The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Credit where credit’s due

Posted on May 10, 2012 by

Alert readers may have noticed a certain undercurrent of cynicism about the Scottish political media in this blog on occasion. But now and again you have to put all sarcasm aside and take your hat off to a professional who bangs the nail straight in with one swing of the hammer. Today it’s Iain Macwhirter in the Herald, who thankfully seems to be returning to form after his Murdoch-inspired red mist of recent weeks.

“‘It’s the big question of separation,’ said the Stirling Labour group leader, Corrie McChord, when asked why he was unable to form a coalition with the SNP – a party which he accepted had almost identical social policies to Labour.

Now, I may be missing something here, but I wasn’t aware that Stirling Council was in danger of separating from the United Kingdom. Why the independence referendum should have had such a decisive bearing on who runs council refuse and leisure services in Stirling is not entirely clear. Perhaps Labour believe the Nats will put something in the water or plant separatist propaganda in the wheelie bins.

Whatever, it seems that Labour think they have more in common with the party that wants to privatise most council services than the party that wants to use them as a bulwark against the austerity plans of, er, the Conservative-led Coalition in Westminster.”

We couldn’t have put it better, or more concisely. As Labour chum up with the Tories across the country (Edinburgh looking like being the sole honourable exception), and the Glasgow party prepares (as widely rumoured by SNP supporters a couple of days beforehand) to set the Orange Order loose on the city’s streets in gratitude for their help, we can’t help but ask the hundreds of Labour activists whose efforts secured the party its better-than-expected result last week: “Is this what you worked so hard for?”

25 to “Credit where credit’s due”

  1. Scott Minto (Aka Sneekyboy) says:

    Religion should play no part in government. This flirting witht he Orange Order is a dangerous precident to set and I am not convinced that it is not intentional to stir up racial tensions and divide unity of purpose.

    Reply
  2. Andrew Haddow says:

    MacWhirter then returns to base with ” The cybernats are hunting the blogosphere for ("Quizmaster" - Ed)s and fifth columnists to blame for duping the Scots into voting to remain under the heel of the English jackboot.”

    Reply
  3. MajorBloodnok says:

    The meds must have been wearing off at that point.

    Reply
  4. tom says:

    “Is this what you worked so hard for?”

    And, sadly, I suspect that very many of them would be jubilant because they had seen off the SNP.

    Reply
  5. Arbroath1320 says:

    Nice to see Labour councillors following the “instructions” from that nice wee fella Willie Bain.
    “Anyone but the SNP!”
    Nice to know that the newly elected councillors are working FOR the community and NOT for themselves……….. AYE RIGHT!

    Reply
  6. Tris says:

    Maybe Labour should reflect on what happened to the last lot that cast their lot in with the Tories…

    What were they called again…the Liverpool Demagogues or something of that nature?

    Once you get enmeshed in Tory policies in Scotland, you might as well pack up and take up DIY… 

    Reply
  7. Juteman says:

    A box of uncounted votes found in Glasgow

    Reply
  8. Macart says:

    Mr MacWhirter certainly seems free enough with his opinions on people he’s never met. Still I suppose that’s his job to comment and offer opinion. But that’s all it is, opinion.

    Most folks I’ve met on threads of whatever background are decent, mannered and polite. Almost certainly all are motivated and passionate about their corner of the debate and politics in general. There are a number on both sides who get carried away with their argument and use language which they themselves ultimately regret and thankfully there are precious few who are indeed poisonous and seem hell bent on sewing as much strife as they can.

    That is a most unfortunate turn of phrase from Iain MacWhirter, a commentator I had some time for.  Still, I did have a read at the rest of his piece in today’s Herald and as Rev points out he’s taken a swing at some stand out council politicking.

    Reply
  9. MajorBloodnok says:

    @ Juteman

    You jest?

    Reply
  10. Scott Minto (Aka Sneekyboy) says:

    MajorBloodnok says: @ Juteman – You jest?

    Nope. Langside Ward: Registration Report counts 6952 votes.

    Valid Votes 6480 + Spoilt 88 = 6568.

    Took GCC 6 days to notice.

    May reslut in Green seat becoming SNP.    

