The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


What you can do for your country

Posted on April 22, 2010 by

Hang on. Is this classic reverse psychology? Does the Daily Mail actually WANT a hung parliament, for doubtless sinister reasons of its own?

Because it's hard to imagine that a major British newspaper could be edited by anyone SO stupid as to think this absurd, hysterical rubbish (based on an out-of-context quote EIGHT years old) could do anything but strengthen the feelings of anyone who's sick of the old Labour-Tory carve-up of this country. So let's help them, eh?

HangBritain.org is the latest of many websites that have popped up in recent days enthusiastically supporting the notion of a hung (or "balanced") parliament as a means to achieve electoral reform in the UK, to the point where we have something we can describe without shame as a "democracy".

On its site you can enter your postcode and find out how you can cast your vote so as to best contribute to a hung parliament. The organisation's theory is that in "safe" seats you should vote for the incumbent, so as not to risk those seats being lost and unexpectedly contributing to a "back door" majority for the other party, and in seats where a smaller party has a chance you should vote for them.

Now, personally I have some reservations about this policy. The Lib Dems' mandate for electoral reform will rest as much on the number of votes they get as the number of seats – in fact, the bigger the discrepancy between the two, the stronger their case. So even in seats where they have no hope of winning, voting for them has a meaningful purpose.

Indeed, any vote which isn't for Labour or the Tories also adds to the effect. If your constituency has a 20,000 majority and no realistic hope of a change in MP, even a vote for the Monster Raving Loonies is a vote cast that isn't for the big two, and that's much more valuable in terms of making the argument for reform. The lower the percentage of votes the big two get – regardless of the number of seats – the weaker their justification for opposing PR.

(And let's be clear – Brown's proposed move to Alternative Vote isn't just a weak, half-hearted attempt at the minimum reform he can get away with. Astonishingly, the Prime Minister thinks he can get away with electoral "reform" that will actually lead to power becoming even MORE consolidated in the big parties, not less.)

But tactics are a matter of opinion. What's important is the very existence of sites like HangBritain.org, which are sprouting up in response to the huge opportunity that's about to be handed to the British people. It's a signifier of what seems to be a real and powerful trend, which is gathering pace with every passing day, in the face of an increasingly panicked response from the establishment parties and media.

The electorate has had it up to here with "strong government" (a loaded term which would be more accurately, if less elegantly, described as "quasi-elected dictatorship"), as shown by the astonishingly off-message response of Daily Mail readers to the paper's attempt at doom-laden scaremongering. We'd like to try representative government for a change.

WoSblog isn't here to tell you who to vote for. But I'm happy to tell you who NOT to vote for. Next Thursday, PLEASE go out and vote. No matter how safe your seat is – no matter how little chance you have of changing your MP, no matter how pointless it seems – PLEASE get out and vote, for someone who ISN'T the Labour or Tory candidate. If you're in a safe seat it really doesn't matter who you pick, so let your conscience be your sole guide. But for the whole country's sake, if you're EVER going to vote, do it this time.

A hung parliament is tantalisingly within reach, but it's not a done deal yet. The latest polls show that Cameron could still achieve a majority while bypassing both Labour and the Lib Dems, by buying off the minor parties as Labour did with the Ulster Unionists in 2008 (to further erode our civil liberties by letting the government lock you up for six weeks without charge).

This is our chance. Don't leave it to everyone else – too much is at stake. Get out there and Hang Britain.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

3 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Hang politicians and the parliament

The newspapers seem to have gone bananas! Scaremongering and hysteria in overdrive. I was expecting them to try and attack him but this response is ridiculous.
 
Can it be any more transparent and predictable that the Murdoch mud-slinging machine is in action? More proof that the newspapers cannot be trusted, if anyone needed it.
 
link to img682.imageshack.us
 

Bill Hayes

We talked over this blog and your comments made and decided that it probably is a good idea to recommend smaller parties in safe seats, so that's what we've done. I don't know if it'll stay that way, safe seats are tricky things to work with. We'll see what users say.
Thanks for this post to promote our little site and thanks for taking the time to give us this valuable feedback. Very much appreciated.
And I want to second what you said about voting. Everyone, whether you listen to this blog or Hang Britain or anyone else just make sure you actually do vote. In a hung parliament every vote counts for something.

