The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Demarcation dispute

Posted on October 31, 2012 by

Did anyone else notice that in last night’s Scotland Tonight interview (in which he noted that Labour’s tribal hatred of the SNP was blinding and damaging it), former First Minister Henry McLeish referred to Johann Lamont as “leader of the Labour Party in Scotland”, rather than as the leader of anything called “Scottish Labour”? As a current member and ex-head of the party’s Scottish division, you’d think Mr McLeish would know the proper name and internal structure of it. What aren’t we being told?

20 to “Demarcation dispute”

  1. Angus McLellan says:

    This is a bit Ian Smart-ish, no? The Scottish Labour Party doesn’t exist, so it can’t have a leader, but Labour in Scotland does. And Leader of Labour in Scotland (LoLiS) is different from Gray’s title (LoLitSP).

    Reply
  2. scottish_skier says:

    Basically, with the Tories having given up on Scotland and helping things along independence-wise, the only ‘unionist’ party left with any hope of holding the UK together is Labour. However, having a ‘Scottish Labour’ would work against this, hence  Lamont basically saying she’ll adopt Ed’s neo-liberal New Labour policies while Ed hedges his bets with the ‘one nation’ stuff; that ‘one nation’ being England or possibly Great Britain if by chance he gets lucky.

    Reply
  3. Steven of Songnam says:

    I think we’re not being told (directly) that we’re basically an oil well and nuclear launch site as far as the UK government is concerned, and the idea of Scotland as a nation is at least faintly amusing to them.
    I think we’re also not being told that “Scottish Labour” is really all over the place, being pulled in three directions: London, Edinburgh, and Glasgow. That’s why they don’t have any policies except hating the party they should theoretically have some ideological common ground with but are in bed with their supposed mortal enemies. Who would even know what they’re named any more?
     
    Giving your vote to Labour. Now there is “something for nothing”.

    Reply
  4. Macart says:

    There is only THE Labour Party and its leader is Ed Milliband.

    For any further confirmation of this, check with the Labour bunker and pose the following question:

    So Johann, Trident aye or naw?

    Reply
  5. mato21 says:

    O/T
     THE Scottish Parliament’s presiding officer, Tricia Marwick, gave her charges a mini lecture yesterday about behaving better and helping increase the public’s estimation of Holyrood

    This is the first paragraph in A Cochranes’  blog Did anyone hear what she said?

    The reason I ask is, I, like many others I expect, emailed her and laid the blame squarely at her door for the appalling descriptions allowed in Parliament and directed at the FM  last week

    I await a reply from her I have had an acknowledgement 
            

     

    Reply
  6. Elizabeth says:

    House of Commons Scottish Affairs Committee question Ministers about the Edinburgh Agreement – or as it says on the website…”The Referendum on Separation for Scotland” 
    Witnesses
    Rt Hon Michael Moore MP, Secretary of State, Rt Hon David Mundell MP, Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, and Alun Evans, Director, Scotland Office
    It’s today at 2:30pm and youi can watch it here:
    link to parliamentlive.tv  

    Reply
  7. TheGreatBaldo says:

    With delicious irony Davidson and his cronies hold their hearings in ‘The Thatcher Room’….
     

    Reply
  8. James McLaren says:

    Steven of Songnam
     
    You have missed out water for the desert that is the SE of England and North Sea fishing rights to be given in perpetuity to Spain for a quid pro quo over (Gibraltar)?

    Reply
  9. Angus McLellan says:

    James, given the level of competence displayed by UK negotiators – signing up to the CFP, Major’s useless Euro opt-out – they’d be lucky to end up with Spanish backing for Gibraltar joining UEFA.

    Reply
  10. James McLaren says:

    You really have to wonder why no one on the Committee, Labour presumably, tipped the wink to Lour in Scotland in general and Johann Lamont in particular about this opinion?

    Rt Hon Bob Ainsworth MP
    Labour

    Mr John Baron MP
    Conservative

    Rt Hon Sir Menzies Campbell QC MP
    Liberal Democrats

    Rt Hon Ann Clwyd MP
    Labour

    Mike Gapes MP
    Labour

    Mark Hendrick MP
    Labour

    Andrew Rosindell MP
    Conservative

    Mr Frank Roy MP
    Labour

    Richard Ottaway MP (Chair) Conservative

    Rt Hon Sir John Stanley MP Conservative
    Rory Stewart MP Conservative

     
     
    I wonder why.

    Reply
  11. Steven of Songnam says:

    @ James McLaren
     
    I knew we were good for something else, thanks!
     