    Reply
  11. Tearlach says:

    @MajorBloodnok
     
    link to bbc.co.uk
     

    Reply
  12. MajorBloodnok says:

    Evidently not!

    Oh dear, that’ll annoy Lallans Peat Worrier after all the hard work he did.

    Reply
  13. Scott Minto (Aka Sneekyboy) says:

    “Oh dear, that’ll annoy Lallans Peat Worrier after all the hard work he did.”

    He says that it is just a matter of inputting the new value, and luckily it is only one ward (That we know of).  

    Reply
  14. Arbroath1320 says:

    Sorry Major it must be true even the BBC are reporting it so it must be true.
    link to bbc.co.uk
    OOPS! 😀

    Of course now that this “missing” ballot box has turned up 6 days late I wonder if………… Nah shoorley not! 😀

    Reply
  15. Arbroath1320 says:

    Just a wee aside folks.
    NNS is back up. That is for those of you who are able to put up posts. Unfortunately I still have to wait until the mods have had their tea before any of mine get up. Still the “naughty step” is kinda getting nice and warm these days. 😀

    Reply
  16. Arbroath1320 says:

    Just come across this.
    link to facebook.com
    Just wondering, was the picture taken BEFORE or AFTER Mr Matheson’s “wee chat” with the Orange Order before last week’s election? 😀

    Reply
  17. MajorBloodnok says:

    My other half has just pointed out that Archie Graham, elected a Labour member in the Langside ward, is Johann Lamont’s husband.  Interesting.

    Reply
  18. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    That IS interesting.

    Reply
  19. Arbroath1320 says:

    Any chance he’ll challenge that very nice Mr Matheson for the Leadership of GCC by any chance? 😀
    I’m sure that very nice Ms. Lamont would give him her full backing.

    Reply
  20. Jen says:

    Strange that Mr MacWhirters journalism has returned to more objective commentary now that the election is over.  Odd that!

    Reply
  21. G. Campbell says:

    “As Labour chum up with the Tories across the country (Edinburgh looking like being the sole honourable exception)”

    Not for the want of trying.

    One source said “you wouldn’t believe” how much the SNP were offering the Conservatives to try to bring them on board, adding: “Steve Cardownie still wants to be Lord Provost. He has been away to the Tories offering them anything and everything.”

    A senior Tory confirmed the SNP had originally made “some fairly serious offers” if the Conservatives were willing to go into coalition but that the party had held out for a deal with Labour.

    link to scotsman.com

    Stage 8 Cardownie says: “And I would have gotten away with it, if only I’d remembered to put the jumbo box of wagon wheels in the boot.”

    Reply
  22. Doug Daniel says:

    An awful lot of anonymous sources in that article. You need so many pinches of salt you might as well just take it with a whole bag.

    Reply
  23. Longshanker says:


    @Jen
    Strange that Mr MacWhirters journalism has returned to more objective commentary now that the election is over. Odd that!

    Nothing strange about it at all. Because he always remained objective. Or as objective as you can be short of being a robot.

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      Yes, he’s pretty fair and balanced, with the exception of the gigantic bee in his bonnet about Murdoch. Hence “returning to form”.

      Reply
  24. MajorBloodnok says:

