The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



Dulce et decorum 116

Posted on October 12, 2012 by

We mark the anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz, not the day it opened.

Imagine if it were otherwise. Imagine if someone were to propose commemorating the dead of the Holocaust on the 14th of June rather than the 27th of January, because it was a pleasant summer morning rather than a bitterly cold winter one when the first transport of prisoners was marched through the infamous “Arbeit Macht Frei” gates.

There would be revulsion, disbelief and horror at such a sick notion, and rightly so.

World War 1 killed ten times as many people as died in Auschwitz, and almost three times as many as were murdered in the entire Nazi extermination programme. For the past 94 years humanity has marked their deaths on the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month, because that moment in 1918 was when the guns of the Western Front finally fell silent. Yet a little under two years from now, that solemn tradition will be cast aside in favour of a lavish series of public events to be held not on the day the senseless slaughter ended, but on the day it began.

It’s hard to come up with a plausible or convincing reason why.

Read the rest of this entry →

War: what it’s good for 114

Posted on October 11, 2012 by

Sorry folks, we’ve got a cold coming on and we’ve been a bit enfeebled today, so we’ve only just caught up with this. Evidently, independence campaigners such as ourselves were being far too complacent when we imagined that 2012 was the last opportunity for a major Union Jack-waving Festival Of Britishness. Stupidly, it hadn’t occurred to us that in a time when we can’t even afford to pay Disability Living Allowance to blind paraplegics with terminal cancer because the lazy scrounging scum could be out getting work as draught excluders or something, the country’s economy could manage to find 50 million quid spare for a big knees-up to celebrate the START of a war.

After all, World War 1 isn’t generally thought of as all that great a thing. Millions of young lives were squandered senselessly on the Western Front and elsewhere, not in the heroic defence of an innocent nation invaded by an aggressor but because of some inept, spectacularly stupid political manoeuverings and failures of diplomacy. When it finally ground to an end having slaughtered the flower of a generation, the peace-making process was handled so ineptly that it set up another world war just 20 years later, this one three times more catastrophic. Sounds well worth a party.

In our Lemsip-befuddled state, we can’t actually figure out if this is in fact all a ploy specifically designed to foil the referendum or if the Tories really do just get a massive hard-on for ANYTHING that’ll let them wave a flag around and reminisce fondly about the Empire and the spilled blood of the working class. If we do, we’ll let you know.

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,751 Posts, 1,217,295 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Aidan on All Or Nothing: “@Sarah – the collection of well meaning hangers on and drifters aren’t going to get more than a few %…May 7, 17:33
    • Aidan on All Or Nothing: “Yes – but I don’t think that poll is an accurate reflection of where public opinion south of the border…May 7, 17:28
    • Yoon Scum on All Or Nothing: “Rev you are banging on about the 75% who voted to create Holyrood Can I put it to you that…May 7, 17:11
    • Lorn on All Or Nothing: “Had that quote on the inside page of my school dictionary – all the way from Primary 7 to, and…May 7, 17:03
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on All Or Nothing: ““Persuade me how closing Holyrood makes independence any more likely.” Um, the idea isn’t to lose the vote.May 7, 16:44
    • James Cheyne on All Or Nothing: “Is it a case of all or nothing, or a case of either or Or.May 7, 16:28
    • James Cheyne on All Or Nothing: “We should be pushing on every front, It is ridiculous to to think there are only two option to the…May 7, 16:25
    • Alastair on All Or Nothing: “Great analysis. Reform are a complete game changer having already broken the two party game. They are approachable for “out…May 7, 16:21
    • Yoon Scum on All Or Nothing: “Vote for us and we will deliver you indy I’m sure I’ve heard that before Who was it Rickla Furgeon?May 7, 16:09
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on All Or Nothing: “Long since fascinated with NASA’s ongoing release online of planetary photos, particularly the surface of Mars, so your Wiki link…May 7, 16:06
    • Yoon Scum on All Or Nothing: ““No political party ever wants to cede any power it could have for itself.” Some people should have that as…May 7, 16:05
    • crisiscult on All Or Nothing: “One reason there is a Scottish parliament at all is because as a nation (so we claim/so it is claimed)…May 7, 15:54
    • mike cassidy on All Or Nothing: “The idea is floating around Not official policy – yet https://nation.cymru/news/leaked-correspondence-reveals-plot-to-turn-welsh-tories-into-an-abolish-the-senedd-party/May 7, 15:43
    • sarah on All Or Nothing: “Rev, my comment said how it can be done! Vote for the Umbrella candidates. Surely that could work? Get enough…May 7, 15:34
    • Aidan on All Or Nothing: “It’s under S.63: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/46/section/63A The Sewell convention is only a convention (as the name suggests), it does not legally restrain…May 7, 15:20
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on All Or Nothing: ““There are two major objectors to Scottish independence on the English right in particular. There are those that passionately believe…May 7, 15:19
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on All Or Nothing: ““We just need to clear out the dross who currently live there as parasites on our sovereign people.” Oh, as…May 7, 15:18
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on All Or Nothing: ““WM will never again cooperate in risking the integrity of the UK. To believe it will is to go up…May 7, 15:17
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on All Or Nothing: ““OK, but so what?” It’s a valid argument, but it’d be such a politically idiotic move it’d open the door…May 7, 15:15
    • Aidan on All Or Nothing: “Sorry Stu, this has no chance, for a few reasons. There are two major objectors to Scottish independence on the…May 7, 15:15
    • Alistair on All Or Nothing: “The pre-union Scottish parliament was not dissolved, it was prorogued. Because of this, the current Scottish parliament wasn’t created, it…May 7, 15:14
    • Peter McAvoy on All Or Nothing: “A least oppose and challenge it.May 7, 15:14
    • Rob on All Or Nothing: “I voted Yes at the referendum, the first real time the scottish people had a chance to have a fair…May 7, 15:12
    • Yoon Scum on All Or Nothing: “AKA the magic cupboard theory When we leave the union The unicorn of free stuff opens the magic cupboard and…May 7, 15:11
    • sarah on All Or Nothing: “But Holyrood CAN be the legitimate voice of Scotland. Why should it not? It is the place where our Scotland…May 7, 15:10
    • Yoon Scum on All Or Nothing: “WELL…….. https://www.thenational.scot/news/23156760.grangemouth-nuclear-reactor-plans-will-shot-government-vows/ https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-44072425May 7, 15:09
    • Yoon Scum on All Or Nothing: “The people of Scotland voting in the vast majority for parties committed to Net Zero The SNP Scottish labour Lib…May 7, 15:06
    • Jesus H. Cunt on All Or Nothing: “Is everyone forgetting that the English parties are lying when they say Scotland is a burden? That’s just propaganda aimed…May 7, 15:06
    • Giesabrek on All Or Nothing: ““You seriously think arbitrarily closing Holyrood wouldn’t cause a HUGE spike in indy support” OK, but so what? No Scottish…May 7, 14:59
    • Mike on All Or Nothing: “Scotland Act reserves energy and employment to Westminster. Holyrood can’t change that unilaterally within current Supreme Court precedent rulings… Interesting…May 7, 14:56
  • A tall tale



↑ Top