    So Scotland is not a country to them; it is a resource and a problem. Time to shake things up a bit with a Yes vote in the referendum, I think.

    Reply
  12. Arbroath 1320 says:

    Sorry for being O/T but I’ve found these few tit bits which I think folks might enjoy.
     
    1) The reasons we are better together.
     
    link to youtube.com
     
    2) After all the lying and deceit could we soon be witnessing another “good day in the office” for Brown.
     
    link to order-order.com
     
    3) Just when you thought all the fun was over could we yet see Blair sweat a little over this one.
     
    link to order-order.com
     
    link to huffingtonpost.co.uk

    Reply
  13. cynicalHighlander says:

    OT: Yes events list for Nov, click see more.
    link to facebook.com

    Reply
  14. DougtheDug says:

    ‘…former First Minister Henry McLeish referred to Johann Lamont as “leader of the Labour Party in Scotland”, rather than as the leader of anything called “Scottish Labour”?”‘

    I suspect that Johann is being sidelined in preparation for the boot by devaluing the position she holds in the eyes of the media even though it’s a true description of her position.

    As the original commenter who first pointed out way back in 2005 in places like the Herald comments that Scottish Labour wasn’t a real party, it was defined as a region in the Labour party Rule Book, it wasn’t registered with the Electoral Commission and that the then “leader” Jack McConnell only had authority over the MSP’s in Holyrood I feel a sense of accomplishment when even Henry won’t call it “Scottish Labour”.

    Reply
  15. Bill C says:

    I listened carefully to what Henry McLeish said on Scotland Tonight last night and I am under no illusions that Mr. McLeish is Labour through and through.  He is obviously gutted that Labour are a shambles. He highlighted Labour’s lack of passion, lack of direction, lack of policies, lack of ideas on the constitution, lack of Scottishness (whatever that is?) lack of leadership (he was in limp mode in his support of Lamont). My impression is that he only supports Devo something because he thinks that that is the only way to save the union.  I don’t think there is any chance of him joining the YES camp.

    On another note found this on Facebook: sunnyscotland.org.uk (sorry about the uk bit!) The McCrone report – an ambarrassment of riches?  McCrone in bite size bits, it’s all there in two pages. Brilliant for campaigning. YES campaign might be able to put  the very readable information on leaflets.

    Reply
  16. Indy_Scot says:

    From what I can see the only argument that the No campaign has is the union. I believe that if the Yes campaign can get across to the Scottish public that there will still remain a social union between the two countries, then it will effectively leave the unionists empty handed.

    Reply
  17. Bill C says:

    Two Americans discussing Scottish independence on Newsnicht re. article in the Washington Post. One was a former special adviser to AS, she was entirely comfortable with Scottish independence; the other not happy at all.  Basically an independent Scotland would not be in the strategic interest of the US of A. So there we have it, America says NO. We are gubbed!

    Reply
  18. Ronald Henderson says:

    Bill C. We may not be gubbed. There is a lot of sympathy for an independent Scotland in the US. The free online American monthly magazine Celticguide.com carries their own advertisement for the Yes Scotland campaign every month. I would encourage you all to check it out. A lot of people around the world want us to be free but they aren’t sure just how to help. A good start would be for us all to contact (facebook etc) as many people as possible round the planet and inform them about Yes Scotland. The more help and money and even just encouragement that comes in then the better chance we have. But we will have to inform these people first.

    Reply
  19. Bill C says:

    Hi Ronald, 

    To be honest I was being sarcastic when I said that because the Yanks say no we are gubbed.  However there is a serious point to this. Way back in the Seventies when Polaris was all the rage, the Yanks were  in no mood to be messed about by such trivia as Scottish independence.  It was well known in nationalist circles that the CIA and other more domestic security agencies  were actively engaged in trying to discredit the nationalist movement. Geo-politics is never off the agenda with western security agencies, I doubt very much if the black ops brigade will remain inactive in the run up to the referendum.

    Reply
  20. James McLaren says:

    I suspect that someone or something must be subsidising the  Herald and Scotsman. How else can you explain commercial suicide?
     
