The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


First Minister’s Questions, 24-11-11

Posted on November 24, 2011 by

Holyrood witnessed an exceptionally dismaying FMQs this week, with all three opposition leaders embarrassing themselves to varying degrees. Iain Gray once again wasted his entire allotted time on pointlessly demanding a precise date for the independence referendum, which is still some three or more years distant. The First Minister's replies could have been provided by a tape recording and accurately predicted in advance by a primary-school child or an Old Firm supporter, and Gray was further humiliated by some stinging quotes from prominent Labour figures, including one previously highlighted by this very blog.

The Labour leader also came disturbingly close to an outright lie, in misrepresenting the views of the Parliament's former Presiding Officer George Reid by claiming that Mr Reid wanted the referendum supervised by the Electoral Commission. This was despite Mr Reid making his (somewhat different) actual position painstakingly clear in the Scotsman's letters page on the very same day.

But the real clanger was dropped by the new Tory leader Ruth Davidson, who castigated the Scottish Government for dropping legislation aimed at preventing the reduction of minimum sentences, affecting (among others) rape cases. The First Minister gently informed Ms Davidson that she had been misinformed by her researchers, pointing out that the legislation was in fact going ahead and would be brought before Parliament by the end of this month. Davidson sailed straight over the correction without a suggestion of retraction or apology, and went on to make an impenetrable point about demanding life sentences without possibility of parole for certain serious offences – seemingly asking the Parliament to do so regardless of the restrictions placed on such actions by the European Convention of Human Rights.

For the Lib Dems, Willie Rennie went for a worthless point aimed at the tabloid "Our Brave Boys" audience, demanding to know if Scottish soldiers serving in the British Army would be forced to resign and join a Scottish Army in the event of independence. Once again, an opposition leader could think of no more pressing concerns facing Scotland in 2011 than a trivial and hypothetical issue from a hypothetical future, many years away from anyone needing to worry about it.

Even when given a clear and direct answer from the FM – that no, soldiers would not be forced to do such a thing and would be free to choose which army they wished to serve in – Rennie persisted in some aimless rhetoric about soldiers currently fighting side-by-side somehow being pitched against each other and made to "choose between their colleagues and their country". Salmond slapped the line of attack down uncompromisingly with a retort about coalition-imposed redundancies among serving forces and election results in constituencies with military bases, and that was that.

First Minister's Questions is theatre, but it's nonetheless depressing to see all three opposition leaders so ham-fistedly squandering their main opportunity to hold the government publicly to account, something vital to any functioning democracy. Salmond can occasionally be made to look evasive and blustery at FMQs, but he didn't have to get out of second gear to crush his opponents today. He could have phoned it in, and that's no fit state for any self-respecting Parliament.

5 to “First Minister’s Questions, 24-11-11”

  1. Rolf says:

    Great summation. Surely even Labour Party members must have despaired today when Iain 'Groundhog Day' Gray asked about the referendum timing. 
    Someone posted on Twitter that he's probably just repeating this nonsense as it's bound to get re-played all across BBC Scotland's news output. "Ian Gray today demanded that Alex Salmond stops dithering and names a date for his fixed separation referendum, the uncertainty around which is harming the UK economy" etc, etc, ad nauseum.

    Reply
  2. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    I'm surprised "Groundhog Gray" hasn't caught on as a name. Bit late now, I suppose.

    Reply
  3. An Duine Gruamach says:

    Yep, too late now.  He's Yestergray's man.

    Reply
  4. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    Indeed. Soon he will no longer be one of the Grays of our lives.

    Reply
  5. An Duine Gruamach says:

