The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Getting our teeth into the news

Posted on April 30, 2012 by

Impressively we’ve managed to sneeze so powerfully and manfully today that we blew a filling out, so while we go off to the dentist to have it nailed back in here are a few of the better pieces from the Scottish political media and blogosphere over the last few days, in case any of them passed you by.

Alex Massie’s been in a fine vein of form recently on the Spectator, and this analysis of Ed Miliband’s comments on Scotland was particularly insightful. We were also pleased to stumble across this archive piece from a year ago echoing almost exactly our own recent question on the same theme, which remains unanswered.

Stephen Noon blogs much less frequently than Mr Massie, but when he does it’s usually a cracker, and this related piece is no exception, while Kate Higgins shows what she can do when she’s not randomly calling people misogynists with this excellent study of the topic. And finally on Murdochgate, Newsnet Scotland makes an interesting and telling observation that went unnoticed by anyone else.

Away from the Murdoch issue, we don’t often find much to commend in the Telegraph – and less still from Fraser Nelson – but we couldn’t fault this look at “tricolour Britain”. And the increasingly impressive A Sair Fecht enlightened us with an illuminating history of Robert Bontine Cunninghame Graham, founder of the Scottish Labour Party, the Independent Labour Party and the National Party of Scotland, one of the forerunners of the SNP.

That should take you through lunch. We’re off to the bone-driller.

6 to “Getting our teeth into the news”

  1. An Duine Gruamach says:

    That’s quite the sneeze you’ve managed there.  Thanks for the links, and I hope you get yer munchers reddit oot without too much bother.

    Reply
  2. Tearlach says:

    Here is another one for you Stu – an excellent balanced article from McKie in the Herald.

    link to heraldscotland.com

    Should be required reading for the Labour Party in Scotland. Maybe they will then stop digging.   
      

    Reply
  3. MajorBloodnok says:

    Excellent find, Tearlach.

    Reply
  4. Dál Riata says:

    Sorry, but the “Murdochgate” issue is one that the Guardian just cannot let go of!

    They’ve just  put up an article by Charlotte Higgins in their Culture section smearing Alex Salmond with an “understanding that …” he used his Scottish Governmental influence to provide “corporate entertainment” to Murdoch ie tickets to the theatre to watch a production of Black Watch!

    The “understanding that …”  comes from a highlighted quote from Phil Miller, the arts correspondent of the Herald. 

    (Edit: Having just done a Google search on Miller I have seen via his Twitter account that the Herald published an article by him on this same topic on Friday, 27th April. This is where the Guardian took the quote from:  link to heraldscotland.com )

    Honest to god, the MSM are getting desperate in their attempts to make this Alex Salmond’s ‘Gotcha!’ moment!  

    Anyway here’s Charlotte Higgins getting “queasy” in her conclusion:

    “…Leaving aside the Murdoch-Salmond aspect for a moment, what intrigues me is the relationship between the National Theatre of Scotland and the Scottish Government. The NTS is funded directly by the Scottish Government. And it feels rather as if Salmond were using the production as a kind of advanced version of corporate entertainment – certainly using Black Watch to reflect well on his Government, in a way that’s harder to do (I believe rightly) when the arts are at arm’s length. Too close for comfort? It certainly makes me feel a little queasy.”
     
    link to guardian.co.uk

    Reply
  5. MajorBloodnok says:

    Mind you, the Black Watch were probably playing the Helmand Hippodrome at the time so maybe tickets were relatively easy to come by.

    Reply
  6. Al Ghaf says:

    Well, that was plenty to get my teeth into, thanks for filling me in on these. NNS did do a good job of drilling down into the Murdoch issue, much better than the Alan Cochrane’s usual bumping his gums. I often wonder if his articles are meant to be tongue in cheek.

    Anyway, I’ll get my coat now. 