Hang politicians and the parliament

Mandelson, of all people, is condemning this: link to news.bbc.co.uk


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,672 Posts, 1,203,123 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • sarah on The Unbargain Bin: “1.7 million on the petition to call a General Election now because Labour aren’t honouring their promises. That is almost…Nov 24, 22:47
    • sarah on The Unbargain Bin: “Indeed. If only we had direct democracy as Scotland did pre-1707 and as Switzerland now has. That petition is now…Nov 24, 22:12
    • Robert Hughes on The Unbargain Bin: “or Francis Bacon . I can imagine a ” Screaming ” Swinney .Nov 24, 21:50
    • Tinto Chiel on The Unbargain Bin: “It’s not just here, it’s also in the sump which is the House of Commons. In fact, the whole political…Nov 24, 21:19
    • Southernbystander on The Unbargain Bin: “This all seems a bit confused as the ‘official’ line is he left because of the sale of the Observer…Nov 24, 21:05
    • sarah on The Unbargain Bin: “Apparently it is well known to insiders – presumably that includes the press – that Holyrood is a sink of…Nov 24, 20:40
    • sarah on The Unbargain Bin: “1,509, no 1,510, 853. Amazing. How embarrassing for Starmer if it reaches millions and the press/tv report it…Nov 24, 20:31
    • James Gardner on The Unbargain Bin: “Actors telling Jackanory stories, more the fool the folk ….Nov 24, 20:25
    • Tinto Chiel on The Unbargain Bin: “Yes, sarah, I reckon any Hieronymus Bosch painting could depict Holyrood quite accurately 🙂 .Nov 24, 20:15
    • sarah on The Unbargain Bin: “Signed, Mia – thanks for the nudge. Now at 1,457,846.Nov 24, 20:00
    • sarah on The Unbargain Bin: ““Politics is showbiz for ugly people”, someone said. It seems to be true – they are acting a part, not…Nov 24, 19:53
    • sarah on The Unbargain Bin: “Slater’s “Message in a bottle” – brilliant!Nov 24, 19:49
    • Alf Baird on The Unbargain Bin: “Cartoon well reflects that, according to Frantz Fanon, ‘politicians are not intellectuals’; hence anything they write needs to be considered…Nov 24, 19:43
    • Nae Need! on The Unbargain Bin: “‘The Flattery of Seafood Plattery: Scotland’s No1 Thing’ by The Wannabe.Nov 24, 19:31
    • Robert Hughes on The Unbargain Bin: “Aye , T , it’s obvious that the general public’s opinion of Politicians has never been lower – and for…Nov 24, 19:23
    • Pipinghot on The Unbargain Bin: “Party on. It’s what they deserve.Nov 24, 19:15
    • James Gardner on The Unbargain Bin: “Stephen Flynn….well, I used to be conceited, but now I’m absolutely perfect.Nov 24, 19:12
    • Mia on The Unbargain Bin: ““t’s only monarchists who retain the right to a say over Scotland’s Stone Of Destiny” Since when, and by whose…Nov 24, 19:04
    • Tinto Chiel on The Unbargain Bin: “Eminently sensible, Dan, but as twathater and Robert H. have said, the SNP seems to wish to fracture the independence…Nov 24, 18:52
    • Nae Need! on The Unbargain Bin: “You’re actually awrite when you get let off the leash.Nov 24, 18:45
    • robertkknight on The Unbargain Bin: ““Beginners Guide to Hot Air Ballooning’ by I BlackfordNov 24, 18:37
    • robertkknight on The Unbargain Bin: ““The Road to Perdition” by L LloydNov 24, 18:35
    • robertkknight on The Unbargain Bin: ““The Art of Infiltration” by M FooteNov 24, 18:34
    • robertkknight on The Unbargain Bin: ““Secrets and Lies” by A S C RobertsonNov 24, 18:32
    • robertkknight on The Unbargain Bin: ““Downfall” by P T MurrellNov 24, 18:31
    • robertkknight on The Unbargain Bin: ““Hiding in Plain Sight” by J R SwinneyNov 24, 18:30
    • sarah on The Unbargain Bin: “Good idea, Dan. I hope the Rev is working very hard on all and every route to improving our chances…Nov 24, 18:29
    • robertkknight on The Unbargain Bin: ““My Struggle” by N F SturgeonNov 24, 18:29
    • Hatey McHateface on The Unbargain Bin: “Have it your way then, Mia, we’re doomed by the US deep state. Logically though, if SNP voters can’t be…Nov 24, 18:24
    • sarah on The Unbargain Bin: “‘Tis true, ’tis true ’tis pity, and pity ’tis, ’tis true. How is it that Holyrood’s standard of representative has…Nov 24, 18:18
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
212
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x