    The BBC don’t give a monkey’s as they still get their money no matter what they do, who they serve. They have been bought already.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,800 Posts, 1,223,789 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Last Marble: “Link to source of Joanna Cherry quote above – https://x.com/joannaccherry/status/1954107324638880232Aug 11, 01:06
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Last Marble: “Extract from Joanna Cherry’s sustained broadside against Nicola Sturgeon (from 8 Aug Scottish Daily Mail page image featured on Joanna’s…Aug 11, 00:33
    • sarah on Snowflake Patrol: “Well done for putting time and money into trying to protect our youngsters, George. Your daughter is completely right to…Aug 10, 21:47
    • Marie on The Last Marble: “Yet it was an ITV journalist (Peter Smith) that made her out to be a laughing stock on ITV news.Aug 10, 21:28
    • sam on The Last Marble: “For Liberate Scotland?Aug 10, 21:23
    • sarah on The Last Marble: “It is especially galling given that every journalist in Scotland knows what really happened, including the un-reported defence evidence that…Aug 10, 21:21
    • Iain More on The Last Marble: “I see the Alphabet Wokist Quisling Sturgeon getting a lot of Media time on ITV. Nauseating! Disgusting! Stomach Churning!Aug 10, 21:06
    • sarah on The Last Marble: “I agree, sam. It is amusing [sort of] and punchy – a very clear illustration of Scotland’s [and Wales and…Aug 10, 20:37
    • sam on The Last Marble: “Off topic. My missus received this link and we watched it. It is a short video on the Free Scotland…Aug 10, 19:53
    • Izzie on The Last Marble: “Can anyone enlighten me as to how this advances the cause of a free and independent Scotland?Aug 10, 18:53
    • Lorn on Snowflake Patrol: “No, James, I know you did not say that Scotland was subsumed. Professor Black said that recently. I agree that…Aug 10, 18:17
    • Lorn on Snowflake Patrol: “Correct, James. They just banked on no one up here knowing that or, failing that, not caring.Aug 10, 17:53
    • TURABDIN on The Last Marble: “A REVIEW «An amazing achievement. Nicola Sturgeon manages to write dispassionately about her life’s passion, and mindfully about experiences that…Aug 10, 16:47
    • Hatey McHateface on The Last Marble: “Discountable. Remainderable. Pulpable. Recyclable. You overlooked these, TURABDIN. Frankly, somebody’s made a big mistake. The only hope for decent sales…Aug 10, 16:05
    • Iain More on The Last Marble: “Callum says: 10 August, 2025 at 8:30 am Sturgeon and her coterie of sycophants deliberately tried to put an innocent…Aug 10, 15:53
    • sam on The Last Marble: “Doon the stank? Broomielaw?Aug 10, 15:52
    • Hatey McHateface on Snowflake Patrol: “The sound of one hand clapping.Aug 10, 15:52
    • James Barr Gardner on The Last Marble: “Wee Johnny’s lost his jaurie……..Aug 10, 14:59
    • James Cheyne on Snowflake Patrol: “At the moment only one bank benefits from being the bank of England, just as the benefits of being the…Aug 10, 14:28
    • James Cheyne on Snowflake Patrol: “TURABDIN, However, I agree with you that Scotland often seems to be the brains in general, while Certain parts of…Aug 10, 14:14
    • TURABDIN on The Last Marble: “«SUCCESSFUL, REMARKABLE, great skill, unflinching honesty. triumph, truly searching, truly frank, compelling, clear-eyed, self-critical , riveting, deeply human, enlightened, enthralled.…Aug 10, 14:14
    • James Cheyne on Snowflake Patrol: “TURABDIN. The bank of England had stronger connections to the East India Company first. And for all that is still…Aug 10, 14:08
    • Mark Beggan on The Last Marble: “Frankly my dear I don’t give a dam. By Virago CurmudgeonAug 10, 13:25
    • Northcode on The Last Marble: “Sturgeon – no, not that one, this one; Theodore Sturgeon (1918-1985) was an American writer, mostly of fantasy and science…Aug 10, 13:07
    • TURABDIN on Snowflake Patrol: “WHAT SCOTS DO FOR OTHERS, «William Paterson was a Scottish trader and banker. He was a founding member of the…Aug 10, 12:59
    • Confused on The Last Marble: “this is unintentionally funny in all the wrong places https://archive.ph/XOZ9e – also, oddly revealing, in a between the lines sort-of-way…Aug 10, 12:40
    • Sven on The Last Marble: “Oneliner @ 11.25. Well, I’ve long thought her a bit of a (pantomime) horse’s ass.Aug 10, 12:25
    • James on Snowflake Patrol: “Probably got a job with “Aidan” and the 77th in “Fifeshire”.Aug 10, 11:58
    • James on Snowflake Patrol: “Three in a row – Bingo!Aug 10, 11:56
    • James on Snowflake Patrol: “Aye, they Yoons don’t like it up ’em!Aug 10, 11:55
  • A tall tale



↑ Top