The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Going off message

Posted on November 21, 2011 by

An alert viewer draws attention to an interesting historical curio in the Scotsman today. It's a letter to the paper from Labour MSP Hugh Henry, dating from a few days after the 2011 Holyrood election, in which he rejects the idea of an early independence referendum in the most unambiguous of terms:

"Mr Salmond and the SNP clearly stated that any referendum would be held later in the life of this parliament. That's what many Scots voted for, that's what gave Mr Salmond his majority and that's the mandate which the SNP has."

Henry isn't exactly a radical dissident in Scottish Labour – he was Education Minister and Deputy Justice Minister in the second Lab-Lib coalition administration, and was mainstream enough to be the party's nomination for Presiding Officer earlier this year. In the light of Labour's recent threats to back the Westminster government in forcing an earlier UK-controlled referendum over the Scottish Parliament's head, it would be interesting to find out if his position is the same now as it was six months ago.

Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,794 Posts, 1,223,176 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Doug on The Empty Hearse: “Half a millon pro independence supports stayed at home last July instead of voting SNP? How many will stay at…Jul 30, 22:04
    • Andy Ellis on From May To July: “@Aidan 8.25pm But let’s be clear, whilst that judgement might have weight owing to the credentials of those that sit…Jul 30, 21:52
    • Ste fella on The Empty Hearse: “Posted on scotgoespop article at 21:14 300725 and reposted here as he’s too scared to post it. “I bet you…Jul 30, 21:18
    • agent x on The Empty Hearse: “Also: “Chainsaw-wielding attacker with female pronouns disfigured OAP in row over tractor Donald Sandilands, known as Donna Sandilands and referred…Jul 30, 21:15
    • Young Lochinvar on The Empty Hearse: “Yet again; every accusation you make is a confession of your own guilty pleasures.. .Jul 30, 21:13
    • GM on The Empty Hearse: “I’ve not seen anything about it.Jul 30, 20:52
    • Breastplate on Scotland’s Saviour: “John, Thatcher said her biggest achievement was New Labour. It was an acknowledgment of Labour’s lurch to the right, the…Jul 30, 20:47
    • Aidan on From May To July: “@Andy – to be clear on the second post, I posted the article as an example of where the concept…Jul 30, 20:40
    • agent x on The Empty Hearse: “Thanks.Jul 30, 20:28
    • Aidan on From May To July: “Haha well, since we are getting dicks out, this is also not my first rodeo having studied international law at…Jul 30, 20:25
    • sarah on The Empty Hearse: “@ agent x: Liberate Scotland will stand in constituencies as well as regions – a list of 19 of their…Jul 30, 20:19
    • Andy Ellis on From May To July: “@Aidan 6.41pm If so, that is squarely a domestic “legal” right, not something that is recognised in international law. However,…Jul 30, 20:08
    • agent x on The Empty Hearse: “Thanks.Jul 30, 20:04
    • agent x on The Empty Hearse: “see https://www.scotch-whisky.org.uk/media/2170/scotch-whisky-economic-impact-report-2024.pdf “In 2022, the Scotch Whisky industry, defined as the production and sales & distribution of Scotch Whisky, generated…Jul 30, 19:58
    • Onlooker on The Empty Hearse: “What’s happening with the Alex Salmond trial? Anybody any updates?Jul 30, 19:56
    • GM on The Empty Hearse: “Definitely.Jul 30, 19:53
    • Insider on The Empty Hearse: “Did you even attempt to understand the Rev’s article before writing drivel like this….??? “Swinney and his fellow fuckwits don’t…Jul 30, 19:50
    • Andy Ellis on From May To July: “@Aidan 6.01pm This isn’t my first rodeo bud. Unlike some of the regulars here I do actually know a thing…Jul 30, 19:50
    • GM on The Empty Hearse: “It costs a lot of money to put someone in every seat. I suspect they will try and cover all…Jul 30, 19:48
    • wullie on The Empty Hearse: “Why would Swinney bother about tariffs on Scotch. As far as I am aware the whisky industry is owned outwith…Jul 30, 19:24
    • Mark Beggan on The Empty Hearse: “I take it Felix Winter will be welcomed in the men’s jail.Jul 30, 19:17
    • George Ferguson on The Empty Hearse: “I have had a month off happy to report nothing has changed. We booked a cruise with the money we…Jul 30, 19:11
    • agent x on The Empty Hearse: “Hey – Ursula is a hottie 🙂Jul 30, 18:59
    • agent x on The Empty Hearse: “Sturgeon added on her Instagram account: “Feeling was mutual, Donnie. Forever proud to represent all the things that offend your…Jul 30, 18:52
    • Aidan on From May To July: “@Andy – perhaps you’re referring to the right of Implied Constitutional Self Determination described in this article here: https://www.ejiltalk.org/the-uk-supreme-court-reference-on-a-referendum-for-scotland-and-the-right-to-constitutional-self-determination-part-ii/ If…Jul 30, 18:41
    • Willie on The Empty Hearse: “No votes SNP in 2026. That is the strategy for moving forward. The SNP are an anti independence Trojan Horse.Jul 30, 18:28
    • Wally Jumblatt on The Empty Hearse: “Swinney “Scotland’s place as an independent nation in the European Union” -will you listen to yourself man, you want to…Jul 30, 18:26
    • agent x on The Empty Hearse: “Are Liberation Scotland going to have constituent candidates or just list candidates?Jul 30, 18:19
    • Ian on The Empty Hearse: “In summary, the usage of the D’Hondt method in Scottish Parliamentary elections was a deliberate choice by the UK government…Jul 30, 18:04
    • Aidan on From May To July: “@Andy – you’re engaging the commonly held but inaccurate idea that the right to self determination equals the right to…Jul 30, 18:01
  • A tall tale



↑ Top