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,752 Posts, 1,217,367 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Tom Halliday on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “Since 2014, the SNPs strategy (they haven’t a clue what that means) to increase support for independence, has been to…May 8, 17:34
    • Lorn on All Or Nothing: “Had England devolved as a country, the same as Scotland, within the Union – but not as a handful of…May 8, 17:28
    • James Cheyne on All Or Nothing: “It is a interesting subject the Scottish parliament. The vote, to be given by a referendum with in the territorial…May 8, 17:15
    • David on All Or Nothing: “Independence vs the abolition of the Scottish Parliament. The NHS is on the line. There’s an internal market act. And…May 8, 15:21
    • David on All Or Nothing: “On the positive side of things at all under one banner. The crowd were singing Scotland the Brave and A…May 8, 15:13
    • David on All Or Nothing: “Dear Stuart Campbell, Thanks for highlighting the Palestinian block at all under one banner. The Scottish socialist party turned up,…May 8, 15:08
    • Andrew F on All Or Nothing: “You don’t seem to think much of them at all, in fact you seem quite against them. But at least…May 8, 14:44
    • Oneliner on All Or Nothing: “Hear, hear! I could name those whom he may wish to avoid. Let’s just call them Judge A and Judge…May 8, 14:36
    • James Cheyne on All Or Nothing: “I am coming from a slightly different perspective over the scottish plastic parliament than Stu, that it is all or…May 8, 13:32
    • sarah on All Or Nothing: “He will need all our very best wishes. He is accusing COPFS.May 8, 13:00
    • Aidan on All Or Nothing: “@Dunx – exactly, that is the political problem. If the UNCRC agrees with Scotland’s claim, how then does it approach…May 8, 12:50
    • sarah on All Or Nothing: “NB Mark Hirst’s case for malicious prosecution is being heard today. He will need them.May 8, 12:43
    • Bilbo on All Or Nothing: “I came across a news article yesterday which mentioned the Gen Z are turning to religion more than other generations.…May 8, 12:23
    • James on All Or Nothing: “Sam; LOL – the correct answer!!May 8, 12:08
    • James Cheyne on All Or Nothing: “Colin, In what fundamental article of the treaty of union does it state that Scots can only hold a referendum…May 8, 11:50
    • Dunx on All Or Nothing: “One problem with the UN approach is that it relies on the support of member states with their own indy…May 8, 11:47
    • sarah on All Or Nothing: “Not today – it was yesterday, 7th May.May 8, 11:40
    • James Cheyne on All Or Nothing: “If we were adding a maths equation we would have to include all the figures together to reach an accurate…May 8, 11:37
    • sarah on All Or Nothing: “Today’s entertainment – an excellent, almost funny, piece by Robin McAlpine “It’s Karaoke Night in the Mediocracy Cafe” [over on…May 8, 11:19
    • Aidan on All Or Nothing: “Sure – I’m not asking whether you’ve ended the union yet, I just want to know whether you’ve received a…May 8, 11:19
    • Gordon on All Or Nothing: “More tripe about GERS. Scotland’s tax take was £88billion, that’s £40b that could have been spent in Scotland for Scotland,…May 8, 11:08
    • Alf Baird on All Or Nothing: “A wee bit patience please, we have to undo 300+ years of colonialism efter aw, its related pathology, a UK…May 8, 10:53
    • sam on All Or Nothing: ““We have identified and examined a number of individual themes across this body of work including, inter alia: ? The…May 8, 10:39
    • ross on All Or Nothing: “what utter guff. Most people in Scotland want a Parliament regardless of independence status. Totally false choice. This does not…May 8, 10:23
    • sam on All Or Nothing: “Farage is on record saying that he opposes Scotland’s independence. People in England most likely to support Reform are ambivalent…May 8, 09:41
    • Aidan on All Or Nothing: “@Alf – It’s nearly two months since your submission was sent to the UNCDC. What response have you received?May 8, 09:37
    • sam on All Or Nothing: “A brainMay 8, 09:34
    • Chas on All Or Nothing: “Have I got this right? After Independence Scotland will automatically have an honest, competent Government. The Government, who ever that…May 8, 09:21
    • Colin Alexander on All Or Nothing: “It is sheer folly to engage in a dead-end colonial-Scotland political system for the purpose of Scottish independence since The…May 8, 09:17
    • Alf Baird on All Or Nothing: “You make an excellent point Robert. The Rev’s view (and that of the daeless co-opted SNP leadership) that Scottish national…May 8, 09:03
  • A tall tale



↑ Top