    Even the Graytest leaders fall in the end, I suppose.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,787 Posts, 1,222,057 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Aidan on According As We Need Them: “Food for thought – no it isn’tJul 16, 11:13
    • Andrew scott on According As We Need Them: “O/t Nurse Peggie cleared by nhs fife Now the sparks will fly -hopefully upton, gray and the board are SACKEDJul 16, 10:39
    • Oneliner on According As We Need Them: “Yep 16,000 is a good number considering MI5 isn’t a political partyJul 16, 10:38
    • James Cheyne on According As We Need Them: “I think most of Scots in more recent times recognise that the EU is one of the biggest perponents of…Jul 16, 10:06
    • Northcode on According As We Need Them: “I’m reconsidering my use of the term ‘unionist’ to describe… well, to describe unionists. I’m reconsidering my use of the…Jul 16, 10:00
    • James Cheyne on According As We Need Them: “Food for thought, Scotland is registered as a Country in the UN surprisingly just like England, by England although treated…Jul 16, 09:56
    • sam on According As We Need Them: “It is certainly possible for people to take an entirely different view from that of Aiden regarding the ICCPR and…Jul 16, 09:42
    • sam on According As We Need Them: “There is nothing at all in the links you gave to refute or undermine the research done by Professors Walsh…Jul 16, 09:04
    • Aidan on According As We Need Them: “Not to defend Angus Robertson, but the 20,000 people signing the Liberation petition doesn’t compare all that favourable to the…Jul 16, 08:50
    • Sven on According As We Need Them: “Aidan @ 06.54 “People were dying in anticipation of cuts.” Gosh, how that one made me giggle this morning, thankyou,…Jul 16, 08:40
    • Oneliner on According As We Need Them: “Angus Robertson, while an MP, sat on the House Of Commons Defence Committee. Quite a position for one from a…Jul 16, 08:05
    • Aidan on According As We Need Them: “Sure – see Leah Gunn Barrett’s substack: https://dearscotland.substack.com/p/the-scottish-government-surrenders Secondly, Article 25 is the part you want to look at. https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/international-covenant-civil-and-political-rightsJul 16, 08:03
    • Aidan on According As We Need Them: “https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanepe/article/PIIS2666-7762(22)00130-2/fulltext https://lordslibrary.parliament.uk/mortality-rates-among-men-and-women-impact-of-austerity/ This is where is comes fromJul 16, 08:00
    • sam on According As We Need Them: “Any evidence for this assertion of yours regarding a backdoor route to circumvent the Supreme Court judgement? Would you also…Jul 16, 07:50
    • Northcode on According As We Need Them: “Thank you, Sarah. TH said this about your contributions to this place: “Your information is enlightening and relevant…” I agree.Jul 16, 07:41
    • sam on According As We Need Them: “I have no idea what you are talking about. Do you have a reference or link to the “paper” in…Jul 16, 07:30
    • Alf Baird on According As We Need Them: ““I don’t know how Angus Robertson can reasonably claime ICCPR is not needed in Scotland.” Aye Sam, Angus Robertson an…Jul 16, 07:10
    • Aidan on According As We Need Them: “We’ve been around the houses with this one before. Despite being published in the Lancet, it’s a pretty dubious paper.…Jul 16, 06:58
    • Aidan on According As We Need Them: “Re the last paragraph, Ewan Kennedy is flat out wrong. The petitioner does believe that implementing the ICPPR provides a…Jul 16, 06:44
    • sam on According As We Need Them: “One of the Rights under the ICCPR is the right to life which is a protection against arbitrary deprivation of…Jul 16, 06:33
    • twathater on According As We Need Them: “TBQH Sarah I would disregard ANYTHING that Bastard Tax MOAN and his wee Scotland Hating sidekicks like Aydun Corporal Batshit…Jul 16, 01:58
    • sarah on According As We Need Them: “@ Northcode: “mirkie watter”. I like it, Northcode. Your knowledge of poetic forms puts me to shame.Jul 15, 22:58
    • sam on According As We Need Them: “https://yougov.co.uk/politics/articles/52524-europeans-would-welcome-an-independent-scotland-into-the-eu “That Scotland may vote in a second independence referendum to leave the UK cannot be discounted, and Scottish nationalists…Jul 15, 21:43
    • sam on According As We Need Them: “The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) is a United Nations treaty that the UK has ratified (meaning…Jul 15, 21:38
    • Northcode on According As We Need Them: “Thanks, James. Here’s another: mirkie watter Rever stanes smuithed roond; shaped by watter no thair ain; drouned in silence, worn…Jul 15, 19:17
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: “Thanks for the info, Aidan. On the face of it then, it sounds like just another ruse by which the…Jul 15, 19:11
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: “Fair enough, sarah, I stand corrected. How about a link so we can all see what it’s about?Jul 15, 18:58
    • Captain Caveman on According As We Need Them: “@TwatByName You know what they say, “there’s no fool like an old fool”. Silly old sod. Take up bowls or…Jul 15, 18:56
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: “Sure, TH. I have little doubt that the humous boys will be hunted down to the ends of the earth…Jul 15, 18:54
    • Aidan on According As We Need Them: “I’ll save you the trouble, it’s another cunning plan which says that if the Scottish Government implemented the ICCPR, because…Jul 15, 18:34
  • A tall tale



↑ Top