish Labour still claims to be “Scotland’s largest political party” (and also claims on its website to have a “growing membership”), perhaps there might be a case for the Advertising Standards Authority to investigate.

5 to “Legal, decent, honest and truthful?”

  1. John Lyons says:

    Numbers! Awesome I normally really like numbers, but I Love these!

    Reply
  2. Oldnat says:

    Mind you, if Channel 4 are as bad at sums as they are at geography, they may not be reliable.
    Channel 4 News @Channel4News
    England now third in Olympic medal table after Victoria Pendleton wins gold in keirin cycling event.

    Tweeted twice – Oops!

    Reply
  3. Appleby says:

    Well Labour do seem to be clinging on to past glories elsewhere. I suppose membership numbers is part of that “rose-tinted” reality for them.
     
    Cracking bit of news for Scotland’s independence movement though. Clearly the unionists aren’t inspiring upsurges in passionate support. Hints that many of those “No”s or “Don’t Know”s in polls might be easier to sway than I dared hope.

    Reply
  4. par says:

    I remember faintly reading somwwhere although I could be wrong that ScottishLabour stopped announcing their membership figures in 2004 (the year after the Iraq invasion). They usully announced it at their annual conference. From their continuing secrecy on this, it must have been falling ever since.

    Reply
  5. hbw says:

    Political parties and any other organisations that claim to speak on behalf of others should be required to publish unambiguous membership figures.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,755 Posts, 1,217,746 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James Cheyne on The Undertaker: “The Scottish Constitution cannot pass muster under a devolved parliament from Englands Westminster. Parliament As it would turn it into…May 14, 16:43
    • Steven on The Undertaker: “If there is a unionist majority at the next election then surely there is no mandate for independence. Why don’t…May 14, 16:41
    • Owen Mullions on The Undertaker: “James Kelly back with his 6th post of the last 7 about the man who is ‘obsessed’ with him?. I…May 14, 16:10
    • wullie on The Undertaker: “Here’s a thought. Well maybe three Willie McRae shot HIMSELF in the back of the heid, thew the gun away…May 14, 16:01
    • Dislogical on The Undertaker: “Didn’t the perfect storm already hit? Shame the SNP did nothing with it.May 14, 15:33
    • Dislogical on The Undertaker: “In an earlier article about list votes you appeared to be predicting the SNP would have a majority. Do you…May 14, 15:31
    • James Cheyne on The Undertaker: “Hear hear, Uk is not a Country.May 14, 15:26
    • Peter McAvoy on The Undertaker: “I voted yes yes in 97 why can’t they use their limited powers over tax to reduce the income tax…May 14, 15:10
    • Ian McCubbin on The Undertaker: “It’s as clear as day Swinney and his SNP grifting team don’t want independence. If you do vote Alba, ISP…May 14, 15:06
    • sam on The Undertaker: “Why are Scots not more like the English seem to be? https://www.centreonconstitutionalchange.ac.uk/Future-of-England-Study “60% of voters in England say current politics…May 14, 15:04
    • Lorn on The Undertaker: “I have been trying to pin down his voice and attitude. I thought the Rev. I. M. Jolly, too, but…May 14, 14:54
    • SilentMajority on The Undertaker: “Swinney. Whenever his coupon appears on the TV, invariably the mute button gets selected. I find that Eeyore has a…May 14, 14:32
    • Andrew Morton on The Undertaker: “Swinney is the Gordon Brown of the SNP.May 14, 14:24
    • Vivian O’Blivion on The Undertaker: “I’ve worked in businesses which are cyclical, and subject to the vagaries of the market they service. During the troughs,…May 14, 14:10
    • Jon Drummond on The Undertaker: “Well, we both know that they are both full of shit. It pays them well to be so.May 14, 14:08
    • Jon Drummond on The Undertaker: “Indeed! Don’t forget the line… And nothing ever happens, nothing happens at all.May 14, 14:05
    • Lorn on The Undertaker: “It is tempting to think so, and I have no doubt at all that at least a few at the…May 14, 14:04
    • Casper1066 on The Undertaker: “Awwwwww….. you have a very keen fan….May 14, 13:57
    • Oneliner on The Undertaker: “Robertson and Swinney – the Hinge and Bracket of Scottish politics. One does the arranging, the other sings the words.May 14, 13:56
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Undertaker: “Have you even yet not pondered the possibility that Salmond-assassinating Swinney, Sturgeon, Leslie Evans, etc etc, might well not be…May 14, 13:30
    • Frank Gillougley on The Undertaker: “After the 2014 referendum I remember thinking that Scotland was a cadaver: a body on an operating table but with…May 14, 13:24
    • Red on The Undertaker: “Cozy Feet Pete has decided the problem with Scotland is that it’s full of Scots – Pete Wishart @PeteWishart My…May 14, 13:10
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Undertaker: “Compelling point, there, Robert.May 14, 13:10
    • ROBERT GALLOWAY on The Undertaker: “WHAT ARE YOUR GAINS ALWAYS ATTACKING SCOTLAND,S GOVERNMENT! NEVER WESTMINSTER! THE ENGLISH CHOICE OF LESLIE EVANS AS MAIN CIVIL SERVICE?…May 14, 13:00
    • Aidan on The Undertaker: “I actually think a strategy of trying to get independence support clearly into the 60% region (and that support being…May 14, 12:41
    • Shug on The Undertaker: “To paint themselves into such a corner surely takes some skill or compromise. The sooner the Salmond case comes to…May 14, 12:29
    • robertkknight on The Undertaker: “There’s more chance of England voting for it’s own independence than there is the SNP legislating for IndyRef2. As a…May 14, 12:28
    • James Cheyne on The Blindness Of Hatred: “The not that the Scots were not invited to join into the union! Actually it was. The Westminster parliament from…May 14, 12:28
    • ian lecoup on The Undertaker: “perfectly put “Swinney speaks with all the fire and verve of a weary old church minister burying his fifth stranger…May 14, 12:26
    • willie on The Undertaker: “Like the Yes donkey cartoon. Typifies to a tee the SNP and its latest incarnation of a First Minister. Not…May 14, 12:23
  • A tall tale



↑ Top