The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


The invisible bogeyman

Posted on November 09, 2011 by

Ever since the SNP's victory in May, Unionist politicians of all flavours have been going on and on about making "the positive case for the Union", a thing which apparently exists but which none of them have as yet been able to actually define. The only specific example of this positive case so far has come from the new Scottish Conservative leader Ruth Davidson, who pointed out that being in the Union enabled us to enjoy the performances of the GB team at the Olympics.

(An event which has directly sucked money out of Scotland and down to London, and which mystifyingly enjoys a different tax status to the forthcoming 2014 Commonwealth Games in Glasgow, which our sources tell us is in Scotland.)

Over on Better Nation, though, Labour activist Aidan Skinner (one of the few who seems to have any grasp of the scale and nature of the party in Scotland's predicament) has had a stab at it. Apparently the "coherent and convincing" case for the Union is that it enhances Scotland's "shared defence and commercial interests".

Further details are unforthcoming in the piece, however, which raises more questions than it answers. It doesn't explain, for example, how Scotland's interests are served by years of UK government underspending on defence in Scotland (as identified by Professor Andrew Hughes Hallett), the siting in Scotland of nuclear weapons which are overwhelmingly opposed by the Scottish electorate, or UK foreign policy which makes the entire UK at greater risk of terrorist attack. Nor, oddly, is any nation state which poses a military threat to Scotland identified.

Similarly, the single sentence devoted to this "coherent and convincing case" neglects to clarify any specific instances of Westminster control of Scotland's economy bringing commercial benefits. We're sure there are many, though, and look forward to reading them when the No campaign finally gets round to publishing "The Positive Case For The Union" through Her Majesty's Stationery Office, which we're currently expecting some time around 2017.

3 to “The invisible bogeyman”

  1. Aidan Skinner says:

    Further details are unforthcoming in the piece, 

    Because that piece isn't intended as a grand defence of the union. It's about why there isn't a single, coordinated Unionist bloc for the serried ranks of Nationalists to clash with on the field of open battle. 

    Reply
  2. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    "It's about why there isn't a single, coordinated Unionist bloc for the serried ranks of Nationalists to clash with on the field of open battle."

    Given that the field of battle is whether Scotland stays in the Union or not, perhaps you ought to get your ranks into some sort of order, then. Because whether you like it or not, in a single-issue vote if you're against independence then you ARE all on the same side, no matter whether you argue about economics among yourselves or not.

    Reply
  3. BillyT says:

    I see currency guy is still backing Torrence, AKA, Judge Dan Francisco. His dad cannot be Frank!!

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,803 Posts, 1,224,136 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Lorn on The Envious Heart: “Indeed, Marie. Moira and the rest of his family have maintained a dignified silence that speaks volumes.Aug 14, 19:32
    • Nae Need! on The Envious Heart: “AnneMarie Ward writes a piece today that, I feel, reads very well alongside Stu’s excellent article. Both articles are about…Aug 14, 19:30
    • agent x on The Envious Heart: ““Dan says: 14 August, 2025 at 6:32 pm Okay, rather evasive response there. So if you think here shouldn’t be…Aug 14, 19:11
    • BigJay on The Envious Heart: ““Dan says @ 6:32 pm 14 August, 2025: Okay, rather evasive response there. So if you think here shouldn’t be…Aug 14, 19:06
    • Dan on The Envious Heart: “TestAug 14, 18:44
    • Dan on The Envious Heart: “Hmm, who to believe… Part of the political class that the public don’t have trust in churning out endless often…Aug 14, 18:43
    • Callum on The Envious Heart: “Brilliantly put.Aug 14, 18:39
    • Dan on The Envious Heart: “Okay, rather evasive response there. So if you think here shouldn’t be any malicious prosecutions, what’s your views on why…Aug 14, 18:32
    • Hatey McHateface on The Envious Heart: “Calm doon TH. Scotland has not been destroyed. It would be nice to think that the trusting gullibility of many…Aug 14, 18:24
    • agent x on The Envious Heart: “Money!Aug 14, 18:23
    • agent x on The Envious Heart: “Maybe some of you did but I never voted for Sturgeon/SNP.Aug 14, 18:21
    • Mark Beggan on The Envious Heart: “On a lighter note. Scotlands financial black hole is so big that Star Trek Voyager has been sighted over Leith.Aug 14, 18:18
    • Hatey McHateface on The Envious Heart: ““the Scottish Government’s Cabinet consists of a majority of women” Do they actually make that claim using these words? If…Aug 14, 18:16
    • twathater on The Envious Heart: “To think that we elected this psychotic self obsessed narcissist to destroy our beautiful country and cause such division with…Aug 14, 18:12
    • MaryB on The Envious Heart: “Nicola would be remembered here with more respect if she’d gone quietly. Or, at least, written a respectful memoir. But…Aug 14, 18:10
    • GM on The Envious Heart: “You missed oot a court case.Aug 14, 18:04
    • agent x on The Envious Heart: “Wholeheartedly agree – it has done her no good whatsoever.Aug 14, 18:01
    • agent x on The Envious Heart: “” Dan says: Can you elucidate a bit more on the subject, seeing as it’s clear there have been prosecutions…Aug 14, 17:59
    • agent x on The Envious Heart: “They will stop very very soon. Of course she will then have panic attacks, bouts of self doubt and depression,…Aug 14, 17:50
    • Mark Beggan on The Envious Heart: “I don’t know who’s selling them but hats off. £20 a wip probably cost a 50 pence each. The Lefty’s…Aug 14, 17:48
    • Dan on The Envious Heart: “That’s a quick* and short response. Can you elucidate a bit more on the subject, seeing as it’s clear there…Aug 14, 17:42
    • agent x on The Envious Heart: ““Dan says: What’s your views on it?” ————————————- Simple – I don’t think there should be any malicious prosecutions.Aug 14, 17:22
    • diabloandco on The Envious Heart: “How many ruddy programmes and media comments is this effin’ book going to get ? Are there still those starstruck…Aug 14, 17:16
    • Callum on The Envious Heart: “Frankly has been a disaster for Sturgeon. Friends and foes are disgusted by its contents.Aug 14, 17:15
    • agent x on The Envious Heart: “Is it The National that are selling them?Aug 14, 17:11
    • agent x on The Envious Heart: “” Wark claimed there had “almost been a thread of coercive control” from Salmond running through the book which she…Aug 14, 17:10
    • Dan on The Envious Heart: “It may not be mentioned in Sturgeon’s book, but it’s been mentioned several times before. EG. https://wingsoverscotland.com/the-innocent/#comment-2852325 What’s your views…Aug 14, 17:06
    • Frank Gillougley on The Envious Heart: “Heres the probable truth of the whole matter: Anthony Clare (r.i.p.): And so Nicola, what can you tell me about…Aug 14, 16:52
    • agent x on The Envious Heart: ““Rangers malicious prosecution payouts could top £60 million” Any comment/mention of this?Aug 14, 16:51
    • Mark Beggan on The Envious Heart: “Wish I had thought of that. What a money maker. There’s one born everyday. £££££££Aug 14, 16:45
  • A tall tale



↑ Top