The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Man tells truth, is made to apologise

Posted on November 19, 2010 by

Earlier this week we pointed out that for most people in Britain, the current economic crisis is in fact no such thing. If you're in the blessed section of what in modern times is an unprecedentedly polarised society, which is defined by home ownership – something the majority of adults are – then the chances are you're doing just fine out of the banking catastrophe of 2007-8.

So the widespread vilification of Lord Young of Graffham (above, centre) in this morning's press for accidentally saying out loud what most people already know to be perfectly true is a little… well, it's not surprising, exactly, but it's another nail in the tattered, sieve-like coffin of the concept of honesty between the people and their semi-elected leaders.

To get away with the ideological butchering of the public sector that they've always yearned for an excuse to embark wholeheartedly on, the Tories know that they have to maintain the public facade that they're not just victimising the poor, the unemployed and the sick, because "We're all in this together".

We are, of course, all in it together, in much the same sort way that the passengers and crew of the Titanic were. They were all – literally! – in the same boat, but there were lifeboats for lots of them, and it was only the working classes locked down in steerage who were inescapably doomed to end up in a cold and watery grave.

The vast majority of people in Britain of working age (over 70%) are employed. A very similar percentage (though of course not all the same people) are homeowners. And if you're a homeowner and you're working (and even the worst projections of the unemployment figures over the next few years show a relatively small number of people, as a proportion of the total, losing their jobs), you HAVE never had it so good.

Astonishingly low interest rates have probably put hundreds of extra pounds in your pocket every month from your mortgage payments, public-sector wage freezes (imposed on unions cowed by the spectre of redundancies) will drive down inflation to keep everything you buy nice and cheap, and you'll probably be able to wriggle out of even the cuts that do, at least in theory, affect you personally.

The reason the Prime Minister was so quick to deliver a public smackdown to Lord Young was that he'd let the cat out of the bag. The Tory voters of Middle England are not to suffer in this scorched-earth slash-and-burn, but it must appear that they are. It must be made to look like, in Chancellor George Osborne's words, "those with the broadest shoulders should bear the greatest burden" even though the reverse is true.

So a forgetful old man speaking carelessly at a fancy dinner where he thought himself safely surrounded by friends has been offered up as a whipping boy. Lord Young of Graffham has already prostrated himself before the nation, offering the profound and heartfelt apologies of a penitent sinner for the crime of telling the truth. But let's be sure we know who it is he's actually apologising to. Here's a clue: it's not us.

3 to “Man tells truth, is made to apologise”

  1. Steve Smith says:

    It's also another example of the media concentrating on sensationalism and stirring up emotions rather than reporting news.  Is an advisor's comment really that important in the grand scheme of things?  No.  Are there more important things happening in the world?   Yes.

    Reply
  2. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    That would be a hard position for the UK media to hold after Wills And Kate Week.

    Reply
  3. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    Update: he's now resigned. Truth-telling BASTARD!

