The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Exactly how stupid are Labour?

Posted on May 11, 2010 by

The momentum behind a Lib-Lab coalition seems at the time of writing to be slipping away, as one braindead Labour MP or grandee after another comes out to argue against it in front of an eager media. If Labour's 1983 election manifesto was the longest suicide note in history, today's collected BBC News interviews could be among the shortest.

Because here's what happens if Labour retards like David Blunkett, John Reid, Tom Harris and Wee Dougie Alexander scupper this agreement.

1. There will be a massive, MASSIVE backlash against Labour in Scotland. Scotland as a nation votes overwhelmingly tactically against the Tories, as clearly seen in results like those of Jim Murphy (Lab) and Pete Wishart (SNP) on Thursday. The SNP have offered to support a progressive alliance aimed at keeping the Tories out, and if idiot Labour MPs are the ones who block it and let the Tories in, they will not be forgiven.

A poll a couple of weeks ago showed that support for Scottish independence would almost DOUBLE if the Tories won this election. If they win it in this particular manner, though, with Labour offered power on a plate by the SNP but throwing it back in their faces, that support could turn into a runaway train in the Holyrood general election due in less than 12 months.

Independence, or even just Labour losing a large number of seats in their biggest UK stronghold, would in itself almost end Labour's hopes of ever commanding a UK majority again.

2. It's said that the Labour dimwits opposing the Lib-Lab pact believe they can take advantage of a massively unpopular Tory government imposing terrifying cuts over the next five years, and therefore get back into power at a subsequent election. But the Tories have plans to deal with that.

Their manifesto pledge to reduce the number of MPs by equalising (ie gerrymandering) constituency sizes will favour the Tories enormously. Labour's chances of achieving a majority, however unpopular the Tories are, will grow still tinier. (And let's remember, the last time Labour tried this strategy they were out of power for EIGHTEEN YEARS.)

3. The Lib Dem vote is likely to crumble to dust if they blow this gilt-edged once-in-a-generation chance at securing power/PR. Their voters will – quite reasonably – react with disillusionment and disgust, and around twice as many Lib Dem marginals are fought against the Tories as against Labour. So the Tories are the most likely beneficiaries of a Lib Dem collapse, further locking in the prospect of a perpetual Tory majority.

All that, of course, is only the result for Labour itself. The results for the British electorate, well, they hardly bear thinking about.

If you live anywhere near Tom Harris, Douglas Alexander, David Blunkett or John Reid, do your country a favour and go round and punch them into a coma before it's too late, eh?

16 to “Exactly how stupid are Labour?”

  1. Karl says:

    It's nice to have a day off and just be able to follow this slow motion car crash.
    Labour will need their fucking heads checking if they don't get this deal done. The Conservatives are hoping to get away with a derisory offer, by pushing the media line that a Lab-Lib Government would be TERRIBLE and UNFAIR and UNCONSTITUTIONAL.
    Someone needs to give them a kick up the arse, soonish. Oh, and what's with the BBC news cunt interviewing Bradshaw right now? He's just attacking him, openly pro-Tory.
    Disgusting…

    Reply
  2. Thomas Lawrence says:

    Would a referendum on  proper, non-AV form of PR ever pass the Commons, though? Even if a Lib-Lab coalition whipped for all it was worth? It seems like a lot of labour and Tory MPs are against it, and no surprises there as they benefit from the current system.

    Reply
  3. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    It would take serious whipping, but I believe it would be achievable, yes. Particularly if someone beat the above column into their stupid fucking thick skulls.

    Reply
  4. AJ says:

    I can't believe this. Why are members of the Labour party determined to commit political suicide? This is bizarre. I don't understand the reasoning behind dragging their feet or causing these problems.

    Reply
  5. Karl says:

    Nick Clegg begs the country to stay with him –

    Reply
  6. Jim says:

    I see 38 Degrees wants you to write to any and all Labour MPs opposed to the coalition and remind them of what they're passing up – link to 38degrees.org.uk

    Reply
  7. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    "Nick Clegg begs the country to stay with him"

    Deleted.

    Reply
  8. AJ says:

    Stu's right, the video is gone now. Any other links to it?

    Reply
  9. Karl says:

    Meh. Stupid Youtube. It's just a joke video I made. It works fine embedded on my site – link to bedroomcoder.wordpress.com

    Reply
  10. Karl says:

    Hmmm… OK, the creepy lawyers have shut it down completely now. :S
     
    Obviously I am some kind of criminal and need to be silenced…

    Reply
  11. Karl says:

    I'm guessing I'd be risking severe consequences from Google if I uploaded it to my blog as well…?
     
    Fucking penny-pinching bastards.

    Reply
  12. joncfc says:

    I wonder what the Tory majority would be id Scotland was asked to leave the union…
    oh and stu? the 9 needs changing to an 8.

    Reply
  13. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    What 9?

    Reply
  14. joncfc says:

    the 1993 election manifesto? i thought it was 1983 with Michael Foot?

    Reply
  15. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    Ah, so it was. Man, I'm WAY older than I thought.

