The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Hypership out of control

Posted on November 17, 2011 by

Some frightening numbers and home truths from Iain Macwhirter in the Herald today. The piece reaches the only conclusion it's possible to draw from the evidence, namely:

"There will have to be redistribution to claw back the 40% or so of wealth hoarded by the top 1%."

But which party  – particularly in the UK – does one vote for to achieve this? Who stands on a platform of serious wealth redistribution, calling the "But we'll leave!" bluff of the obscenely rich? (Who avoid as much of their tax burden as they can anyway.) The imminent Second Great Depression is a lot like the First World War – everyone can see it coming, nobody actually wants it, but we've hitched ourselves to an ideological bandwagon that's hurtling towards a terrible abyss and nobody's prepared to shoot the horse that's pulling it.

Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,773 Posts, 1,219,500 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Jokers: ““I posted yesterday (although my comment seems to have failed to pass moderation)” You’ve changed your email so you were…Jun 6, 13:08
    • David on The Jokers: “The migrants invading Britain is upsetting to so many working class men wanting housing but can’t get on the ladder.…Jun 6, 12:38
    • David on The Jokers: “Katy Louden voted against funding for Hamilton town centre! She got what she deserved – a big massive rejection from…Jun 6, 12:29
    • Daniel Souter on The Jokers: “The voters in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse won’t be worried much about it, because when this Labour “pig with a…Jun 6, 12:23
    • Skip_NC on The Jokers: “Effijy, I think this character is going to set a world record for points of order. “Eh, um Presiding Officer,…Jun 6, 12:14
    • Heather McLean on The Jokers: “It wouldn’t matter which of the current crop of SNP MSPs they put in his place they are all toxic…Jun 6, 11:40
    • Captain Caveman on The Jokers: “The guy thinks he’s Shakespeare.Jun 6, 11:22
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Jokers: “Alba can’t BUY press coverage since electing a non-MSP as leader. They really needed the exposure.Jun 6, 11:20
    • Kelpie on The Jokers: “I posted yesterday (although my comment seems to have failed to pass moderation) that while the SNP may have been…Jun 6, 11:17
    • Politically Homeless on The Jokers: “Well what a surprise. It turns out the majority of voters don’t care about anything political, indeed, not least “wanging…Jun 6, 11:11
    • Hatey McHateface on The Jokers: “@Northcode says: 6 June, 2025 at 10:34 am Vote for Scotland – stay at home. Work for Scotland – stay…Jun 6, 10:52
    • Allison on The Jokers: “It’s a by-election – different to a full election – with media attention for a small party who desperately need…Jun 6, 10:45
    • Ronnie on The Jokers: “In the name of God, Swinney, just go.Jun 6, 10:37
    • Northcode on The Jokers: “The Colonial News (edited in London – capital of the ’empire’) Latest news from our Scotland colony: Hooray! The Colonials…Jun 6, 10:34
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Jokers: “It’s Larkhall ffs.Jun 6, 10:30
    • desimond on The Jokers: “Look forward to the “Well its disappointing but lets not forget…” pish from Swinney. How long before Stephen Flynn has…Jun 6, 09:56
    • agent x on The Jokers: “Labour wins the only poll that matters. Well done.Jun 6, 09:53
    • Tony Little on The Jokers: “Whether anyone likes it or not, an absentee voter is still a vote – it’s a vote to abdicate the…Jun 6, 09:51
    • Sally Hughes on The Jokers: “The voters have chosen… better the useless f..k wit you know, than a new one. The results for Reform will…Jun 6, 09:39
    • June on The Jokers: “Both ALBA leadership candidates promised to reverse Salmond’s election strategy for 2026. Salmond would have stood candidates in constituencies. Repeating…Jun 6, 09:35
    • Antoine Roquentin on The Jokers: “Masochism is hardly a new phenomenon amongst the Scottish electorate.Jun 6, 09:26
    • Captain Caveman on The Jokers: “The BBC can hardly contain their glee… I still can’t quite believe this was a by-election FFS. What an utterly…Jun 6, 09:21
    • Doug on The Jokers: “Expect the same result next year if Swinney remains FM.Jun 6, 09:08
    • Neutral Observer on The Jokers: ““It’s going to take a while to unpick quite what the heck just happened, but one stat did jump out…Jun 6, 09:07
    • Doug on The Jokers: “Many independence supporters stayed at home, like they did last July, instead of voting for the devolutionist SNP. Others shunted…Jun 6, 09:06
    • James Galt on The Jokers: “Many a true word said in jest. It would be interesting to see how many bets were laid at 11/1…Jun 6, 09:00
    • Rookiescot on The Jokers: “If the Reform Company can’t win in Larkhall then they have no chance of winning anywhere. Let us remember that…Jun 6, 08:58
    • diabloandco on The Jokers: “This is gleeful headline news in the Guardian online. ‘didn’t we do well!’spluttered everyone and their auntie!Jun 6, 08:56
    • Captain Caveman on The Jokers: “Aaaaaand we’re back into the “voting for a [pudding – Ed] with a red rosette” territory. Should’ve seen it coming,…Jun 6, 08:55
    • Al Dossary on The Jokers: “Truly a damning indication of the damage done by Sturgeon, the Greens and the failure of Swinney to turn things…Jun 6, 08:43
  • A tall tale



↑ Top