    @Langshonker

    Not that I’m an AI specialist or anything (I know some though), I didn’t realise that robots were inherently objective.  I’m sure Karel ?apek would have mentioned it.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,785 Posts, 1,221,249 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • 100%Yes on Too Tight To Mention: “The big question is, how is the SNP still alive and kicking. I do not believe for a minute the…Jul 3, 15:34
    • TURABDIN on Too Tight To Mention: “Indeed, «hiding»in plain sight and all perfectly normal in Yookay.. It seems the British state functions on the accommodating body…Jul 3, 15:17
    • Xaracen on The Con Merchant: “And which substantive point was that, exactly, CC?Jul 3, 15:02
    • Aidan on The Con Merchant: “Again we keep coming to this issue of the preservation of sovereignty. In the context you mean it, sovereignty means…Jul 3, 14:52
    • Captain Caveman on The Con Merchant: “Semantics, at the end of the day. The substantive point still stands, whether or not you think you’ve answered Aiden’s…Jul 3, 14:42
    • Xaracen on The Con Merchant: ““Ah, a classic case of hinging an entire argument off a single, extreme outlier argument” Maybe it escaped your attention,…Jul 3, 14:31
    • Mark Beggan on Too Tight To Mention: “I think it’s about time we looked seriously at these Trade Union representatives. 1. They don’t understand the Law. 2.…Jul 3, 14:26
    • Confused on The Con Merchant: “this is why I miss, such a lot : RED GEM WOMAN – coz she could sit here all afternoon…Jul 3, 13:26
    • Confused on The Con Merchant: “Still rubbish, Main. Still not seeing any “the positive case for the Union”. Surely you don’t lack arguments. Do you…Jul 3, 13:16
    • James on The Con Merchant: “Ooft. I think you nailed it there, Lochinvar. A GOTCHA.Jul 3, 13:14
    • Confused on The Con Merchant: “Read books. It will do you good.Jul 3, 13:14
    • Captain Caveman on The Con Merchant: ““Professor Robert Black KC, FRSA, FRSE, FFCS, ILTM ( Professor Emeritus of Scots Law at the University of Edinburgh), was…Jul 3, 13:06
    • Andrew scott on Too Tight To Mention: “@cheyne Your contributions adds what to the debate as to the devious Murrell getting taxpayers money to fight his case?????Jul 3, 13:03
    • Xaracen on The Con Merchant: “So what, Aidan? The procedures of the two houses of the parliament of England were indeed known in 1707, but…Jul 3, 12:42
    • McDuff on Too Tight To Mention: “The initial complaint was about the missing £600,000 yet no information regarding its whereabouts has been forthcoming. Why? It’s either…Jul 3, 12:36
    • Mark Beggan on Too Tight To Mention: “For Sale Time machine. Si 2000xL Mark II One careful owner. Six months tax and MOTed. 100,000 light years on…Jul 3, 12:29
    • Ste fella on Too Tight To Mention: “Posted on scotgoespop today on his joy at krap alba polling article at 12:”4 030725: “Wishing the demise of a…Jul 3, 12:25
    • lothianlad on Too Tight To Mention: “SNP have been infiltrated by the british security services for years. Bribery and blackmail are their weapons. discrediting the snp…Jul 3, 12:07
    • James Cheyne on Too Tight To Mention: “Salvo need to include such information in their presentations should the requirement arise as evidence that the Scots are a…Jul 3, 11:13
    • James Cheyne on Too Tight To Mention: “Westminster governance of Great Britain is under the governance of Englands law. To all intents and purposes. This can be…Jul 3, 10:57
    • James Cheyne on Too Tight To Mention: “So the devolved parliament sent to Scotland. Is it under the governing body of english law? The governing body of…Jul 3, 10:42
    • James Cheyne on Too Tight To Mention: “TURABDIN. Aside from the obvious hidden traciblity of ownership. The interesting part of that information that may go unnoticed is…Jul 3, 10:33
    • Aidan on The Con Merchant: “You are arguing with me separately about the impact of English people moving to Scotland and now you’re telling us…Jul 3, 10:20
    • James Cheyne on The Con Merchant: “A slight change in conversation. It is interesting to note that ulster Scots are recognised as a minority. For funding.…Jul 3, 10:06
    • James Cheyne on The Con Merchant: “Commentry is once again being delayed.Jul 3, 09:48
    • James Cheyne on The Con Merchant: “He also states there is no such identity as the UK,Jul 3, 09:45
    • James Cheyne on The Art Of Noise: “The above comments came from Carwyn Jones, former first minister of Wales.Jul 3, 09:36
    • James Cheyne on The Con Merchant: “English principle of sovereignty of parliament. There is nothing in Statue,Law that defines parliamentary Sovereignty. There is no legislation that…Jul 3, 09:20
    • Dan on The Con Merchant: “Article VI of the Union Treaty “VI. ‘That all Parts of the united Kingdom, for ever, from and after the…Jul 3, 09:13
    • The Flying Iron of Doom on Too Tight To Mention: “I’ve just been enjoying the irony of this news coming out in lavender season, this being the late June to…Jul 3, 09:03
  • A tall tale



↑ Top