    link to bbc.co.uk

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,731 Posts, 1,215,562 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Mark Beggan on The Groomer’s Shield: “This all stems from wee Cranky trying to stuff big ideas into a very small brain. Then trying to implement…Apr 14, 18:49
    • Dan on The Groomer’s Shield: “Just for clarity and possibly a wee chuckle at mention of folk sucking on public tit… Are you the (albeit…Apr 14, 18:47
    • Yoon Scum on The Groomer’s Shield: “I love how you have total and utter faith in people who don’t exist in the world of politics to…Apr 14, 18:41
    • Mark Beggan on The Groomer’s Shield: “What sort of conspiracy is going on here? Why is LGBTQ allowed free range on children.Apr 14, 18:21
    • sarah on The Groomer’s Shield: “Lorn, I do know what is going on in other countries – not only Ireland but also New Zealand, Australia…Apr 14, 18:13
    • Willie on The Groomer’s Shield: “Just another example of the filthy rotten governance of Scotland.Apr 14, 18:11
    • Karen on The Groomer’s Shield: “Theo ‘Beth’ Upton of the Peggie tribunal case: Dad Jeremy, head curator at Edinburgh Uni, boss of Mr Buttars of…Apr 14, 18:05
    • Lorn on The Groomer’s Shield: “Sarah: I have wanted independence since I was a wee girl, have never wavered till now. I still want it…Apr 14, 17:50
    • Yoon Scum on The Groomer’s Shield: “When the UN step in and send the troops in to remove the unionist scum from our capital Who do…Apr 14, 17:47
    • Mark Beggan on The Groomer’s Shield: “With respect these people are exposed. Everyone is aware.Apr 14, 17:43
    • Hatey McHateface on The Groomer’s Shield: “6. Get all of these organisations, umbrella groups, campaigns and pressure groups you list to sign up to an unequivocal…Apr 14, 17:37
    • Lorn on The Groomer’s Shield: “Oh, you think?Apr 14, 17:31
    • Hatey McHateface on SNP 2025 Update: “Here you go, Geri. The photos of 22 blown to bits on this link. Take your time and have a…Apr 14, 17:29
    • Lorn on The Groomer’s Shield: “About 98%, if all charities follow the same pattern – that, and lobbying.Apr 14, 17:29
    • sarah on The Groomer’s Shield: “@ Lorn at 4.33: “Absolutely no point in being independent if this is how an independent Scotland is going to…Apr 14, 17:20
    • Morgatron on The Groomer’s Shield: “Thanks Stu for all your hard work and endeavour with this. Shocking but alas not surprising.Apr 14, 17:19
    • Lewis Moonie on The Groomer’s Shield: “Another wanker sucking at the public tit.Apr 14, 17:16
    • Hatey McHateface on SNP 2025 Update: “Fa’s this current genocide than? And how come raisins are being left alone? Can they afford to be unconcerned? Do…Apr 14, 17:15
    • TenaciousV on The Groomer’s Shield: “If I were to ask my MSP to get me this information could theyrefuse her I wonder?Apr 14, 17:13
    • Hatey McHateface on The Groomer’s Shield: ““Your Honour, the People of Scotland have reached their verdicts and find as follows on the charges. Too wee: Not…Apr 14, 17:02
    • twathater on The Groomer’s Shield: “I commend you and thank you for your unwavering commitment to EXPOSE the vile and depraved actions these perverts and…Apr 14, 16:57
    • Yoon Scum on The Groomer’s Shield: “It’s slightly worse then that As the charities rely on government funding AND It is made perfectly clear to them…Apr 14, 16:44
    • Antoine Roquentin on The Groomer’s Shield: “What a dangerous wee country, we all call home.Apr 14, 16:37
    • Yoon Scum on The Groomer’s Shield: “Same here I won’t just the SNP to tie shoelaces If only for the fact they’d probably nick them And…Apr 14, 16:35
    • Lorn on The Groomer’s Shield: “Thank you, thank you, Rev. Have been saying this for so long. Absolutely no point in independence if this is…Apr 14, 16:33
    • Yoon Scum on The Groomer’s Shield: “Scottish nationalist problem solving Step 1 – Identify problem Step 2 – leave the union Step 3 – magic happens…Apr 14, 16:29
    • Geri on The Groomer’s Shield: “A parliament oath/ constitution for a start. Remember, no one voted for this bullshit. It was just inflicted onto every…Apr 14, 16:27
    • Eddie Munster on The Groomer’s Shield: “If you need the threat of hell and eternal damnation to keep in line, then you are not a good…Apr 14, 16:26
    • joolz on The Groomer’s Shield: “Campaigning for independence means ensuring that we have a government that we would trust to negotiate a settlement with Westminster.…Apr 14, 16:21
    • sarah on The Groomer’s Shield: “Oh my goodness. Is this too much of a coincidence? Well done AnonfaeFifefor digging this nugget out. As Alex Salmond…Apr 14, 16:21
  • A tall tale



↑ Top