    Reply
  16. Toops says:

    Was thinking the exact same thing – almost as bad as if the human race couldn't see the wood from the trees when it comes to the planet and their self-destruction….oh wait it's already happened.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,748 Posts, 1,217,047 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Captain Caveman on For Children Scotland: “yOu mUsT bE oN tEh FAr RiGHtMay 3, 19:12
    • agent x on For Children Scotland: “a woman is a biological woman – shock to the SNP.May 3, 19:01
    • SusanAHF on For Children Scotland: “Is Reform “far right”? It’s a cheap MSM jibe.im “far right” because I agree with the Supreme Court decision according…May 3, 18:45
    • Mia on For Children Scotland: ““Your verbose, salty tears and gnashing of teeth” What salty tears and what gnashing of teeth are you referring to?…May 3, 18:27
    • agent x on For Children Scotland: “‘It’s needed now more than ever’: Thousands march in support of Scottish independence https://www.thenational.scot/ Believe it or not.May 3, 18:24
    • Yoon Scum on For Children Scotland: “I love how ALL scottish nationalists have cancelled their license fee AND Know WAY more about what is on the…May 3, 18:20
    • agent x on For Children Scotland: “Politics is not done well on here. Stick to the bleeding heart colony rubbish.May 3, 18:10
    • Hatey McHateface on For Children Scotland: “Surely the Hebrides Hum is caused by white sizzlers constant low level gurning? The natives constant low level whining about…May 3, 18:04
    • Bilbo on For Children Scotland: “Waves and waves of R mechanised armour rolling across Europe with their cheap Chinese tyres LOLMay 3, 17:57
    • Hatey McHateface on For Children Scotland: “Wow, Marie, you’ve blown our minds with that post. I’ll respond formally eventually, but I’ll ask your forbearance meantime. Your…May 3, 17:53
    • Bilbo on For Children Scotland: “YS, here’s a hanky to wipe away all that greetin and snorters.May 3, 17:43
    • Bilbo on For Children Scotland: “Dan, my use of analogy of chess is that the SNP is positioning itself to protect the Scottish people from…May 3, 17:39
    • Marie on For Children Scotland: “Imagine admitting publicly that you get your “news” from the propaganda arm of the British State. Sad.May 3, 17:37
    • Marie on For Children Scotland: “I agree Mia – the lurch to the far right is happening by design.May 3, 17:34
    • Hatey McHateface on For Children Scotland: “Ach, YS, Scotland might have to wait years, or even decades, for you to get the big ‘C’. And besides,…May 3, 17:30
    • Captain Caveman on For Children Scotland: “Imagine knocking Reform when you’ve had the SNP and *Scottish Greens* running the show…. Not so much glass houses, more…May 3, 17:28
    • Yoon Scum on For Children Scotland: “Reform are everything that Scotland hates We shall leave this union and we will become the first completely islamic nation…May 3, 17:16
    • Yoon Scum on For Children Scotland: “Sorry I did a whoopsie I forgot that all the experts who correctly predicted the downsides of leaving the EU…May 3, 17:03
    • Captain Caveman on For Children Scotland: ““ahahahahahahaha!!! Please do not take me for a fool. A new political movement my foot.” Heh! Your verbose, salty tears…May 3, 17:00
    • Yoon scum on For Children Scotland: “What if the Scottish government say that it’s only filthy Yoons like myself can apply for assisted dying It would…May 3, 16:58
    • Yoon Scum on For Children Scotland: “YEP the union is vastly unfair that the 65 million English Have more of a say in Westminster then the…May 3, 16:45
    • Hatey McHateface on For Children Scotland: “Message received loud and clear, Mia: We’re all doomed. Jeez. Think I’ll binge watch a few Dad’s Army episodes. See…May 3, 16:27
    • Mia on For Children Scotland: ““the rise of a new political movement” ahahahahahahaha!!! Please do not take me for a fool. A new political movement…May 3, 15:06
    • Hatey McHateface on For Children Scotland: “Accept the bid, even if it’s low, but on the condition that Barbie stays with the van. After all, your…May 3, 15:04
    • Hatey McHateface on For Children Scotland: “Ouch! Several bedroom carpets over the length and breadth of Auld Scotia have just seen another bite being taken out…May 3, 14:58
    • Hatey McHateface on For Children Scotland: “Interesting article on the BBC Online website at the moment – “How ordinary Poles are preparing for a R invasion”.…May 3, 14:50
    • Hatey McHateface on For Children Scotland: “So what if we can never find out who’s behind it all, Mia. Can’t you just make something up like…May 3, 14:25
    • James Cheyne on For Children Scotland: “Mia, Aye, the process is half done. And as I mentioned a week ago, it is only a matter of…May 3, 14:17
    • Hatey McHateface on For Children Scotland: “Wait long enough, Willie, and the New Scottish Caliphate will decree there is no need to educate girls. Perhaps the…May 3, 14:10
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on For Children Scotland: “« Now, where’s that jar of marmalade, it’s time for breakfast. » (Vivian O’Blivion) ________ An appropriately cryptic rejoinder follows (of course…May 3, 14:04
  • A tall tale



↑ Top